Choosing between a 12-inch and an 8-inch mattress is about more than height. A thicker mattress may offer room for more comfort and support layers, while a thinner model can be a simpler fit for a low-profile setup. The materials and construction matter just as much as the measurement. These five options include foam and hybrid designs, so you can compare what each one offers before deciding which thickness suits your bed and sleep preferences.
Quick Comparison
| Mattress | Thickness | Construction and features | Size listed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best Price Mattress 12-Inch Green Tea Memory Foam | 12 inches | Memory foam with support and high-density foam layers | Queen |
| Novilla 12-Inch Twin Hybrid Mattress | 12 inches | Gel memory foam, comfort foam, and pocketed coils | Twin |
| EGOHOME 12-Inch Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress | 12 inches | Medium-firm memory foam with green tea gel | Twin |
| Best Price Mattress 8-Inch Cooling Gel Memory Foam | 8 inches | Medium-firm, gel-infused memory foam | Not specified in the supplied product details |
| Celestial Sleep 12-Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress | 12 inches | Quilted cover, gel bead memory foam, comfort foam, and base foam | Twin XL |
Our Picks: Best 12 Inch Vs 8 Inch Mattress reviews
Best Overall Foam Pick: Best Price Mattress 12-Inch Green Tea Memory Foam
This queen-size, 12-inch mattress uses memory foam over support and high-density foam layers. Its all-foam construction is a straightforward alternative to a hybrid mattress, and the memory foam is designed to mold to your body and ease pressure points. Green tea is infused into the foam, while the cover is made from Poly Jacquard fabric.
The layered build gives this model more material depth than the 8-inch foam option in this comparison. That may appeal if you want a thicker mattress, but the product details do not specify its firmness, so shoppers who need a particular feel should confirm that before choosing. The foam is CertiPUR-US certified, and the mattress includes a 10-year warranty, which are useful details to consider when comparing options.
This model is a practical choice for someone shopping for a queen-size foam mattress with several layers and a memory foam feel. It is less suited to shoppers specifically seeking pocketed coils or a listed medium-firm feel.
Pros:
- 12-inch layered foam construction
- Memory foam is designed to contour and relieve pressure
- Green tea infusion and Poly Jacquard cover
- CertiPUR-US certified foams and a 10-year warranty
Cons:
- Firmness is not specified in the supplied details
- All-foam construction may not suit shoppers who prefer coils
Verdict: Choose this queen mattress if you want a thicker, layered memory foam design with a stated warranty and certification.
Best Hybrid Pick: Novilla 12-Inch Twin Mattress with Pocketed Coils
Unlike the all-foam choices here, this 12-inch twin mattress pairs gel memory foam and comfort foam with individually pocketed coils. The coil system is described as having targeted support zones, while the foam layers are intended to cushion pressure-sensitive areas. Its cool-touch nylon knit cover is designed for breathability and moisture wicking.
The hybrid construction makes this the most distinct option for shoppers who want both foam cushioning and a coil layer. Reinforced perimeter construction is intended to help provide support near the edges. The mattress arrives compressed in a box, which can make moving it through tight spaces easier, though it still needs room to expand after unpacking.
The product details do not state a firmness level or provide a specific coil count, so you should not choose it based on assumptions about either. It is listed in twin size, making it a focused option for a twin bed rather than a queen or twin XL setup.
Pros:
- Combines pocketed coils with gel memory foam and comfort foam
- Targeted support zones and reinforced perimeter construction
- Cool-touch, breathable nylon knit cover
- Compressed packaging designed for easier delivery and setup
Cons:
- Only the twin size is listed in the supplied product details
- Firmness is not specified
Verdict: Pick the Novilla if you want a 12-inch twin hybrid with pocketed coils rather than an all-foam mattress.
Best Medium-Firm Foam Pick: EGOHOME 12-Inch Green Tea Memory Foam
This twin-size mattress is a 12-inch memory foam option with a stated medium-firm feel. Its foam is designed to contour to the body, distribute pressure, and fill gaps as you change positions. The product description also highlights a bubble-hole structure for airflow and green tea gel intended to help manage heat.
Compared with the Best Price Mattress 12-inch foam model, EGOHOME provides a stated firmness level, which can make it easier to narrow your choices if you are looking for medium-firm. Both are foam designs with green tea-related features, but the EGOHOME is listed in twin size and does not include the same stated warranty information in the supplied details.
This could suit shoppers who want a thicker twin mattress and prefer a medium-firm specification. The product description discusses support for different sleep positions, but comfort is personal; the firmness label alone cannot guarantee that it will feel right for every sleeper.
Pros:
- 12-inch memory foam construction with a stated medium-firm feel
- Designed to contour and distribute pressure
- Green tea gel and airflow-focused foam structure
- Foam is described as maintaining a consistent feel across temperature and humidity changes
Cons:
- Twin is the size listed in the supplied product details
- Does not have a coil layer for shoppers seeking a hybrid design
Verdict: The EGOHOME is a strong option to consider if you want a 12-inch twin foam mattress and a clearly stated medium-firm feel.
Best Slim Profile Pick: Best Price Mattress 8-Inch Cooling Gel Foam
This is the only 8-inch mattress in the group. It uses gel-infused memory foam and has a listed medium-firm feel. The foam is designed to adapt to your body and ease pressure, while the breathable construction and gel infusion are intended to support a cooler sleep environment.
A thinner mattress can be useful when you want a lower-profile bed or need to account for the total height of your mattress and bed frame. It also has less overall thickness than the 12-inch options here, but that alone does not determine comfort or support. The supplied description does not detail its internal layers, so there is less construction information to compare with the layered 12-inch models.
The mattress arrives compressed and is described as expanding to full size within 72 hours after unboxing. Check the product listing for the available size before buying, since the size is not specified in the information provided here.
Pros:
- 8-inch profile for shoppers seeking a thinner mattress
- Medium-firm feel is specified
- Gel-infused memory foam is designed for pressure relief and temperature regulation
- Breathable design and convenient compressed packaging
Cons:
- Less total mattress thickness than the 12-inch options
- Size and detailed layer construction are not specified in the supplied details
Verdict: Consider this model if a slim, medium-firm foam mattress is your priority, but confirm the available size and check that its profile suits your bed setup.
Best Certified Twin XL Pick: Celestial Sleep 12-Inch Gel Memory Foam
Celestial Sleep’s 12-inch twin XL mattress combines a quilted cover with cooling technology, gel bead-infused memory foam, a comfort foam layer, and a base foam layer. The layers are intended to balance cushioning and structure. Its product details state that it is made in the USA and is CertiPUR-US, Oeko-Tex, and fiberglass-free certified.
This model stands out for its stated certifications and twin XL size. The gel bead-infused foam is designed to conform to your shape, while the cover is described as heat-wicking. Like the other all-foam options, it does not offer pocketed coils, so it is not the match for someone specifically looking for a hybrid.
The supplied details do not list a firmness level. If you are comparing it with the EGOHOME, which is described as medium-firm, keep in mind that Celestial Sleep’s feel is not specified here. It is best suited to shoppers who need twin XL and value the listed material certifications.
Pros:
- 12-inch design with several foam layers and a quilted cover
- Gel bead-infused memory foam and heat-wicking cover
- CertiPUR-US and Oeko-Tex certifications, and described as fiberglass-free
- Twin XL size is listed
Cons:
- Firmness is not specified in the supplied details
- All-foam construction does not include pocketed coils
Verdict: Choose Celestial Sleep if you need a twin XL 12-inch foam mattress and want the stated certifications and layered construction.
How to Choose Between a 12-Inch and 8-Inch Mattress
Think about the full bed height
Mattress thickness changes the height of your finished bed, so consider how it will work with your frame and bedding. A 12-inch mattress will sit higher than an 8-inch mattress on the same base. If you prefer a lower-profile bed or want to keep the overall height down, an 8-inch model may be worth considering. Measure your setup and check the mattress dimensions before ordering.
Compare the materials, not just the inches
Thickness does not tell you what a mattress is made of or how it will feel. The options here include all-foam models and a hybrid with pocketed coils. Foam construction can offer contouring, while the Novilla combines foam comfort layers with coils. Look at the listed materials and construction details to find the type that best matches your preferences.
Use firmness information as a guide
Only some products in this selection state a firmness level: the Best Price Mattress 8-inch model and the EGOHOME 12-inch model are described as medium-firm. Firmness is a useful comparison point, but it is not a complete measure of comfort. If you have a strong preference, check the current product listing for additional details and consider the seller’s return terms before buying.
Match the mattress to your bed size
Size is just as important as thickness. The products listed here include queen, twin, and twin XL, while the supplied details do not specify the size for the 8-inch Best Price Mattress. Confirm the exact size and dimensions on the product page so the mattress fits your frame and your needs.
Consider the support layers and edge details
Some products describe multiple foam layers, while the Novilla highlights pocketed coils, targeted support zones, and reinforced perimeter construction. These features can help you distinguish one design from another, but the product descriptions do not provide the same level of detail for every mattress. Compare what is actually stated rather than assuming that a thicker mattress automatically has better support.
Check certifications, warranty, and setup details
If certifications matter to you, compare the specific claims made for each mattress. The Best Price Mattress 12-inch model lists CertiPUR-US certified foams and a 10-year warranty. Celestial Sleep lists CertiPUR-US and Oeko-Tex certifications and describes the mattress as fiberglass-free. Setup details also vary: the 8-inch Best Price Mattress listing says it expands within 72 hours, while the other products are described as compressed or boxed without the same expansion timing in the supplied details.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a 12-inch mattress always more comfortable than an 8-inch mattress?
No. Thickness alone cannot determine comfort. Materials, layer design, firmness, and your own preferences all matter. Compare the construction and stated feel rather than choosing only by height.
What is the main difference between these 12-inch and 8-inch options?
The 8-inch model has a lower profile and is described as medium-firm gel-infused memory foam. The 12-inch options include several foam designs and one hybrid with pocketed coils. The 12-inch products also vary in size, materials, and listed features.
Does a thicker mattress provide more support?
Not necessarily. A thicker mattress may include more room for layers, but thickness by itself does not prove that it will offer better support. Check the materials and construction details, and match them to your needs.
Which mattress in this selection has pocketed coils?
The Novilla 12-inch twin hybrid is the only option here described with individually pocketed coils. The other listed models are foam mattresses.
Which options state a medium-firm feel?
The Best Price Mattress 8-inch cooling gel foam mattress and the EGOHOME 12-inch green tea memory foam mattress are both described as medium-firm. The supplied details do not state a firmness level for the other three models.
How should I choose between the two Best Price Mattress options?
Compare their profile and construction. The 12-inch queen model has memory foam, support foam, and high-density layers, plus a stated 10-year warranty and CertiPUR-US certified foams. The 8-inch model is described as medium-firm gel-infused memory foam and may suit shoppers looking for a thinner profile. Confirm the 8-inch model’s available size on its product page.
What should I check before ordering a mattress in a box?
Confirm the size, dimensions, bed-frame fit, and any setup or expansion instructions on the product listing. Make sure you have a clear path for moving the box and enough space to unpack the mattress.
Final Recommendation
For a low-profile option, the Best Price Mattress 8-inch model is the clear choice in this group, with a stated medium-firm feel and gel-infused foam. If you want a 12-inch mattress, choose based on construction and size: the Novilla offers pocketed coils, the EGOHOME has a stated medium-firm feel, and the Celestial Sleep is a twin XL option with several listed certifications. For a queen-size layered foam mattress, consider the Best Price Mattress 12-inch model. Whichever you choose, verify the size, firmness details, and bed-frame fit before ordering.
