If your mattress feels too firm, a soft topper can add cushioning without replacing the whole bed. The right choice depends on the kind of softness you want: a plush pillow-top feel, a thick foam layer that contours to your body, or a balance of cushioning and support. These five options use different materials, thicknesses, and attachment styles, so compare their designs and fit before choosing.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Topper type | Thickness | Fit and standout features | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BEDLORE Queen Pillow Top Mattress Topper | Bamboo-viscose and polyester pillow top | Not specified | Deep elastic pocket; machine washable | Plush surface comfort and easy care |
| SHOUREN 5-Inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper | Gel memory foam and shredded foam | 5 inches | Four-way elastic anchor straps; quilted cover | Deep cushioning with a stable fit |
| WhatsBedding 4-Inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper | Gel memory foam and shredded foam | 4 inches | Four elastic anchor straps; dot-quilted design | Softness with a little less loft |
| EGO 3-Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper | Ventilated gel memory foam | 3 inches | Ventilation holes; CertiPUR-US certified foam | Contouring comfort in a thinner profile |
| WhatsBedding 5-Inch Bamboo Viscose Mattress Topper | Bamboo-viscose cover with memory and shredded foam | 5 inches | Deep pocket fits mattresses 8–21 inches thick | Plush loft and a wraparound fit |
Our Picks: Best Mattress Topper For Softness reviews
BEDLORE Queen Pillow Top Topper for a Plush Surface
The BEDLORE is a pillow-top style topper with a surface made from 40% bamboo viscose and 60% polyester. Its design focuses on adding a softer, cushioned layer over your mattress rather than changing the bed with a thick memory-foam slab. The product description also highlights a breathable construction, though how cool it feels can vary with your bedding and sleep environment.
A deep elastic pocket and fitted bed skirt are intended to help hold the topper in place. The listed fit range is for mattresses 6 to 18 inches deep, so measure your mattress before ordering. This model is also described as machine washable, which is useful if you want a topper that can be laundered rather than spot-cleaned only.
Compared with the foam options here, BEDLORE may suit shoppers who want a familiar pillow-top feel and easier care. Its thickness is not specified in the supplied product details, so it is harder to compare its loft directly with the 3-, 4-, and 5-inch foam models. It may also provide less of a body-contouring feel than a memory-foam topper.
Pros:
- Pillow-top construction adds a soft surface layer.
- Cover blend includes bamboo viscose and polyester.
- Elasticized pocket is designed for mattresses 6 to 18 inches deep.
- Listed as machine washable for convenient care.
Cons:
- Product details do not state the topper’s thickness.
- May not offer the same close contouring as a memory-foam design.
Verdict: Choose the BEDLORE if you want a washable pillow-top layer with a deep fitted pocket, rather than a thick foam topper.
SHOUREN 5-Inch Topper for Deep Foam Cushioning
SHOUREN combines gel memory foam with shredded foam in a 5-inch topper. The two-part design aims to pair a contouring feel with a fluffier, more yielding layer. That much added height can make a noticeable difference to the feel of a bed, so it is worth considering if you want substantial cushioning rather than a light surface change.
Four-way elastic anchor straps are designed to secure the topper at the corners, while the dot-quilted fabric is intended to keep the filling evenly distributed. It arrives vacuum-compressed, and the product instructions recommend allowing 24–48 hours for it to expand. Plan for that setup time before sleeping on it.
Its generous thickness may appeal if you want softness around your shoulders and hips, with foam underneath for support. However, a 5-inch topper can change the height and feel of your bed more than the thinner EGO model. Check your fitted sheet depth and bed setup before choosing a high-loft option. The product title mentions back-pain relief, but a topper is not a treatment, and individual comfort needs vary.
Pros:
- Five-inch dual-foam construction offers substantial cushioning.
- Combines gel memory foam with shredded foam.
- Four-way corner straps are designed to limit shifting.
- Quilted fabric is intended to help keep filling evenly spread.
Cons:
- Requires 24–48 hours to expand after unpacking.
- The added height may be more than you want if you prefer a subtle change.
Verdict: The SHOUREN is a strong option if your priority is a thick, cushioned foam layer and you have room for the added loft.
WhatsBedding 4-Inch Topper for a Softer, Balanced Feel
This WhatsBedding topper uses gel memory foam and shredded memory foam in a 4-inch design. It aims to provide a soft, contouring surface while retaining some support from the shredded foam. At an inch thinner than the SHOUREN and the other WhatsBedding model below, it may be a more moderate choice for shoppers who want noticeable cushioning without choosing the tallest profile in this group.
The cover is described as breathable and skin-friendly, and dot quilting is designed to help distribute the fill. Four elastic anchor straps secure the topper to the mattress corners. As with the other compressed foam options, it may look less lofty straight out of the package; the product instructions suggest gently patting it and letting it stand for 24 hours.
This model could suit you if a thin pad is unlikely to add enough softness but a 5-inch topper sounds excessive. Its foam-and-fill construction is different from the BEDLORE pillow top, and its corner straps do not wrap around the full mattress like a deep-pocket design. Measure your bed and consider which attachment style you prefer.
Pros:
- Four inches of combined gel memory foam and shredded foam.
- Designed to balance contouring softness with support.
- Four corner straps help hold it in place.
- Dot quilting is intended to reduce uneven fill distribution.
Cons:
- Needs time to regain loft after vacuum-compressed packaging.
- Corner straps are a different fit style from a wraparound deep pocket.
Verdict: Pick this WhatsBedding model if you want substantial foam cushioning but prefer a 4-inch profile over a thicker 5-inch topper.
EGO 3-Inch Gel Foam Topper for a Lower Profile
This 3-inch topper is made from AeroFusion memory foam, with gel infusion and ventilation holes. The foam is designed to conform to body curves and pressure points, while the holes are intended to help heat and humidity move through the topper. These features may make it an appealing pick if you want a contouring foam feel without the taller profile of the 4- and 5-inch choices.
The product is offered in 2- and 3-inch options; the listed product here is the 3-inch version. It is designed to sit on top of the mattress and beneath a mattress cover. The foam is CertiPUR-US certified, and the product arrives compressed. Allow 24–72 hours for expansion, depending on the model and temperature. The product information also notes that a mild, temporary odor may occur and recommends airing out the room.
Unlike the other foam models in this roundup, the supplied details do not describe anchor straps or a deep pocket. If your mattress cover does not hold the topper securely, that is a point to investigate before buying. Its 3-inch height may be a practical middle ground when you want more than a thin pad but do not want a very thick layer.
Pros:
- Three-inch memory foam offers contouring in a lower profile.
- Gel infusion and ventilation holes are designed to support airflow.
- CertiPUR-US certified foam.
- Available in both 2- and 3-inch options.
Cons:
- May take 24–72 hours to fully expand.
- Supplied details do not specify straps or a deep-pocket fit.
Verdict: Choose the EGO if you want a thinner, contouring memory-foam topper with ventilation features and certified foam.
WhatsBedding 5-Inch Bamboo Viscose Topper for Extra Loft
This 5-inch WhatsBedding topper pairs a bamboo-viscose and polyester top layer with memory foam and shredded foam. The cover blend is listed as 40% bamboo viscose and 60% polyester. Its 3D breathable design is intended to provide a comfortable surface, while the foam blend adds substantial loft and cushioning.
A 360-degree deep pocket is designed to wrap around mattresses from 8 to 21 inches thick. That broad fit range may be helpful if your mattress is taller than average or if you prefer a full-pocket attachment over corner straps. The circular quilting is intended to keep the filling evenly spread, and the topper should be given 24–48 hours to expand after unpacking.
Compared with the SHOUREN, this model adds a bamboo-viscose surface and specifies a wider mattress-depth range, while both are 5 inches thick and use mixed foam fill. The extra height can add pronounced softness, but may also make it harder to use sheets with limited depth. The supplied details do not state that this topper is machine washable, so check its care instructions before buying if easy laundering matters to you.
Pros:
- Five-inch construction combines memory foam and shredded foam.
- Top layer uses a bamboo-viscose and polyester blend.
- Deep pocket is listed for mattresses 8 to 21 inches thick.
- Circular quilting is designed to help keep the filling evenly distributed.
Cons:
- The high loft may change the bed’s feel and height substantially.
- Machine-washability is not specified in the supplied details.
Verdict: This is a good fit to consider if you want a thick, cushioned topper with a bamboo-viscose surface and a wide deep-pocket fit range.
How to Choose a Mattress Topper for Softness
Decide How Much Cushioning You Want
Thickness is a useful starting point. A 3-inch topper may offer a more modest change, while 4- and 5-inch models add more loft. A thicker topper is not automatically more comfortable: the best amount depends on how much softness you want and how much your current mattress needs to change. If you only want to soften the surface, a pillow-top option may also be worth considering.
Choose Between Pillow-Top and Foam Feel
A pillow-top design such as BEDLORE focuses on adding a cushioned surface layer. Memory foam options are designed to contour more closely to your body, and the mixed-foam models combine memory foam with shredded foam. Think about whether you prefer a plush, padded feel or a more body-conforming feel before narrowing your choices.
Check the Mattress Fit
A topper that shifts can disrupt your sleep, so compare the attachment style with your mattress. BEDLORE lists a deep pocket for mattresses 6 to 18 inches deep, and the 5-inch WhatsBedding model lists a pocket for 8 to 21 inches. SHOUREN and the 4-inch WhatsBedding model use four corner straps. The supplied EGO details do not specify a strap or pocket system. Measure your mattress depth and check the product listing for fit details before ordering.
Consider Heat and Airflow Features
If you tend to sleep warm, look closely at the materials and construction rather than relying on broad cooling claims. The EGO combines gel-infused foam with ventilation holes. The SHOUREN and WhatsBedding foam options describe breathable fabric or a breathable top layer, while BEDLORE describes its design as breathable. These features are intended to help with airflow or comfort, but they cannot guarantee a particular sleeping temperature.
Think About Care and Setup
Care instructions can matter as much as comfort. BEDLORE is listed as machine washable, while the supplied details for the other options do not make the same claim. Foam toppers arrive compressed and need time to expand: the listed waiting periods range from 24 hours to as long as 72 hours. Check the care label and allow for expansion before planning to use a new topper.
Account for the Extra Height
A thick topper can raise the height of your bed and affect how well fitted sheets stay in place. Before choosing a 4- or 5-inch model, consider your mattress depth, sheet-pocket depth, and how much loft you want. A thinner topper may be easier to fit into your existing setup, while a thicker one may suit someone seeking a more noticeable change.
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of mattress topper feels softest?
Softness is personal. Thick foam toppers can add substantial cushioning, while a pillow-top topper offers a different, more padded surface feel. Compare the materials and thicknesses, then choose based on how much you want to change your mattress.
Is a thicker mattress topper always better?
No. A thicker topper adds more loft, but that may not suit everyone or every bed. Consider your desired feel, mattress depth, fitted-sheet depth, and whether you want a subtle or substantial change.
Which of these options is machine washable?
The supplied product details identify the BEDLORE topper as machine washable. The other listings do not specify machine-washability in the information provided, so check their care instructions before cleaning.
How long should I wait before using a compressed foam topper?
Follow the instructions for the specific model. The SHOUREN and 5-inch WhatsBedding options suggest 24–48 hours, the 4-inch WhatsBedding model suggests 24 hours, and the EGO lists 24–72 hours depending on the model and temperature.
How can I keep a topper from shifting?
Match the attachment style to your mattress. Some options use elastic corner straps, while others use a deep pocket and fitted skirt. Measure your mattress and verify that the product’s stated fit range covers its depth.
Can a mattress topper fix back pain?
A topper can change the cushioning and feel of a mattress, but it is not a medical treatment and cannot guarantee pain relief. If pain is persistent or affects your daily life, consider asking a qualified health professional for advice.
Which topper should I choose if I only want a small change?
The 3-inch EGO has the lowest stated thickness among the foam options here. BEDLORE may also be worth considering if you want a pillow-top surface, though its thickness is not specified in the supplied details. Compare the product dimensions and fit information before deciding.
Final Recommendation
For a plush surface and machine-washable care, the BEDLORE is the clearest choice. If you want thick foam cushioning, compare the SHOUREN and 5-inch WhatsBedding models, paying close attention to their different attachment styles. For a lower-profile foam option, consider the 3-inch EGO; for a middle ground in thickness, the 4-inch WhatsBedding offers mixed foam with corner straps. Your best pick depends on how much softness you want, how your mattress is built, and what fit and care features matter most.