A convertible crib can carry your child’s sleep space beyond the newborn months, but “5-in-1” does not mean every bed setup is ready out of the box. Toddler guardrails and full-size conversion parts are often sold separately, and some cribs add a changing station or storage that takes up more room. The picks below compare conversion options, materials, features, and the details worth checking before you buy.
| Crib | Conversion options | Standout feature | Best suited for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Graco Benton 5-in-1 Convertible Crib | Crib, toddler bed, daybed, full bed | GREENGUARD Gold certification | A classic, simple nursery setup |
| Suite Bebe Piper 5-in-1 Convertible Crib | Crib, toddler bed, daybed, full bed | New Zealand pine construction | Shoppers who value a wood-forward design |
| Dream On Me Storybrooke 5-in-1 Convertible Crib | Crib, toddler bed, daybed, full bed | GREENGUARD Gold certification | A traditional look in a pink finish |
| Graco Bellwood 5-in-1 Convertible Crib & Changer | Crib, toddler bed, daybed, full bed | Attached changing table and drawer | Nurseries that need built-in storage |
| Storkcraft Portofino 5-in-1 Convertible Crib and Changer | Crib, toddler bed, daybed, full bed | Changing table with drawers and shelves | Families who want changing and storage in one piece |
Conversion parts are not included with several models, and availability can change. Check each listing and the manufacturer’s instructions for current options before you plan a room around a particular crib.
Our Picks: Best Crib That Grows With Baby reviews
Graco Benton 5-in-1: A versatile, classic crib
The Graco Benton is a full-size crib with a classic look and several ways to reconfigure it as your child grows. It can be used as a crib, toddler bed, daybed, and full bed. Its white finish and simple lines make it an easy match for many nursery styles.
The crib is made with pine and wood composites, and it is GREENGUARD Gold certified. Its stated dimensions are 56.73 inches wide, 29.72 inches deep, and 41.68 inches high, so measure your room before choosing a spot. The product information describes assembly as a roughly 30-minute job and recommends two adults.
Plan for extra parts as your child moves through the bed stages: the toddler guardrail and crib-to-bed conversion kit are sold separately, as is the crib mattress. That added cost and the need to find compatible parts are the main trade-offs. Compared with the changer models below, the Benton also keeps the footprint simpler by leaving changing and storage furniture separate.
Pros:
- Offers four configurations, from crib to full bed
- GREENGUARD Gold certified
- Classic white design is easy to coordinate
- Dimensions and assembly guidance are provided
Cons:
- Toddler guardrail and full-bed conversion parts are sold separately
- Mattress is not included
Verdict: Choose the Benton if you want a straightforward convertible crib with a versatile finish and are comfortable sourcing conversion parts separately.
Suite Bebe Piper 5-in-1: A wood-forward, adaptable choice
The Piper is a full-size convertible crib made with FSC-compliant New Zealand pine solids and veneers. Its gently curved lower rail and simple back panel give it a clean, modern-transitional look. It converts from a crib to a toddler bed, daybed, and full-size bed.
Its mattress support has three height positions, allowing you to adjust the setup as your child grows. The product information says it meets or exceeds applicable CPSC standards and has been tested to Baby Safety Alliance standards. For later bed stages, conversion components and full-size bed rails are sold separately; check which parts are needed for the configuration you want.
Unlike the two changer models in this list, the Piper does not include an attached changing station or drawer, so you can arrange those pieces separately. That may suit a room where a less integrated layout is useful, but it means you will need other furniture for changing and storage.
Pros:
- Converts to toddler, day, and full-size bed configurations
- Three adjustable mattress-support positions
- Made with FSC-compliant New Zealand pine solids and veneers
- Simple design can work with different nursery styles
Cons:
- Conversion components and full-size bed rails are sold separately
- No attached changer or storage is listed
Verdict: The Piper is worth considering if you want a convertible crib with a wood-forward construction and a pared-back design, and you have room in your budget for separate conversion parts.
Dream On Me Storybrooke 5-in-1: A traditional crib in pink
The Storybrooke is a full-size wood crib with a pink finish and a traditional panel-and-slat design. It is designed to convert from a crib to a toddler bed, daybed, and full-size bed. Conversion kits and rails are sold separately, so check the parts list before counting on a later setup.
Its three-position mattress support lets you change the mattress height as your child grows. The product information also lists GREENGUARD Gold certification and Baby Safety Alliance verification, and says the crib was tested to applicable ASTM and CPSC standards. It measures 54 inches long, 29 inches wide, and 43 inches high.
The pink finish and more traditional shape make this a more specific style choice than the Benton or Piper. It may be a good fit if that look suits your nursery, but the color may be less flexible if you want a neutral piece that blends into a later bedroom. The supplied product information marks this option as unavailable; check the listing before making it part of your plan.
Pros:
- Converts to toddler, day, and full-size bed configurations
- Three adjustable mattress-support positions
- GREENGUARD Gold certified, according to the product information
- Traditional panel-and-slat design in a pink finish
Cons:
- Conversion kits and rails are sold separately
- Supplied listing data marks it as unavailable
Verdict: Consider the Storybrooke if you want its pink, traditional look and can confirm the crib and compatible conversion parts are available.
Graco Bellwood 5-in-1: A crib with an attached changer
The Bellwood combines a full-size crib with an attached changing table and an under-crib drawer. The changing table includes a water-resistant changing pad, and the drawer tracks are pre-installed. This built-in arrangement can keep changing supplies close at hand, though it also creates a larger piece of furniture than a crib alone.
The crib can convert to a toddler bed, daybed, and full bed. As with the Benton, the toddler guardrails and crib-to-bed conversion kit are sold separately, and the crib mattress is not included. It is GREENGUARD Gold certified and made with pine and wood composites. Its listed dimensions—71.38 inches wide, 29.45 inches deep, and 40.91 inches high—make checking available floor space especially important.
The extra width is the key trade-off: the Bellwood offers integrated changing and storage, but it may be harder to fit in a compact nursery. The supplied product information marks this option as unavailable, so confirm the listing and parts availability before choosing it.
Pros:
- Includes an attached changing table and water-resistant pad
- Under-crib drawer adds built-in storage
- Converts to toddler, day, and full-size bed configurations
- GREENGUARD Gold certified
Cons:
- Wide footprint needs careful room measurement
- Conversion parts are sold separately, and supplied listing data marks it as unavailable
Verdict: The Bellwood is a practical option for a larger nursery where an attached changer and drawer matter more than a compact footprint, if you can confirm availability.
Storkcraft Portofino 5-in-1: A changer with extra storage
The Portofino pairs a convertible crib with an attached changing table, three enclosed drawers, and two open shelves. Its traditional sleigh design and pebble gray finish give it a more decorative look than the simpler Benton. The changing pad is water-resistant and includes a safety strap, according to the product information.
It converts from a crib to a toddler bed, daybed, and full-size bed, with the toddler guardrail and conversion kit sold separately. The mattress support offers three height positions. The crib is GREENGUARD Gold certified and JPMA certified, and its listed materials include New Zealand pine, engineered wood, and wood composites.
The product information states that the crib may be used until a child can easily climb out or is taller than 35 inches. Follow the included instructions for use and transition timing. The supplied listing data marks the Portofino as unavailable, so check whether the crib and its conversion parts can be obtained before planning on this configuration.
Pros:
- Changing table includes drawers, open shelves, a pad, and a safety strap
- Three mattress-support height options
- Converts to toddler, day, and full-size bed configurations
- GREENGUARD Gold certified and JPMA certified
Cons:
- Attached changing station makes it a larger, less flexible piece
- Conversion kit is sold separately, and supplied listing data marks it as unavailable
Verdict: Choose the Portofino if you need built-in changing and storage in one substantial piece and can verify that the product and future conversion parts are available.
How to Choose a Crib That Grows With Baby
Check which conversions are included
A “5-in-1” label describes possible setups, not necessarily everything included in the box. Toddler guardrails, conversion kits, and full-size bed rails may be separate purchases. Before buying, identify the exact parts needed for the stages you expect to use and confirm that they are compatible with the crib model.
Look closely at mattress height adjustment
Several of these cribs have three mattress-support positions. Adjustable height can make it easier to reach a younger baby and lets you lower the mattress as your child develops. Follow the crib’s instructions on when to lower the support, and use only the positions and setup allowed by the manufacturer.
Measure the room and the crib
Compare the crib’s full dimensions with the space available, allowing room to move around it and open drawers or storage. The Bellwood, at more than 71 inches wide, takes up considerably more width than a crib-only design. An attached changer can save the need for a separate piece, but it limits how freely you can arrange the room.
Choose between an integrated changer and separate furniture
A built-in changing table and drawer or shelves can keep everyday items nearby. Models without a changer, such as the Benton and Piper, give you more choice about where to place a dresser or changing station. Think about your room layout and whether you want furniture that can be rearranged independently.
Review materials and certification details
Compare the listed materials, construction, and safety-related information rather than relying on style alone. Some options list GREENGUARD Gold certification, while the Piper describes its wood as FSC-compliant and the Portofino lists JPMA certification. Check the product documentation for the exact standards and proper setup, and follow all assembly and use instructions.
Plan for the later bed configuration
Full-size conversion may require separate rails or a conversion kit, and you will need a suitable mattress for that bed stage. If you expect to convert the crib later, check the manufacturer’s parts information before purchasing. A crib’s long-term value depends on having access to compatible parts, not just on the number of configurations listed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does “5-in-1 convertible crib” mean?
It generally means the crib is designed for several configurations, such as a crib, toddler bed, daybed, and full-size bed. The exact setup varies by model, and some configurations require separately sold guardrails, conversion kits, or rails.
Do these cribs include a mattress?
The product information says the Graco Benton and Bellwood mattresses are sold separately. Check the listing and instructions for the other models to confirm what is included and which mattress size is required.
Are toddler-bed guardrails included?
The Benton, Bellwood, and Portofino descriptions specify that the toddler guardrail is sold separately. For the Piper and Storybrooke, check the listing and conversion instructions to confirm the required parts.
Can any of these cribs convert to a full-size bed?
All five are described as having a full-size bed configuration. Conversion kits or bed rails may be sold separately, so confirm the exact parts needed for your model before making a purchase.
How do I know when to lower the crib mattress?
Use the manufacturer’s instructions to determine when to move the mattress support to a lower position. These cribs offer adjustable support, but the manual—not a general rule—should guide the setup for your specific model and child.
Which option is best for a small nursery?
A crib without an attached changer is generally easier to arrange as a standalone piece. Compare the listed dimensions with your room before deciding; the Bellwood’s listed width is notably larger because it includes a changer.
Which crib is the best overall choice?
The Graco Benton is a balanced pick if you want a classic convertible crib without an attached changing station. The Bellwood or Portofino may suit you better if built-in changing and storage are priorities, while the Piper stands out for its stated wood construction.
Final Recommendation
For a flexible, traditional crib without an attached changer, the Graco Benton is the clearest all-around choice in this group. If you need changing and storage built into the furniture, compare the Bellwood and Portofino footprints and confirm availability first. Whichever model you choose, check the required conversion parts, mattress fit, and manufacturer instructions before you buy.
