A large glass baking dish with a lid can take a meal from the oven to the table and help keep leftovers covered for storage. The best choice depends on the size and depth you need, whether you prefer a plastic or glass lid, and how you plan to use the dish. These five options include everyday 9-by-13-inch pans, deeper casseroles, and a two-dish set.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Size or capacity | Lid type | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| OXO Good Grips Glass Baking Dish with Lid | 9 × 13 inches, 3 qt | BPA-free plastic | Freezer-to-oven cooking and carrying |
| Pyrex Deep 9 × 13-Inch Glass Baking Dish | 9 × 13 × 2.75 inches | BPA-free plastic | Deeper casseroles and reducing spillovers |
| Sio 9 × 13 Glass Baking Dish with Glass Lid | 9 × 13 × 2 inches | Glass with silicone seal | Avoiding plastic in the lid |
| Sorbus 9 × 13 Glass Baking Dish Set | Two 9 × 13-inch dishes | BPA-free plastic lids | Having two covered dishes on hand |
| Pyrex 5-Qt Deep Rectangular Baking Dish | 5 qt | BPA-free plastic | Large recipes and everyday storage |
Our Picks: Best Large Glass Baking Dish With Lid reviews
OXO Good Grips: A Handy Pick for Freezer-to-Oven Meals
This 9-by-13-inch dish holds 3 quarts and is made for baking, serving, and storing food in the same pan. Its borosilicate glass is described as thermal shock-resistant, with the ability to move from the freezer directly to the oven. Follow the product instructions when making that transition, and use the dish without its lid in the oven.
Wide handles are a useful design detail when carrying a hot casserole. The BPA-free lid is described as slosh-proof and stackable, which can help when transporting food or organizing leftovers. The glass dish is dishwasher-, microwave-, and freezer-safe; the listing does not give the same appliance-use details for the lid.
Compared with the deeper Pyrex option, the OXO has a standard 3-quart capacity rather than a deeper profile. It is a strong fit if the freezer-to-oven feature and easy-to-grip handles matter more to you than extra depth.
Pros:
- Thermal shock-resistant glass is designed for freezer-to-oven use.
- Wide handles offer a secure place to grip.
- Slosh-proof lid helps with transport and stacking.
- Dish has dimension markings and is dishwasher-, microwave-, and freezer-safe.
Cons:
- The 3-quart capacity may be limiting for extra-large recipes.
- The lid is plastic rather than glass.
Verdict: Choose the OXO if you want a practical 9-by-13 dish with comfortable handles and a stated freezer-to-oven feature.
Pyrex Deep 9 × 13: More Room for Tall Casseroles
This Pyrex dish measures 9 by 13 inches and stands 2.75 inches deep. That extra depth gives layered dishes and generous portions more room than a standard-depth pan, and can help limit spillovers. It comes with a BPA-free plastic lid for storage.
The glass is listed as safe for a preheated oven, microwave, and freezer. The lid is listed as freezer- and microwave-safe, and is dishwasher-safe on the top rack. Remove the lid for oven use. The nonporous glass is designed to resist stains, odors, and flavors, making the dish useful for both baking and storing leftovers.
Its deeper shape is the main reason to choose it over the OXO or the standard-depth Sio dish. If you mostly make recipes that fit comfortably in a shallower pan, the extra height may not be necessary.
Pros:
- Deep 2.75-inch sides provide more room for layered or generous dishes.
- Glass is listed as oven-, microwave-, and freezer-safe.
- Plastic lid supports covered storage and reheating.
- Nonporous glass resists stains, odors, and flavors.
Cons:
- The lid is plastic, not glass.
- The listing specifies a preheated oven, so it is not the stated freezer-to-oven option in this group.
Verdict: Pick this Pyrex if extra depth is your priority for casseroles and other dishes that can bubble over.
Sio Glass-Lid Dish: A Plastic-Free Lid for Covered Storage
The Sio is a standard-depth 9-by-13-inch dish with a matching glass lid and a silicone seal. Both pieces are described as borosilicate glass, so this set may suit you if you prefer a glass lid instead of a plastic storage cover. The listing also describes the seal as airtight for storing food.
The dish is listed as safe for the oven, microwave, dishwasher, and freezer. For oven use, remove the lid; for microwave use, unlatch it as directed. The listed depth is 2 inches, so it offers less vertical room than the 2.75-inch Pyrex Deep dish.
This option combines baking and covered storage without a plastic lid, but a glass lid needs careful handling and takes up more storage space than a low-profile cover. It is a better match for home storage than for carrying a dish where a spill-resistant lid is essential.
Pros:
- Matching glass lid avoids a plastic cover.
- Silicone seal is intended to help keep stored food fresh.
- Dish and lid are listed as dishwasher-safe.
- Dish is listed for oven, microwave, and freezer use when used as directed.
Cons:
- At 2 inches deep, it is shallower than the Pyrex Deep dish.
- The glass lid should be removed for oven use and handled with care.
Verdict: Choose the Sio if a glass lid and covered refrigerator storage matter more to you than a deeper pan or a lightweight transport lid.
Sorbus Two-Dish Set: Useful When One Pan Is Not Enough
This set includes two 9-by-13-inch borosilicate glass dishes and BPA-free lids. Having a pair can be convenient if you often prepare a main dish and a side at the same time, or want one pan for serving and another for storing food. The low-profile shape is designed to stack for storage.
The glass dishes are listed as oven-safe up to 450°F. The lids are described as snug-fitting and leak-resistant for refrigerator or freezer storage, and both the dishes and lids are listed as dishwasher-safe. The product information does not specify microwave use, so check the manufacturer’s instructions before using either piece in a microwave.
Unlike the single-dish picks, Sorbus gives you two pans, but the listing does not provide a capacity for each one or a deeper profile like the Pyrex Deep. If you need just one casserole dish, the set may be more than you need.
Pros:
- Includes two 9-by-13-inch dishes with matching lids.
- Borosilicate glass is listed as oven-safe up to 450°F.
- Stackable design can help save storage space.
- Lids are described as leak-resistant for fridge and freezer storage.
Cons:
- The lids are BPA-free plastic rather than glass.
- The product information does not specify microwave use.
Verdict: Consider the Sorbus set if you regularly need two covered baking dishes; for a single pan, one of the other options may be a simpler fit.
Pyrex 5-Quart Dish: A Large-Capacity Everyday Option
This rectangular Pyrex dish has a 5-quart capacity and comes with a matching red BPA-free plastic lid. Its larger stated capacity makes it a useful choice for substantial recipes, serving, food preparation, and storing leftovers. The listing does not provide the dish’s dimensions, so check the product details if you need it to fit a particular oven rack or storage shelf.
The dish is made of tempered glass, and its nonporous surface is described as resistant to food odors, flavors, and stains. The glass dish and lid are dishwasher-safe, with the lid specified for the top rack. The product information does not list temperature limits or microwave and freezer compatibility, so consult the manufacturer’s instructions for those uses.
Compared with the 9-by-13-inch dishes, this option emphasizes capacity rather than a specific footprint or extra-deep dimensions. That makes it worth considering for larger portions, but less convenient if you need confirmed measurements before buying.
Pros:
- 5-quart capacity suits large recipes and serving.
- Includes a matching BPA-free plastic lid.
- Tempered glass is described as resistant to odors, flavors, and stains.
- Dish and lid are dishwasher-safe; the lid is top-rack safe.
Cons:
- The product information does not provide the dish’s dimensions.
- Oven, microwave, and freezer compatibility are not specified in the listing details provided.
Verdict: Choose this Pyrex if a stated 5-quart capacity is more important than having confirmed 9-by-13-inch dimensions or detailed temperature guidance.
How to Choose a Large Glass Baking Dish with a Lid
Match the Capacity and Depth to Your Recipes
A 9-by-13-inch dish is a common format for casseroles and baked meals, but the side depth can make a real difference. The Pyrex Deep is 2.75 inches deep, while the Sio is 2 inches deep. Choose a deeper pan for recipes that rise, bubble, or have several layers. If capacity matters most, the other Pyrex option lists a 5-quart capacity, though its dimensions are not provided.
Decide What Kind of Lid You Want
Plastic lids are lighter and can be convenient for covering food in the refrigerator or carrying a dish. A glass lid, like the one included with the Sio, avoids a plastic cover but is heavier and more fragile. Check which parts are safe for the microwave, freezer, dishwasher, and oven; a dish and its lid may have different care instructions.
Check Oven Guidance and Temperature Limits
Do not assume every glass dish can move directly from the freezer to a hot oven. The OXO listing specifically describes freezer-to-oven use, while the Pyrex Deep specifies a preheated oven. Sorbus lists an oven limit of 450°F for its glass dishes. Follow the instructions for the exact product you buy, and remove lids for oven use unless the manufacturer says otherwise.
Think About Handles and Transport
Wide handles can make it easier to carry a hot dish, a feature called out on the OXO. If you plan to bring food to a gathering, consider how securely the lid fits and whether it is described as spill-resistant. A lid meant for refrigerator storage is not automatically leakproof for travel.
Plan for Storage and Cleanup
Glass dishes are useful for storage because they do not absorb food odors or stains as readily as some materials. For a crowded refrigerator or cabinet, a stackable shape can help; Sorbus specifically describes its dishes as stackable. Also check the cleaning instructions for both parts, especially whether a lid is dishwasher-safe only on the top rack.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I put a glass baking dish with a lid in the oven?
Use the glass dish according to its product instructions, and remove the lid unless the manufacturer explicitly says it is oven-safe. The lids in these picks are primarily described for storage, while the dish listings provide the oven-use details.
Which option is the deepest?
The Pyrex Deep dish is listed at 2.75 inches deep. The Sio is listed at 2 inches deep. The Sorbus dishes are described as low-profile, but their exact depth is not provided.
Which dish has a glass lid?
The Sio 9-by-13-inch dish comes with a matching glass lid and a silicone seal. The other listed options come with BPA-free plastic lids.
Can these dishes go from the freezer straight into the oven?
The OXO is specifically described as suitable for freezer-to-oven use. The other product descriptions do not make the same claim, so do not assume they can handle that transition. Follow each manufacturer’s instructions.
Are the lids microwave-safe?
The Pyrex Deep lid is listed as microwave-safe, and the Sio listing says to unlatch its lid for microwave use. The supplied details do not specify microwave use for every lid, so check the instructions for the particular product.
Which option is best for transporting food?
The OXO lid is described as slosh-proof, and the Sorbus lids are described as leak-resistant. Those features may help with carrying food, but they do not guarantee that a dish will stay spill-free in every position. Transport it level and follow the product’s care instructions.
What is the best all-around pick?
The OXO is a balanced choice if you want a standard 9-by-13-inch dish, wide handles, and a stated freezer-to-oven feature. Choose the Pyrex Deep if extra height matters more, or the Sio if a glass lid is your priority.
Final Recommendation
For most people seeking a large glass baking dish with a lid, the OXO Good Grips is the most versatile pick in this group thanks to its handles, slosh-proof storage lid, and stated freezer-to-oven use. The Pyrex Deep is the better fit for taller casseroles, while the Sio stands out for its glass lid. Before choosing, compare the dimensions and care instructions with the recipes and storage space you have in mind.