A smoker can add a wood-fired aroma to an Old Fashioned without changing the drink’s basic recipe. The best choice depends on whether you want a complete bar set, a traditional torch-powered smoker, or a flame-free electric design. Below, we compare five options by their included accessories, wood-chip selection, setup, and practical trade-offs.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Power style | Notable features | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| ComboJoy Whiskey Smoker Kit | Torch-powered | Six wood-chip varieties, two glasses, ice-ball molds | A ready-to-gift bar set |
| Aumpkin Cocktail Smoker Kit | Torch-powered | Six wood-chip varieties, stone ice cubes, tools and brush | A versatile accessory-packed kit |
| Smokpub Electric Whiskey Smoker | Rechargeable electric | USB charging, six wood-chip varieties, magnetic safety cover | People who want to avoid filling a butane torch |
| Yecuip Whiskey Smoker Kit | Torch-powered | Wine-barrel-inspired design, eight wood-chip flavors | A distinctive-looking gift set |
| Smlpuame Cocktail Smoker Kit | Manual smoker top | Cherry-wood body, four wood-chip varieties, replaceable filters | A simple smoker with a focused set of supplies |
Our Picks: Best Smoker For Old Fashioned Drinks reviews
ComboJoy Whiskey Smoker Kit: Best Complete Gift Set
The ComboJoy kit combines a wooden smoker top with useful bar accessories, making it a good fit if you’re building out a home cocktail setup or choosing a gift. It includes six wood-chip varieties, two glasses, two ice-ball molds, a metal filter, and a torch. The included glasses mean you can try the smoker without first shopping for matching drinkware.
The wood chips are intended to create cold smoke that adds aroma to cocktails and other foods. For an Old Fashioned, you can place the smoker on a suitable glass, light the chips, and let the smoke infuse the drink. The kit can also be used with items such as cheese or meat, though its main appeal is the cocktail setup.
One important setup detail: the torch ships without butane and must be filled before use. The product information also notes that the torch may need adjustment at its base after filling. That extra step is worth considering if you want a kit that works straight out of the box.
Pros:
- Includes two glasses and two ice-ball molds, along with the smoker accessories.
- Offers six wood-chip varieties for trying different smoke aromas.
- Designed for both drinks and foods.
- Presented as a gift-ready set.
Cons:
- Butane is not included, so the torch needs preparation before first use.
- The torch may require adjustment if it does not ignite after filling.
Verdict: Choose ComboJoy if you want an all-in-one gift set with glasses and ice molds; look elsewhere if you prefer not to handle a butane torch.
Aumpkin Cocktail Smoker Kit: Best for Bar Accessories
Aumpkin’s kit brings together a wooden smoker with a lid and a range of small cocktail tools. The listed contents include a refillable triple-flame torch, six wood-chip flavors, stone ice cubes, two metal filters, a cleaning brush, an ice-ball mold, a spoon, and pliers. That accessory mix makes it more than a basic smoker top.
To use it, you add chips to the smoker, ignite them with the torch, and let the smoke reach the drink. The kit is also described for use with foods such as cheese, dried fruit, and meat. If you enjoy experimenting beyond an Old Fashioned, that extra flexibility may be useful.
As with other torch-powered options here, butane is not included. You’ll need to fill the torch before using it, and the product notes that the flame adjustment may need attention on first use. The many included pieces also mean there is more to store and keep together than with a simpler smoker.
Pros:
- Includes a torch, cleaning brush, filters, spoon, and pliers.
- Comes with six wood-chip varieties and two types of ice accessories.
- Wooden smoker has a lid.
- Designed for cocktails as well as some foods.
Cons:
- Butane must be purchased separately.
- The extra accessories take up more storage space than a basic smoker top.
Verdict: Aumpkin is a strong option if you want several cocktail tools in one package and don’t mind filling a torch or storing a larger set.
Smokpub Electric Whiskey Smoker: Best Butane-Free Setup
The Smokpub takes a different approach from the torch-powered kits: it uses a rechargeable electric ignition system, so it does not need butane. The product details say it charges by USB and can provide up to 130 ignitions per full charge. Its magnetic safety cover is designed to extinguish the flame when opened.
It includes six wood-chip varieties: oak, apple, hickory, cherry, pear, and beech. The maker describes the smoker as fitting a range of glass sizes and says it can be used with drinks such as whiskey and coffee, as well as food. The button-based operation may appeal if you want to avoid refilling and adjusting a small torch.
This design still relies on burning wood chips, so it is not smoke-free; the electric feature replaces the butane torch rather than the smoke itself. You’ll also need to charge the device, and the listed package does not include the broader bar accessories found in some other kits. The product information describes the ignition sequence, so it’s worth following those instructions closely.
Pros:
- Electric ignition avoids the need to buy or refill butane.
- USB-rechargeable design is described as providing up to 130 ignitions per full charge.
- Includes six wood-chip varieties.
- Magnetic cover is designed to extinguish the flame when opened.
Cons:
- Needs charging before use.
- Includes fewer drink-making accessories than the larger torch-powered kits.
Verdict: Pick the Smokpub if avoiding butane is your main priority; choose a more accessory-rich kit if you want glasses, ice molds, or extra bar tools included.
Yecuip Whiskey Smoker Kit: Best Barrel-Inspired Design
Yecuip gives its smoker a wine-barrel-inspired look, a design detail that may suit a rustic home bar or a gift display. The kit includes a torch, a stainless-steel filter, and eight wood-chip flavors according to the product description. That is the widest stated chip selection among the five options in this comparison.
The smoker is described as fitting most cups and as suitable for cocktails and other uses, including coffee and seafood. For an Old Fashioned, the basic appeal is straightforward: add wood-chip smoke to the glass and drink for a more aromatic presentation. The included filter helps keep chips out of the drink.
The torch is shipped without butane, so you’ll need to fill it before using the kit. The product also advises keeping each ignition brief and allowing the torch to cool between uses. Unlike the most complete kits here, the listed contents do not include glasses or ice molds, so you’ll need your own drinkware and ice setup.
Pros:
- Includes eight wood-chip flavors.
- Barrel-inspired design offers a distinctive look.
- Includes a torch and stainless-steel filter.
- Described for use with drinks and some foods.
Cons:
- Butane is not included.
- Glasses and ice molds are not listed among the included items.
Verdict: Yecuip suits shoppers who value a distinctive design and a broad choice of wood chips, provided they already have drinkware and are comfortable preparing a butane torch.
Smlpuame Cocktail Smoker Kit: Best Simple Smoker Top
The Smlpuame kit centers on a natural cherry-wood smoker with an enlarged chimney. Its listed contents include four wood-chip varieties—apple, cherry, pecan, and oak—plus a cleaning brush and ten replaceable filters. The product information emphasizes the chimney design as a way to direct smoke into a glass.
This is a more focused option than the sets that bundle glasses, ice molds, or several bar tools. It may make sense if you already own a torch and cocktail accessories and mainly want a smoker top with chips and replacement filters. The product description does not list a torch, so check the package details before buying if you need an ignition source included.
The smoker is described for drinks and foods, including bourbon, cocktails, cheese, desserts, and meats. Its smaller accessory selection keeps the kit straightforward, but it also means fewer extras for someone starting a home bar from scratch.
Pros:
- Cherry-wood smoker has an enlarged chimney design.
- Includes four wood-chip varieties and ten replaceable filters.
- Cleaning brush is included.
- Described for use with drinks and a range of foods.
Cons:
- A torch is not listed in the included contents.
- Does not include glasses or ice molds.
Verdict: Choose Smlpuame if you want a simple smoker top and already have an ignition source; for a more complete starter set, consider ComboJoy or Aumpkin.
How to Choose a Smoker for Old Fashioned Drinks
Choose the ignition style that suits you
Most of these kits use a torch to light the wood chips. That setup is direct, but the torches in the ComboJoy, Aumpkin, and Yecuip kits ship without butane, so you’ll need to fill them before first use. The Smokpub uses rechargeable electric ignition instead, which avoids butane but requires charging. The Smlpuame package does not list a torch, so confirm what you already have before choosing it.
Look at the included accessories
A smoker top and wood chips may be enough if your bar is already equipped. If you’re starting from scratch or buying a gift, accessories can add value: ComboJoy includes two glasses and ice-ball molds, while Aumpkin lists a spoon, pliers, filters, a brush, stone ice cubes, and an ice-ball mold. Yecuip includes a torch and filter, and Smlpuame includes a brush and replacement filters. Compare the specific pieces you’ll use rather than choosing by package size alone.
Consider wood-chip variety and your flavor preferences
The kits offer different selections: four varieties with Smlpuame, six with ComboJoy, Aumpkin, and Smokpub, and eight with Yecuip. More varieties give you more options to explore, but they don’t guarantee that every flavor will suit your drink. If you have a preferred wood aroma, check whether it appears in the listed selection before buying.
Check the fit with your glassware
A smoker needs to sit securely over the glass while smoke collects. Yecuip says its design fits most cups, and Smokpub describes its smoker as fitting a range of glass sizes. For other models, the supplied product details don’t specify a range of glass dimensions. If your favorite Old Fashioned glass is especially wide or unusually shaped, check the product listing for fit details before ordering.
Think about storage and portability
A set with a torch, molds, glasses, and several tools can be convenient, but it needs more storage space. A more focused smoker kit may be easier to put away, though it may not include everything you need. If you plan to take the smoker outdoors, consider how you’ll carry the pieces and handle the torch or electric device safely.
Use the smoker with care
These kits involve smoke and, in most cases, an open flame or hot ignition source. Follow the maker’s instructions, keep the flame away from children, and use the device on a stable surface. If your kit uses a butane torch, remember that fuel is not included in the listed torch-powered sets. The Yecuip product information also advises limiting ignition time and allowing the torch to cool between uses.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a smoker add to an Old Fashioned?
A cocktail smoker adds the aroma of burning wood chips to the drink. The smoke can change the way the drink smells and tastes, while also adding a visual flourish. The result depends on the wood chips, the amount of smoke, and your own preference.
Do these kits include butane?
No. The ComboJoy, Aumpkin, and Yecuip product descriptions say their torches ship without butane. You’ll need to fill those torches before using them. Smokpub uses rechargeable electric ignition instead, and Smlpuame does not list a torch among its included items.
Which option avoids a butane torch?
The Smokpub is the electric option in this comparison. Its product details describe USB charging and electric ignition. It still uses wood chips to produce smoke, so it avoids the butane torch rather than eliminating smoke or heat altogether.
Do I need special glasses for a cocktail smoker?
Not necessarily, but the smoker must fit securely over the glass. The Smokpub is described as fitting a range of glass sizes, and Yecuip says it fits most cups. For the other models, check the listing if you use wide or unusually shaped glassware.
Can I use a cocktail smoker for food?
The product descriptions for these kits also mention uses such as cheese, meat, coffee, or other foods, though the suggested uses vary. Follow the instructions for your specific smoker and use only suitable food-safe wood chips.
Which kit is best for a gift?
ComboJoy is a practical gift choice if you want glasses and ice-ball molds included. Aumpkin is another accessory-rich option, with tools such as a spoon, pliers, and cleaning brush. Yecuip may appeal if the barrel-inspired design and larger listed chip selection are the main draw.
Is a smoker top included with every kit?
The product descriptions list a wooden smoker or smoker top for ComboJoy, Aumpkin, Yecuip, and Smlpuame, and an electric smoker for Smokpub. Still, check the current product listing for the exact contents and any setup requirements before purchasing.
Final Recommendation
For a balanced starter or gift set, the ComboJoy kit stands out because it includes glasses and ice-ball molds as well as the smoker and wood chips. Aumpkin is a better fit if you want more small bar tools, while Smokpub is the clearest choice if you’d rather use rechargeable electric ignition than fill a butane torch. If you already own the necessary bar gear, Smlpuame offers a more focused smoker setup. Choose based on the accessories you’ll actually use and the ignition method you’re comfortable with.