A 13-by-9-inch baking dish with a lid can take a casserole from the oven to the fridge with fewer transfers and less cleanup. The right choice depends on what matters most to you: extra depth, a lid that helps with transport, an all-glass design, or a carrier for potlucks. Below, we compare five options by their listed materials, dimensions, lid features, and practical limitations.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Standout feature | Lid | Best suited for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pyrex Deep 9×13 Glass Baking Dish | Extra-deep 2.75-inch dish | BPA-free plastic | Layered or generous casseroles |
| OXO Good Grips Glass Baking Dish | Wide handles and slosh-proof lid | BPA-free plastic | Transport and everyday storage |
| Sio Glass Baking Dish with Glass Lid | Glass lid with silicone seal | Glass | Those avoiding a plastic lid |
| Sorbus 9×13 Glass Baking Dishes | Two dishes in the set | BPA-free plastic | Cooking and storing more than one dish |
| Vitrignis Baking Dish with Carrier | Insulated carrying bag included | Plastic lid | Potlucks and picnics |
Availability can change. The supplied product information marks the Sorbus and Vitrignis listings as unavailable.
Our Picks: Best 13X9 Baking Dish With Lid reviews
1. Pyrex Deep Dish: Best for Extra Room
This Pyrex dish keeps the familiar 9-by-13-inch footprint but adds extra depth. It measures 2.75 inches high, making it a useful option for casseroles or layered dishes that might crowd a shallower pan. The glass dish comes with a BPA-free plastic lid for storage.
The glass is listed as safe for a preheated oven, microwave, and freezer. The lid is listed as freezer-safe, microwave-safe, and safe for the top rack of the dishwasher. Remove the lid for oven use. Pyrex also describes the glass as non-porous and resistant to stains, flavors, and odors.
The trade-off is that this is a deep dish rather than a standard-depth option. That extra height is helpful when you need room, but check your recipe and storage space if you usually use shallower pans. The lid is plastic, so it may not suit shoppers who want an all-glass cover or need a secure transport seal.
Pros:
- Extra-deep 2.75-inch design offers more room for food.
- Glass dish is listed as safe for a preheated oven, microwave, and freezer.
- Included lid is freezer-, microwave-, and top-rack dishwasher-safe.
- Non-porous glass resists retaining stains, flavors, and odors.
Cons:
- Plastic lid is not listed as oven-safe.
- Deeper profile may take up more storage space than a standard-depth dish.
Verdict: Choose the Pyrex if extra capacity and a useful oven-to-storage dish matter more to you than having a glass lid.
2. OXO Good Grips: Best for Carrying and Storing
OXO’s 9-by-13-inch dish is made from borosilicate glass and has a listed capacity of 3 quarts. Its standout details are practical ones: wide handles for gripping and a BPA-free, slosh-proof lid intended to reduce spills during transport and help with stacking.
The product information says the glass is thermal shock-resistant and can move from the freezer directly to the oven. It is also listed as microwave-, freezer-, and dishwasher-safe. Dimension markings on the dish can help when you want to check measurements while preparing a recipe.
Compared with the deeper Pyrex, this OXO model is a more standard-depth option and puts more emphasis on carrying and storage. Its broad handles may be useful when moving a full dish, though they also add to its overall footprint. As with other plastic lids, remove the lid for oven use.
Pros:
- Wide handles are designed for a secure grip.
- Slosh-proof lid helps reduce spills during transport.
- Borosilicate glass is listed as freezer-to-oven safe.
- Includes dimension markings and a 3-quart capacity.
Cons:
- The plastic lid is not intended for oven use.
- Its handles may take up more room in a crowded cabinet or fridge.
Verdict: Pick the OXO if you want a lidded baking dish with carrying-friendly handles and a lid designed for taking food to gatherings.
3. Sio Glass-Lid Dish: Best for an All-Glass Cover
Sio pairs a 9-by-13-inch borosilicate glass dish with a matching glass lid. The dish measures 2 inches deep, so it is a standard-depth choice rather than an extra-deep casserole pan. A silicone seal around the lid is intended to help keep stored food fresh and prevent leaks.
The product description lists the dish and lid as safe for the dishwasher, microwave, and freezer. For oven use, remove the lid; for microwave use, unlatch it. This is the only option in this comparison with a glass lid, which may appeal if you prefer to avoid storing food under plastic.
The glass lid is a different kind of trade-off: it avoids a plastic cover but adds another glass piece to handle and store. Its 2-inch depth may also be limiting for recipes that need more headroom. The listed seal is useful for storage, but follow the maker’s instructions for latching and use.
Pros:
- Glass dish and glass lid avoid a plastic cover.
- Silicone seal is designed to support freshness and help prevent leaks.
- Dish and lid are listed as dishwasher-, microwave-, and freezer-safe.
- Borosilicate glass is intended for casseroles, lasagna, cakes, and other baked dishes.
Cons:
- The lid must be removed for oven use and unlatched for microwave use.
- At 2 inches deep, it offers less height than the Pyrex deep dish.
Verdict: Choose the Sio if a glass lid and sealed storage are your priorities, and a standard-depth dish fits your cooking needs.
4. Sorbus Two-Dish Set: Best for Having a Spare Pan
The Sorbus listing describes a set of two 9-by-13-inch borosilicate glass baking dishes, each with a BPA-free lid. The dishes are listed as oven-safe up to 450°F. The rounded-corner design is described as stackable, which may help when storing both pans.
These dishes are intended for baking and storing casseroles, roasted meats, and other meals. The lids are described as snug-fitting and leak-resistant for fridge or freezer storage. Both the glass dishes and lids are listed as dishwasher-safe.
A two-pan set can be useful when you cook more than one dish at a time or want a second pan for meal prep. However, the product information provided marks this listing as unavailable. Check the listing before planning to buy, and confirm that its stated temperature limit suits your recipes.
Pros:
- Includes two 9-by-13-inch dishes and lids.
- Borosilicate glass is listed as oven-safe up to 450°F.
- Stackable shape may help save storage space.
- Dish and lid are listed as dishwasher-safe.
Cons:
- The supplied product information marks the listing as unavailable.
- The plastic lids are not listed as oven-safe.
Verdict: Consider Sorbus if you need two matching pans, but check availability and the stated oven limit before choosing it.
5. Vitrignis Dish and Carrier: Best for Potluck Transport
Vitrignis combines a 3-liter borosilicate glass dish with a plastic lid and an insulated carrying bag. The dish is described as shallow and suitable for casseroles, lasagna, roasted vegetables, and meal prep. The bag has an insulated lining and handles for carrying food to gatherings.
The product description lists the glass dish as safe for ovens, microwaves, steamers, and dishwashers. It gives a temperature range of -4°F to 752°F for the glass. The plastic lid is not oven-safe and, importantly for transport, is not described as leak-proof.
The carrier makes this set distinct from the other choices, but it does not replace a leak-resistant lid. If you plan to carry liquid-heavy food, take extra care to keep the dish level. The supplied product information also marks the listing as unavailable, so check the listing before making it your pick.
Pros:
- Includes an insulated bag for carrying hot or cold food.
- Borosilicate dish is listed as suitable for oven, microwave, steamer, and dishwasher use.
- 3-liter capacity works for meal prep and serving.
- Bag has handles and an insulated lining.
Cons:
- The plastic lid is not oven-safe or leak-proof.
- The supplied product information marks the listing as unavailable.
Verdict: This is the most transport-focused set, but it is a better fit for level, careful carrying than for spill-prone foods, and its availability needs checking.
How to Choose a 13×9 Baking Dish With a Lid
Match the Dish Depth to Your Recipes
A 13-by-9-inch dish can have different depths, and that affects how much food it can hold. The Pyrex is 2.75 inches deep, while the Sio is 2 inches deep. If you often make tall or layered casseroles, the deeper option may give you more room. For recipes that use a standard-depth pan, a shallower dish may be easier to store.
Check the Dish Material and Oven Instructions
All five options use glass, but their stated details differ. The Pyrex is described as safe for a preheated oven, and the OXO is made from borosilicate glass and described as thermal shock-resistant. Sorbus lists an oven limit of 450°F, while Vitrignis provides a temperature range for its dish. Follow the product’s instructions, especially when moving glass between cold and hot conditions.
Choose a Lid That Fits Your Storage and Transport Needs
A lid can help cover leftovers, but not every lid has the same purpose. The OXO lid is described as slosh-proof, and the Sio lid uses a silicone seal. Sorbus describes its lids as leak-resistant. Vitrignis specifically says its lid is not leak-proof, so the included carrier should not be taken as a substitute for a secure seal. Remove plastic lids before placing dishes in the oven.
Decide Whether You Want Glass or Plastic on Top
The Pyrex, OXO, Sorbus, and Vitrignis options have plastic lids, with the listed safety instructions varying by product. Sio includes a glass lid with a silicone seal. A glass lid avoids a plastic cover, but it is another glass piece to handle. Consider how you plan to store, reheat, and transport food before deciding which style works for you.
Think About Handling and Storage
Wide handles, stackable shapes, and carrying bags can make a difference when a dish is full. OXO highlights wide handles, Sorbus describes a stackable design, and Vitrignis includes an insulated bag. If refrigerator or cabinet space is tight, consider the dish’s depth and handle shape as well as its listed footprint.
Check Set Size and Availability
Most of these options are described as one dish with a lid, while Sorbus is listed as a two-dish set. A pair can be useful for cooking multiple dishes, but takes more storage space. The supplied information marks Sorbus and Vitrignis as unavailable, so confirm the current listing status before settling on either option.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I put the lid in the oven?
The listed lids are not described as oven-safe. Remove a plastic lid before baking. For the Sio dish, the product information also says to remove its glass lid for oven use.
Which option is the deepest?
The Pyrex dish is listed as 2.75 inches deep. The Sio is listed at 2 inches deep, and the supplied descriptions do not give a depth for every other option.
Which dish has a glass lid?
The Sio 9-by-13-inch dish comes with a matching glass lid and silicone seal. The other options in this comparison are described with plastic lids.
Which option is designed for carrying food?
OXO’s lid is described as slosh-proof, and its wide handles are designed to make gripping easier. Vitrignis includes an insulated carrying bag, but its product description says the lid is not leak-proof.
Can a glass baking dish go from the freezer directly into the oven?
The OXO description specifically says its thermal shock-resistant borosilicate glass can go from the freezer directly to the oven. Do not assume that instruction applies to every glass dish; follow the instructions for the model you choose.
Are the dishes dishwasher-safe?
The product information lists the Pyrex lid as top-rack dishwasher-safe. OXO, Sio, Sorbus, and Vitrignis are described as dishwasher-safe, though it is wise to check each product’s care instructions for both the dish and lid.
Final Recommendation
For most shoppers who want extra room for casseroles and a practical lid for storing leftovers, the Pyrex Deep 9×13 is the strongest all-around fit in this group. Choose the OXO if carrying and stacking matter more, or the Sio if you specifically want a glass lid. Sorbus offers two dishes, and Vitrignis adds a carrying bag, but the supplied product information marks both listings as unavailable. Check each listing’s instructions and availability before buying.
