The best baking sheet for an air fryer is one that fits your appliance without blocking airflow. The options below are conventional oven baking sheets, so check your air fryer’s usable tray or oven dimensions before ordering. Among them, the NutriChef set offers three pan sizes, the Farberware sheet has an insulated design, and the GoodCook sheet provides a textured surface and a stated 11-by-17-inch size.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Best for | Key details |
|---|---|---|
| NutriChef 3-Piece Nonstick Cookie Sheets | Choosing among multiple pan sizes | Carbon steel, nonstick coating, red silicone handles, oven safe to 446°F |
| Farberware GOLDEN BAKE Jumbo Baking Cookie Sheet | Even baking and delicate browning | Insulated air-pocket construction, heavy-gauge steel, oven safe to 450°F |
| GoodCook BestBake 11" x 17" Cookie Sheet | Larger batches and sheet-pan meals | Textured carbon steel, scratch-resistant nonstick coating |
Our Picks: Best Baking Sheet For Air Fryer reviews
NutriChef 3-Piece Set: Best for Flexible Pan Sizes
The NutriChef set includes small, medium, and large carbon-steel baking sheets. That range gives you more flexibility than a single-pan purchase: you can pick a sheet based on the amount of food you’re preparing, provided one of the pans fits your air fryer.
The pans have a nonstick coating and red silicone handles for a more confident grip when moving them in and out of the oven. They’re listed as oven safe to 446°F and suitable for oven, refrigerator, and freezer use. The product description also identifies the coating as free of PTFE, PFOA, and PFOS, and says the sheets are dishwasher safe.
The main practical question is fit. The supplied product details don’t list the dimensions of each pan, so measure your appliance’s usable cooking area and confirm the individual pan sizes before buying. These sheets are a versatile option for someone who also wants pans for regular oven baking, but a multi-piece set may be unnecessary if you only need one air-fryer tray.
Pros:
- Three pan sizes offer flexibility for different recipes
- Carbon-steel construction with a nonstick coating
- Red silicone handles provide a grasping point
- Listed as oven safe to 446°F and dishwasher safe
Cons:
- Pan dimensions aren’t provided in the supplied product details
- The set may be more than you need if only one pan fits your appliance
Verdict: Choose the NutriChef set if you want several nonstick pan sizes for both air-fryer-oven use and general baking, but verify each sheet’s dimensions before ordering.
Farberware GOLDEN BAKE: Best for Delicate Browning
This Farberware sheet uses an insulated air-pocket design intended to support airflow and more even heating. That approach may appeal if you bake cookies or other foods where a browned bottom can be a concern. It’s made from heavy-gauge steel and has a nonstick surface.
The sheet is oven safe to 450°F, the highest stated temperature among these three options. The product description says its interior nonstick coating was designed without intentionally adding PFAS, PFOA, lead, or cadmium. As with any large baking sheet, confirm its dimensions against your appliance before buying; the supplied details don’t state the exact measurements.
Its insulated construction makes it more specialized than the NutriChef set, which offers multiple sizes, and the GoodCook sheet, which lists its dimensions. The air-pocket design is intended to promote even heating, but whether the sheet fits and leaves enough room for air movement in your appliance is still the key consideration.
Pros:
- Insulated air-pocket design intended to support even heating
- Heavy-gauge steel construction
- Nonstick surface for easier food release
- Oven safe to 450°F
Cons:
- Exact dimensions aren’t provided in the supplied product details
- Insulated construction may not suit shoppers looking for a simpler, single-layer sheet
Verdict: Consider the Farberware if you value its insulated design for baking and can confirm that its size works in your air-fryer oven.
GoodCook BestBake 11" x 17": Best for Larger Batches
The GoodCook BestBake is a large, 11-by-17-inch carbon-steel sheet designed for larger batches of cookies, desserts, and sheet-pan meals. Its diamond-pattern surface is intended to promote airflow and even heating, while also adding strength and stability.
A scratch-resistant nonstick coating is designed to help food release and make cleanup easier. The sheet also has slightly angled side walls, described as a bakery-style feature for straighter edges. That design may be useful for baked goods, though the raised sides and overall footprint should be checked against your air fryer’s interior.
Unlike the other two options, this product’s supplied details specify its dimensions, which makes checking fit more straightforward. However, at 11 by 17 inches, it may be too large for many air-fryer ovens. No maximum oven temperature is included in the supplied description, so check the product information before using it at high heat.
Pros:
- Stated 11-by-17-inch size makes fit checks more specific
- Textured carbon-steel surface is designed to support airflow and stability
- Scratch-resistant nonstick coating helps with food release
- Useful for larger batches and sheet-pan meals when the appliance has room
Cons:
- The large footprint may not fit many air-fryer ovens
- The supplied product details don’t specify a maximum oven temperature
Verdict: Pick the GoodCook if you need a larger baking sheet and have confirmed that its 11-by-17-inch footprint fits your air-fryer oven with room for airflow.
How to Choose a Baking Sheet for an Air Fryer
Measure the Cooking Space, Not Just the Outside
Measure the usable width and depth of the air-fryer oven’s tray area, then compare those numbers with the sheet’s full dimensions. Leave space around the pan so air can circulate; a sheet that touches the walls or blocks vents may interfere with how the appliance cooks. For the NutriChef and Farberware options, confirm the exact dimensions before ordering because they aren’t included in the supplied details.
Check What Type of Air Fryer You Have
These products are baking sheets, not replacement baskets. They are most relevant to air-fryer ovens that have a flat rack or tray area. A basket-style air fryer may not have a level surface or enough room for a conventional sheet pan, so check your appliance’s manual and accessories before choosing one.
Match the Material and Coating to Your Needs
All three options use nonstick surfaces, and the NutriChef and GoodCook sheets are described as carbon steel. A nonstick finish can help with food release and cleanup, while the NutriChef set also offers three sizes. If coating composition matters to you, check the product details: the supplied descriptions make specific composition statements for NutriChef and Farberware, but not for GoodCook.
Consider the Sheet’s Construction
The Farberware sheet has an insulated air-pocket design intended to support even heating. The GoodCook uses a textured diamond pattern intended to promote airflow and add stability. NutriChef’s main advantage is having three sizes in one set. These design differences are useful for choosing a pan for your usual recipes, but they don’t replace checking whether it fits your appliance.
Check the Maximum Oven Temperature
Match the sheet’s stated heat limit to the recipes you plan to make. The NutriChef is listed as oven safe to 446°F, and the Farberware to 450°F. The supplied GoodCook description doesn’t include a maximum temperature, so consult its product information before using it at higher heat.
Think About How Many Pans You’ll Use
A set can be a good choice if you bake different quantities or also need sheets for a conventional oven. If you only want a single pan for an air-fryer oven, one sheet may be more practical. Keep in mind that an air-fryer oven’s usable space may limit you to a smaller pan, even if a larger sheet would be useful elsewhere in your kitchen.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a regular baking sheet in an air fryer?
It depends on the appliance. These sheets are conventional oven bakeware, so they’re most suitable for air-fryer ovens with a flat rack or tray area. Check your manual, measure the cooking space, and make sure the sheet won’t block airflow.
Which of these baking sheets is the smallest?
The supplied details don’t list the exact dimensions of the NutriChef or Farberware sheets, so it isn’t possible to compare their sizes reliably. The GoodCook is listed as 11 by 17 inches. Check product specifications and measure your appliance before choosing.
Which option is best if I want more than one pan size?
The NutriChef set includes small, medium, and large sheets. Since exact dimensions aren’t provided here, confirm the size of each sheet and whether any will fit your air fryer before ordering.
Which sheet has the highest stated oven-safe temperature?
The Farberware sheet is listed as oven safe to 450°F. NutriChef is listed to 446°F. The supplied GoodCook details don’t state a maximum temperature.
Is the GoodCook sheet a good fit for a compact air fryer?
Its 11-by-17-inch footprint may be too large for a compact appliance. Measure the usable cooking area and allow room around the sheet for airflow before buying.
Are these sheets dishwasher safe?
The NutriChef product description says the set is dishwasher safe. The supplied details don’t specify dishwasher safety for the Farberware or GoodCook sheets, so check their care instructions.
What’s the best overall choice?
The NutriChef set is the most flexible choice if you want multiple sizes, while the Farberware stands out for its insulated design. The GoodCook is worth considering for larger batches if its 11-by-17-inch size fits your appliance. For any of them, fit should come first.
Final Recommendation
The NutriChef 3-piece set is the most versatile pick for shoppers who want several pan sizes for different recipes. If your main priority is an insulated design, consider the Farberware; if you need a large sheet, the GoodCook offers a clearly stated 11-by-17-inch size. Before choosing any of them, measure your air fryer’s usable cooking area and confirm that the pan leaves enough space for air to circulate.