Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Mattresses & Toppers

Best Pack N Play Mattress Protector: 5 Options Compared

Updated 9 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 9minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

A good Pack N Play mattress protector should fit the playard mattress securely, help block leaks, and be easy to wash. The right choice depends on your mattress size and thickness, whether you want one protector or a spare, and whether you prefer a fitted pad or a zippered cover. Below, we compare five options and explain what to check before you buy.

Quick Comparison

ProductBest forFit and designNotable feature
American Baby Company Waterproof Pack and Play Mattress ProtectorA soft, quiet fitted protector39 x 27 inches; pockets fit mattresses up to 2 inches thickQuilted, waterproof, machine washable
PlushDeluxe Pack and Play Mattress ProtectorA quilted terry surface39 x 27 inches; skirt fits mattresses up to 8 inches deepWaterproof and described as noiseless
Yoofoss Waterproof Pack and Play Mattress Protector Sheets, 2-PackA two-protector set39 x 27 inches; pockets fit mattresses up to 5 inches thickQuilted, OEKO-TEX certified, machine washable
Biloban Zippered Pack and Play Mattress ProtectorA removable encasement38 x 26 inches; 1.5-inch depthWaterproof cover with non-slip bottom
Margaux & May Pack N Play Mattress Protector, 2-PackA bamboo-derived fabric two-pack39 x 27 inches; fitted 5-inch skirtWaterproof TPU layer and OEKO-TEX certification

Our Picks: Best Pack N Play Mattress Protector reviews

American Baby Company: A Soft, Quiet Fitted Protector

This fitted protector is designed for a 39-by-27-inch playard or mini crib mattress. Its quilted, multi-layer construction adds a soft surface, while a waterproof polyester backing helps guard the mattress against spills and leaks.

The all-around elastic is intended to keep the cover from slipping or bunching. The product description says its pockets fit mattresses up to 2 inches thick, so check your mattress dimensions and thickness before ordering. It is machine washable and dryer safe, which can make cleanup more straightforward.

Compared with the two-packs in this group, this is a single protector. That may suit you if you only need one, but you may want a spare available while it is in the wash. Its stated pocket depth is also more limited than those of the PlushDeluxe and Yoofoss options.

Pros:

  • Waterproof backing with a quilted surface
  • All-around elastic is designed to help keep it in place
  • Described as soft and quiet
  • Machine washable and dryer safe

Cons:

  • Pockets are listed for mattresses up to 2 inches thick
  • Sold as one protector rather than a two-pack

Verdict: Choose this protector if your mattress matches its size and thickness limits and you want a simple, washable fitted option.

PlushDeluxe: A Quilted Terry Protector With a Deep Skirt

PlushDeluxe pairs a quilted terry cloth top with a waterproof, breathable membrane. The fitted-sheet style has a deep skirt listed to fit mattresses up to 8 inches deep, making it the deepest stated fit among these fitted protectors.

The brand describes the fabric as soft and noiseless, and says the cover is designed for 39-by-27-inch Pack N Play, playard, and mini crib mattresses. Its deep skirt may be useful if your mattress is thicker than the fit limits listed for some other options. Still, confirm your mattress dimensions and follow the playard maker’s guidance on compatible accessories.

This is a single protector, unlike the Yoofoss and Margaux & May two-packs. It could be a practical pick if the terry surface and deeper skirt matter more to you than having a backup on hand.

Pros:

  • Quilted terry cloth top
  • Waterproof and described as breathable
  • Deep skirt listed for mattresses up to 8 inches
  • Fitted-sheet style is designed for a snug fit

Cons:

  • Sold as a single protector
  • Confirm the 39-by-27-inch size matches your mattress

Verdict: Consider PlushDeluxe if you want a quilted terry surface and need a fitted protector with a deeper stated skirt.

Yoofoss: A Quilted Two-Pack for Easier Changes

The Yoofoss set includes two quilted waterproof protectors, so you can keep one available while the other is being washed. Each measures 39 by 27 inches, and the listing says the pockets fit mattresses up to 5 inches thick. It also mentions compatibility with some 38-by-24-inch portable or mini crib mattresses; check the fit carefully rather than assuming it works with every playard.

The soft, breathable fabric and quilted construction are intended to provide a cushioned surface. The waterproof layer helps protect against moisture, and the product is described as machine washable and dryer safe. It is also listed as OEKO-TEX certified.

The two-pack is a useful point of difference from the single covers here. The tradeoff is that fit depends on your mattress size and thickness, so the broader compatibility language should not replace checking your playard’s measurements and instructions.

Pros:

  • Includes two protectors for convenient changes
  • Quilted surface with waterproof protection
  • Pockets listed for mattresses up to 5 inches thick
  • Machine washable and dryer safe; listed as OEKO-TEX certified

Cons:

  • Confirm whether the 39-by-27-inch cover fits your specific mattress
  • May not suit mattresses thicker than the stated 5-inch limit

Verdict: Pick the Yoofoss set if you want two washable quilted protectors and your mattress fits the listed dimensions and thickness range.

Biloban: A Zippered Encasement for Specific Mattress Sizes

Unlike the fitted pads, this Biloban protector is a zippered encasement. It measures 38 by 26 inches with a listed depth of 1.5 inches. Its bamboo-derived viscose jacquard surface and waterproof TPU layer are described as soft and quiet, while non-slip dots on the bottom are intended to help the mattress stay in place.

Fit is especially important with this option. The listing names compatibility with Graco Pack N Play, Dream On Me, and Pamo Babe playards, but excludes the 4moms Breeze Plus Portable, 4moms Breeze GO Portable, and Lotus Travel Crib playards. Measure your mattress and check those compatibility details before buying.

The zipper lets you remove the cover for washing, and the care instructions specify a cold, gentle machine wash and low-heat tumble dry. This cover may appeal if you want an encasement rather than a fitted pad, but its narrower stated size and depth make it less flexible than the 39-by-27-inch options.

Pros:

  • Zippered design makes the cover removable
  • Waterproof TPU layer and non-slip bottom
  • Soft surface described as quiet
  • Care instructions include machine washing and low-heat tumble drying

Cons:

  • Smaller stated dimensions than the 39-by-27-inch protectors
  • Not compatible with several listed playard models

Verdict: Choose Biloban only if its 38-by-26-inch dimensions, 1.5-inch depth, and compatibility details match your mattress and playard.

Margaux & May: A Bamboo-Derived Two-Pack With a Fitted Skirt

This two-pack is designed for 39-by-27-inch playard mattresses. Each protector has a fitted 5-inch skirt and a quilted, absorbent top over a waterproof TPU layer. The fabric is described as viscose derived from bamboo, with a quiet, breathable feel.

Having two protectors can make it easier to swap in a clean one after a spill or wash. The listing says they are machine washable, dryer safe, and shrink-resistant, and identifies them as OEKO-TEX certified. As with any fitted protector, check the mattress thickness and playard guidance before use.

Compared with the Yoofoss set, this option has a stated 5-inch skirt and highlights bamboo-derived viscose. The available product information does not specify a particular mattress thickness limit, so check the fit details before purchasing if your mattress is unusually thick.

Pros:

  • Two protectors included
  • Waterproof TPU layer beneath an absorbent quilted top
  • Fitted 5-inch skirt
  • Listed as OEKO-TEX certified, machine washable, and dryer safe

Cons:

  • Designed for 39-by-27-inch mattresses, so it may not fit other sizes
  • Check mattress thickness because a maximum thickness is not stated in the supplied details

Verdict: Consider Margaux & May if you want two fitted protectors with a bamboo-derived fabric surface and your mattress matches the listed size.

How to Choose a Pack N Play Mattress Protector

Measure the Mattress, Not Just the Playard

Protector sizing is not identical across these picks. Four are listed as 39 by 27 inches, while the Biloban encasement measures 38 by 26 inches. Measure your actual mattress and compare its length and width with the product details. A protector that is too large can fit loosely, while one that is too small may be difficult to put on.

Check Mattress Thickness and Pocket Depth

Fit also depends on thickness. American Baby Company lists pockets for mattresses up to 2 inches thick; Yoofoss lists pockets up to 5 inches; PlushDeluxe lists a skirt for mattresses up to 8 inches deep; and Margaux & May lists a 5-inch skirt without a maximum mattress thickness in the supplied details. Biloban has a stated depth of 1.5 inches. Compare these measurements with your mattress before choosing.

Choose Between a Fitted Protector and an Encasement

Most options here use an elastic fitted design. Biloban instead has a zipper and fully removable cover. A fitted style may be simpler to place over a mattress, while an encasement wraps around it. Consider which design you prefer, but do not assume that one style fits every playard mattress.

Consider the Waterproof Layer and Surface Fabric

All five products are described as waterproof. The listed surfaces include quilted fabric, terry cloth, and viscose derived from bamboo. If sound matters to you, several products specifically describe their materials as quiet or noiseless. Look for the surface and construction details that suit your preferences, and avoid treating “waterproof” as a substitute for checking the product’s care instructions.

Decide Whether a Two-Pack Is Useful

Yoofoss and Margaux & May include two protectors; the other listed options are single covers. A second protector can be handy when one is in the wash. If you only need one, a single-cover option may be enough.

Follow the Playard Maker’s Fit and Care Guidance

Before use, confirm that the protector is compatible with your playard and mattress. Pay close attention to exclusions, such as those listed for the Biloban cover. Follow the playard manufacturer’s instructions for sleep surfaces and accessories, and use the protector only when it fits securely. Check the product label for washing and drying directions; care instructions can differ among covers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What size Pack N Play mattress protector should I buy?

Buy a protector that matches your mattress measurements, not just the playard name. Many options here measure 39 by 27 inches, while the Biloban encasement measures 38 by 26 inches. Check both the length and width before ordering.

Will a 39-by-27-inch protector fit every Pack N Play?

No. The supplied product details describe these protectors as fitting certain standard playard or mini crib mattresses, but they do not establish universal compatibility. Measure your mattress and check the product’s fit limits and your playard maker’s instructions.

Do these protectors have different mattress thickness limits?

Yes. The listed limits vary: American Baby Company says up to 2 inches, Yoofoss up to 5 inches, and PlushDeluxe up to 8 inches. Margaux & May lists a 5-inch skirt but does not state a maximum mattress thickness in the supplied information. Biloban lists a 1.5-inch depth.

Are the protectors in this guide waterproof?

Each product is described as waterproof. The specific construction varies, including polyester backing, a waterproof membrane, and a TPU layer. Check the product details for the construction and follow its care directions to maintain the cover.

Which options come with two protectors?

Yoofoss and Margaux & May are listed as two-packs. The American Baby Company, PlushDeluxe, and Biloban options are presented as single protectors in the supplied product information.

Can I use a mattress protector with any playard mattress?

Do not assume so. Check the protector’s dimensions, pocket depth, and compatibility notes, then follow the playard manufacturer’s instructions. Biloban, for example, lists specific compatible models and several exclusions.

Final Recommendation

For a flexible two-pack with a stated fit for mattresses up to 5 inches thick, the Yoofoss protector is a practical place to start, provided its dimensions match your mattress. If you prefer a single fitted cover, compare American Baby Company and PlushDeluxe based on their different pocket-depth limits. For any option, verify fit and follow your playard’s guidance before use.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment