A large ice cube tray with a lid helps you make slow-melting cubes while keeping them covered in the freezer. The options below use flexible silicone, and several add a reinforcing frame to make filling and carrying easier. The main differences are how many trays you get, how many cubes they make, and whether features such as dishwasher-safe cleaning or measured fill lines matter to you.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Trays and cubes | Standout features |
|---|---|---|
| VLM 3-Pack Large Ice Cube Molds | 3 trays; 18 cubes total | 2-inch cubes, internal frame, removable lids |
| GGUW 3-Pack Large Ice Cube Trays | 3 trays; 18 cubes total | 2-inch cubes, steel-reinforced silicone, dishwasher safe |
| FDDBI 2-Pack Large Ice Cube Trays | 2 trays; 12 cubes total | 2-inch cubes, steel-reinforced rim, dishwasher safe |
| KitchFort 2-Pack Silicone Ice Cube Trays | 2 trays; 12 cubes total | 2-inch cubes, stackable lids, dishwasher safe |
| OAOZFWY 2-Pack Large Ice Cube Trays | 2 trays; 12 cubes total | 2-inch cubes, steel frame, fill-level markings |
Our Picks: Best Large Ice Cube Tray With Lid reviews
VLM 3-Pack: A High-Capacity Set for Regular Use
VLM’s set includes three silicone trays, each with six cavities, for 18 large square cubes per batch. Each cube is listed as 2 inches, a size suited to drinks where you want a substantial piece of ice rather than several small cubes.
An internal frame adds support when you fill or move a tray. That is a useful detail with flexible silicone, which can be harder to carry when full than a rigid plastic mold. The removable lids are described as helping prevent spills and freezer odors, and the covered trays can be stacked to save space.
The set’s main advantage over the two-tray picks is its larger total output. It also suits more than drinks: the product description says the molds can be used to freeze soup, baby food, and meal portions. Keep in mind that each tray still makes only six cubes, so this set is best for people who value having multiple molds ready at once.
Pros:
- Three trays make 18 cubes in one batch.
- 2-inch cubes are sized for whiskey and cocktails.
- Internal frames help support the trays during filling and transport.
- Removable lids allow covered, stackable storage.
Cons:
- Three trays take more freezer space than a two-tray set.
- The product description does not specify whether the trays are dishwasher safe.
Verdict: Choose the VLM set if you want a higher cube count and the convenience of three framed trays with lids.
GGUW 3-Pack: A Stackable Set with Dishwasher-Safe Trays
This three-pack also makes 18 square cubes, with six cavities in each tray. The cubes are 2 inches across, and the independent compartments are designed to let you push cubes out from the bottom rather than flexing the entire tray.
The trays use food-grade silicone around a steel frame. The frame is intended to help the mold keep its shape during filling and carrying, while the silicone makes it possible to press out individual cubes. The fitted lids are described as helping keep ice clean, limiting odor absorption, and allowing the trays to stack. The trays are also listed as dishwasher safe.
Compared with the VLM three-pack, GGUW explicitly lists dishwasher-safe cleaning. The tradeoff is similar: three trays give you plenty of cubes, but they require more storage room than a two-tray set. The listing does not provide exterior tray measurements, so check your freezer space if room is tight.
Pros:
- Makes 18 2-inch cubes per batch.
- Steel reinforcement supports the flexible silicone mold.
- Dishwasher-safe trays simplify cleanup.
- Lids are designed for covered, stackable storage.
Cons:
- The three-tray set may take up more freezer space than you need.
- No exterior dimensions are provided in the supplied product details.
Verdict: The GGUW set is a practical fit if you want three trays, a reinforced design, and dishwasher-safe cleanup.
FDDBI 2-Pack: Framed Molds for Cocktails and Food Portions
FDDBI’s two-tray set makes 12 square cubes, with six cavities in each mold. The 2-inch cubes suit whiskey, cocktails, coffee, and juice. The separate cavities are meant to make it easier to press out one cube at a time.
A silicone-wrapped steel rim adds structure for filling and carrying the trays. Each mold has a removable lid, and the covered trays are designed to stack in the freezer. The product description also lists the trays as dishwasher safe and suggests using them to freeze food in portions.
This set offers the same basic cube size and reinforced construction as the three-tray options, but with fewer molds to store. That can be a better match for a smaller household or anyone who does not need 18 cubes at once. If you entertain often or want to keep a larger supply of ice on hand, the VLM or GGUW sets make more per batch.
Pros:
- Makes 12 2-inch cubes across two trays.
- Steel-reinforced rims support filling and transport.
- Dishwasher-safe trays are easier to clean.
- Can also be used for freezing food portions.
Cons:
- Produces fewer cubes per batch than the three-tray sets.
- No exterior tray measurements are listed in the supplied details.
Verdict: Pick FDDBI if you want framed, dishwasher-safe molds but do not need the higher capacity of a three-pack.
KitchFort 2-Pack: A Straightforward Choice for Everyday Freezing
KitchFort’s two trays have six cavities each and make 12 large cubes at a time. The 2-inch size is intended for slow-melting ice in cocktails, whiskey, coffee, and other drinks. Flexible silicone and separate cavities are designed to make releasing cubes a matter of twisting the mold and pushing from underneath.
The lids help keep freezer odors away from the contents and make the trays stackable. Unlike some picks in this list, the supplied description does not mention a steel frame, so this option focuses on a simpler silicone design. It is listed as dishwasher safe and can also be used for baby food, purees, sauces, and other portions.
The two-tray capacity is a sensible middle ground if you want enough cubes for everyday use without storing a three-pack. The listing does not provide exterior measurements, so consider the space available in your freezer before choosing any stackable tray set.
Pros:
- Makes 12 2-inch cubes per batch.
- Flexible, separate cavities are designed for easy release.
- Dishwasher safe for easier cleanup.
- Lids help protect contents and allow stacking.
Cons:
- Does not list a reinforcing frame like several competing options.
- The two-tray set makes fewer cubes than the three-packs.
Verdict: KitchFort is a good option if you want a simple two-tray set for drinks and portion freezing, with dishwasher-safe convenience.
OAOZFWY 2-Pack: Fill-Level Markings for More Measured Portions
OAOZFWY’s two molds make 12 2-inch cubes. Its standout feature is a set of fill-level markings inside each compartment, listed at 40 ml/1.5 oz and 80 ml/3 oz. Those marks can help you portion liquids more consistently, whether you are making ice or freezing measured amounts of another ingredient.
The trays have an embedded stainless steel frame to resist bending and collapsing when moved or stacked. Flexible silicone cavities are designed to release cubes with a press from the bottom. The listing describes the lid as sealing each chamber to help prevent leaks during transport or tilting, though careful filling and handling are still sensible with any tray.
Compared with the other two-tray choices, this one stands out for its measurement marks and its specifically described frame. The product details do not state that it is dishwasher safe, so check the care instructions if that feature is important to you.
Pros:
- Makes 12 large cubes across two trays.
- Fill-level markings support more measured portions.
- Embedded steel frame helps the tray keep its shape.
- Lids are designed to seal individual chambers.
Cons:
- The supplied details do not specify whether it is dishwasher safe.
- Its two-tray capacity is lower than the three-pack options.
Verdict: Choose OAOZFWY if you want a reinforced two-pack and find marked fill levels useful for portioning.
How to Choose a Large Ice Cube Tray With a Lid
Choose a cube size that fits your drinks
All five picks are described as making 2-inch cubes. Large cubes are often chosen for whiskey and cocktails because they have less exposed surface area than many small cubes, which can help slow melting. They also take up more room in a glass, so consider the glassware you use most often.
Match the tray count to how much ice you need
Each tray in this group has six cavities. The three-tray VLM and GGUW sets make 18 cubes per batch, while the two-tray FDDBI, KitchFort, and OAOZFWY sets make 12. More trays can be useful for parties or keeping a supply ready, but they also need more freezer space.
Look for support that suits your filling routine
Flexible silicone can make it easier to push cubes out, but a filled tray can be less rigid to carry. Several options add a steel or internal frame for support. If you plan to fill a mold at the sink and carry it to the freezer, a framed design may be worth prioritizing.
Check what the lid is designed to do
The listed lids are intended to cover the ice, help limit freezer odors, and make stacking easier. The OAOZFWY listing specifically describes chamber-by-chamber sealing. If you need to move a full tray, handle it level and check the lid is properly attached rather than assuming every lid will prevent spills in every position.
Consider cleanup and other uses
GGUW, FDDBI, and KitchFort are listed as dishwasher safe. The supplied details do not make that claim for VLM or OAOZFWY, so check the product instructions before putting those trays in a dishwasher. Several molds can also freeze portions of food, sauces, or purees, which may make them more useful than a drink-only tray.
Measure your freezer space
The product information provided here does not list the trays’ outside dimensions. Before ordering, consider the shelf or drawer where you plan to store them, especially if you want to stack multiple covered trays. A set’s cube count does not tell you how much space the trays themselves will occupy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why use large ice cubes instead of regular small cubes?
Large cubes are commonly used when you want ice that melts more slowly than smaller pieces and may dilute a drink less quickly. The products in this guide make 2-inch cubes designed for drinks such as whiskey and cocktails.
How many cubes does each tray make?
Each tray listed here has six cavities. The VLM and GGUW three-packs make 18 cubes total, while the other three two-packs make 12 cubes total.
Do the lids make the trays leakproof?
The lids are described as helping prevent spills, and the OAOZFWY lid is specifically described as sealing each chamber. Since lid designs differ, keep a filled tray level when moving it and make sure the lid is fitted securely.
Are all of these trays dishwasher safe?
No. The supplied product details list GGUW, FDDBI, and KitchFort as dishwasher safe. They do not specify dishwasher-safe cleaning for VLM or OAOZFWY, so check the product’s care instructions.
Can I use these molds for food besides ice?
Several listings describe other uses, including freezing soup, baby food, purees, sauces, juice, or meal portions. Check the individual product details and care instructions for the uses and cleaning method you need.
Which option makes the most ice?
VLM and GGUW both include three trays with six cavities each, for 18 cubes per batch. The other options include two trays and make 12 cubes per batch.
Final Recommendation
For the most cubes in one batch, the VLM and GGUW three-packs are the strongest fits, with 18 cubes and framed construction. GGUW also lists dishwasher-safe cleaning, while VLM offers the same batch capacity with removable lids and an internal frame. If you prefer a smaller set, FDDBI, KitchFort, and OAOZFWY each make 12 cubes; choose based on whether you value a reinforced rim, dishwasher-safe care, or fill-level markings. Before buying, make sure the covered trays will fit your freezer.