Teething can send a puppy looking for something to gnaw—sometimes your furniture or shoes. The best chew toy for your puppy should suit their size and chewing style, offer an appealing texture, and be easy to check for damage. These five options include toys you can chill or freeze, textured chews for gentle chewers, and a stuffable rubber bone for playtime.
Quick Comparison: Best Chew Toys for Teething Puppies
| Product | Standout feature | Best suited for |
|---|---|---|
| Pupstages Cool Teething Stick | Soak-and-freeze cooling option | Puppies drawn to soft, fringed toys |
| Nylabone Puppy Teething Ring Bone | Textured, freezer-friendly ring bone | Extra-small puppies up to 15 pounds |
| Nylabone Puppy Pacifier | Textured chew with bacon flavor | Puppies up to 25 pounds who chew gently |
| Nylabone 2-in-1 Teething Freezer Bone | Soak-and-chill design with bristles | Small puppies up to 25 pounds |
| KONG Puppy Goodie Bone | Stuffable natural rubber design | Small puppies who enjoy food-filled play |
Our Picks: Best Chew Toy For Teething Puppy reviews
Best Cooling Comfort: Pupstages Cool Teething Stick
The Pupstages Cool Teething Stick is a soft, stuffed toy with a polyester shell and playful fringe. Its main draw is that you can soak and freeze it before offering it to your puppy, giving you a cooling option for chew time.
Unlike the Nylabone picks, this toy has a soft fabric-style build rather than a firm textured chew. That may suit a puppy who enjoys tugging or mouthing a soft toy, but it also means you should check it closely during play. The maker warns that no toy is indestructible and says to remove and replace it if damaged.
This is a useful choice if you want a chillable toy with a different feel from a bone or ring. It is not the best match for a puppy that shreds soft toys or needs a firmer chew, and it should not be left with an unsupervised pet.
Pros:
- Can be soaked and frozen for a cooling chew.
- Soft stuffed shell offers a different texture from firm chews.
- Fringe adds a playful element for mouthing and interaction.
Cons:
- Soft construction may not suit puppies that tear or shred toys.
- Requires supervision and replacement if damaged.
Verdict: Choose the Pupstages stick if your puppy prefers soft toys and you want a freezer-friendly option, but inspect it during use and put it away if it starts to come apart.
Best for Extra-Small Puppies: Nylabone Puppy Teething Ring Bone
This Nylabone ring bone is made for extra-small puppies up to 15 pounds. It has ridges and nubs intended to massage gums, and its chicken flavor is infused throughout the chew. The toy is also freezer-friendly for owners who want to chill it before use.
The manufacturer describes the material as soft and intended for puppies with gentle chewing styles. That makes the size and chewing-style limits important: it is not intended for powerful puppies or puppies with adult teeth. If your puppy is a strong chewer or has outgrown the teething stage, choose a toy made for their current needs instead.
Compared with the larger Nylabone Puppy Pacifier and freezer bone, this ring bone is the more size-specific pick for a very small puppy. Its compact sizing is useful only when it matches your dog; don’t choose it just because it is easy to hold.
Pros:
- Designed for extra-small puppies up to 15 pounds.
- Ridges and nubs provide a textured surface for chewing.
- Can be chilled in the freezer.
- Chicken flavor is infused throughout the toy.
Cons:
- Not intended for powerful chewers or puppies with adult teeth.
- Its extra-small size limits which puppies it may suit.
Verdict: This is a sensible option for a gentle-chewing puppy under 15 pounds, provided the toy still fits your puppy’s stage and chewing strength.
Best Textured Chew: Nylabone Puppy Pacifier
The Nylabone Puppy Pacifier is a 6-inch chew toy with textured nubs, bright colors, and bacon flavor infused throughout. Its shape and raised details give a puppy several surfaces to mouth, while the nubs are designed to comfort gums and help clean teeth.
This toy is made from soft material for teething puppies with gentle chewing styles and is sized for dogs up to 25 pounds. The manufacturer says it is not intended for powerful puppies or puppies with adult teeth, so it is important to consider both your dog’s weight and how they chew. A size label alone does not make a toy suitable for every puppy in that range.
Unlike the freezer-focused Nylabone picks, the Puppy Pacifier’s main distinction is its shape and bacon flavor. It may suit a puppy who likes to carry or mouth a shaped chew, but it is not the right choice for a determined power chewer.
Pros:
- Textured nubs offer multiple surfaces to chew.
- Bacon flavor is infused throughout the toy.
- Designed for puppies up to 25 pounds.
- Measures 6 inches long.
Cons:
- Not intended for powerful chewers or puppies with adult teeth.
- Does not have the listed soak-and-freeze feature of the other Nylabone options.
Verdict: Pick the Puppy Pacifier for a gentle-chewing puppy who fits its size range and may enjoy a textured, flavored chew without needing a freezer-ready design.
Best Freezer Bone: Nylabone 2-in-1 Teething Freezer Bone
This Nylabone bone is designed for small puppies up to 25 pounds. You can soak and chill it, and its bristles are intended to massage gums and help clean teeth. The peanut butter flavor is allergen-free, according to the product description.
Its bone shape sets it apart from the ring bone, while the chillable design gives it a similar role as a cooling chew. It may be a good fit if you want a firm, shaped toy that can be prepared with water and chilled. As with any chew, supervise your puppy and check the toy regularly for damage.
The product is specifically described as a chew for small puppies, so match it to your dog’s size and chewing behavior. The listed weight range is helpful, but it does not replace checking whether your puppy can use the toy safely.
Pros:
- Can be soaked and chilled for a cooling chew.
- Bristles are designed to massage gums and help clean teeth.
- Peanut butter flavor is listed as allergen-free.
- Designed for small puppies up to 25 pounds.
Cons:
- Requires preparation if you want to use the cooling feature.
- May not suit puppies outside its stated size range.
Verdict: Choose this bone if you want a chillable chew with bristles and your puppy falls within the stated small-puppy range.
Best Stuffable Option: KONG Puppy Goodie Bone
The KONG Puppy Goodie Bone is made from the brand’s natural rubber for puppies. Its Goodie Grippers can hold KONG Puppy Snacks or KONG Puppy Easy Treat, giving you the option to add a treat during play. The maker says the rubber is designed to soothe sore teeth and gums.
This bone differs from the Nylabone picks because it is stuffable rather than described as a freezer toy. That makes it a more flexible choice for treat-based play, but it is not the most direct match if your main priority is a chew you can soak and chill. The supplied product information identifies this version as blue and for small puppies, but does not give a weight range.
KONG advises supervised play and says to remove the toy if it becomes damaged. That guidance matters even with a rubber toy: no dog toy is truly indestructible. Choose it if your puppy is small and you want to combine chewing with a treat, rather than relying on flavor alone.
Pros:
- Made from KONG Puppy natural rubber.
- Goodie Grippers can hold compatible KONG puppy treats.
- Offers a stuffable alternative to the freezer-focused chews.
- Designed for small puppies.
Cons:
- No weight range is provided in the supplied product details.
- Requires supervision and should be removed if damaged.
Verdict: The KONG Goodie Bone is a strong option if your small puppy enjoys food-filled play, while a Nylabone or Pupstages toy may be a closer fit if you specifically want a chillable teething chew.
How to Choose a Chew Toy for a Teething Puppy
Match the toy to your puppy’s size
Start with the size guidance in the product details. The Nylabone ring bone is listed for puppies up to 15 pounds, while the Puppy Pacifier and freezer bone are listed for puppies up to 25 pounds. The KONG Goodie Bone is described for small puppies without a specific weight range in the supplied details, and the Pupstages stick does not list one. Your puppy should be able to hold and chew the toy comfortably, so use the stated fit guidance rather than picking by appearance alone.
Consider how your puppy chews
Chewing style matters as much as size. The Nylabone options are described as soft chews for puppies with gentle chewing styles, and the manufacturer cautions against using them for powerful puppies or puppies with adult teeth. The Pupstages toy has a soft stuffed shell, while the KONG is made from natural rubber. Choose a toy suited to your puppy’s current behavior, and supervise play so you can step in if the toy is damaged.
Decide whether you want a cooling feature
If you want a toy you can chill, look for a clear preparation method. The Pupstages stick can be soaked and frozen, as can the Nylabone ring bone and freezer bone. The KONG Goodie Bone’s standout feature is its stuffable design rather than a listed freezer use, and the Puppy Pacifier is described as a textured, flavored chew. Follow the product’s directions when preparing a toy.
Choose a texture and shape your puppy will use
A ring bone, shaped pacifier, bone, and soft fringed stick offer different ways to hold and mouth a toy. Textured Nylabone designs have ridges, nubs, or bristles; the Pupstages toy offers a soft shell and fringe; and the KONG bone has openings for treats. If your puppy ignores one style, another shape or texture may be more appealing, but keep the toy’s size and chewing limits in mind.
Check the toy during and after play
Supervision helps you notice damage before a toy becomes unsafe to keep using. The Pupstages and KONG product details specifically say to remove and replace a damaged toy, and KONG advises supervised play. Make a habit of checking the toy, and stop using it if it breaks or starts coming apart. No toy in this group should be treated as indestructible.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which chew toy is best for a teething puppy?
It depends on your puppy’s size, chewing strength, and preferred texture. The Pupstages stick and two Nylabone options offer chillable designs, while the KONG Goodie Bone is made for treat-filled play. Check the size and chewing-style guidance before choosing.
Can I freeze a puppy teething toy?
Several options here are described as freezer-friendly: the Pupstages Cool Teething Stick, Nylabone ring bone, and Nylabone freezer bone. Follow the preparation instructions for the specific toy rather than assuming every chew can be frozen.
Are the Nylabone toys suitable for strong chewers?
The supplied product details describe the Puppy Teething Ring Bone and Puppy Pacifier as intended for gentle chewing, not powerful puppies. The freezer bone is listed for small puppies, so check its current product information and your puppy’s chewing style before buying.
How do I know what size to buy?
Use the product’s stated size range and consider your puppy’s current size and chewing behavior. The ring bone is for puppies up to 15 pounds; the Puppy Pacifier and freezer bone are for puppies up to 25 pounds. The supplied details do not give a weight range for the Pupstages stick or KONG bone.
Can a puppy use a teething chew without supervision?
Supervise your puppy while they chew. The Pupstages and KONG product information warns against leaving toys with unsupervised pets, and KONG says to remove its toy if damaged. Check any chew regularly and stop using it if it breaks or starts to come apart.
What if my puppy has adult teeth?
The Nylabone ring bone and Puppy Pacifier are described as unsuitable for puppies with adult teeth. If your puppy has moved beyond the teething stage, check the product details for an age- and chewing-style-appropriate option before using a toy designed for teething puppies.
Final Recommendation
For a puppy who enjoys soft toys, the Pupstages Cool Teething Stick offers a soak-and-freeze option with a different texture from a hard chew. For a gentle-chewing extra-small puppy, the Nylabone ring bone has clear size guidance; the Nylabone freezer bone is another choice for small puppies who may benefit from a chilled chew. If treat-filled play matters most, consider the KONG Puppy Goodie Bone. In every case, match the toy to your puppy’s size and chewing style, supervise use, and remove it if damaged.