Australian Shepherds need more than a toy that sits in the basket: many enjoy active games that use their energy and natural urge to chase, push, or carry. The best dog toys for Australian Shepherds depend on how your dog likes to play. A herding ball can encourage outdoor movement, while a sturdy nylon chew toy offers a different kind of activity. Here’s how these five options compare, including important size and supervision notes.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Best for | Key detail |
|---|---|---|
| Frienhund Tough Dog Toys, 3 Pack | Supervised chewing | Three bacon-flavored nylon toys |
| YHPCZP Calming Jumbo Herding Ball | Outdoor pushing and chasing | Three size options; pump included |
| Pet Deluxe 18-Inch Herding Ball | Small-to-medium dogs that enjoy herding games | Heavy-duty cover; size guidance is weight-specific |
| Jolly Pets Jolly Egg, 8-Inch | Erratic outdoor chasing | Hard, egg-shaped toy that floats |
| MWATT 18-Inch Herding Ball | Large-dog outdoor play | Inflatable ball with grab straps |
Our Picks: Best Dog Toys For Australian Shepherds reviews
Frienhund Tough Dog Toys: A Three-Pack for Supervised Chewing
This three-pack of nylon chew toys is designed for dogs that like to gnaw. Each toy has a bone shape that’s easy to grasp, and the product description says the nylon is infused with bacon flavor. The pack gives you a few designs to rotate, which can be handy if one toy needs cleaning or a break.
The listed weight range is 30–75 pounds, making these a possible fit for some Australian Shepherds. The maker recommends limiting chewing sessions to about 10 minutes. That’s a useful reminder to supervise your dog and check the toys often, especially if your dog chews forcefully. No chew toy should be treated as indestructible.
Unlike the herding balls in this guide, this set is meant for chewing rather than chasing across a yard. It may suit a dog that settles with a chew, but it won’t provide the same kind of movement or interactive herding play.
Pros:
- Three toys in one pack for rotation or multi-dog homes
- Nylon construction and bone shapes designed for chewing
- Bacon flavor may help attract a dog’s interest
Cons:
- Not intended to replace active games or herding toys
- Requires supervision and regular checks for wear
Verdict: Choose this set if your Australian Shepherd enjoys chewing and falls within the stated weight range, but supervise each session and follow the maker’s time guidance.
YHPCZP Calming Jumbo Ball: A Size-Choice Herding Toy
This inflatable herding ball comes in 10-, 18-, and 22-inch sizes. A fabric cover sits over an inner bladder, and the package includes a pump and installation tools. Handles make it easier to carry or move the ball during play, while the removable cover can be machine-washed according to the supplied product details.
The important distinction is that this is a pushing and chasing toy, not a chew toy. The maker advises against it for aggressive chewers and recommends supervising play. Use it in an open area where your dog can roll the ball without running into obstacles, and stop play if the cover or bladder becomes damaged.
The different size choices make this a flexible option, but you’ll need to choose based on your dog and the space available. Compared with the Jolly Egg, it’s a larger inflatable toy with a cover; compared with a chew toy, it’s better suited to active outdoor play.
Pros:
- Available in three listed sizes
- Includes a pump and removable, machine-washable cover
- Handles help with carrying and interactive play
- Designed for pushing and chasing rather than chewing
Cons:
- Not recommended for aggressive chewers
- Requires inflation and supervision during play
Verdict: This is a useful pick if you want a covered, inflatable ball for supervised herding games and can match the size to your dog and play area.
Pet Deluxe 18-Inch Herding Ball: A Reinforced Option for Smaller Dogs
This 18-inch herding ball has a dual-layer cover made from high-density 900D fabric, with double-stitched seams, according to the product description. It’s designed for dogs to push and chase, and the listing calls out grass, dirt, sand, and other outdoor surfaces as places to use it. The inner bladder is described as puncture-resistant, and the ball comes with a pump.
Pay close attention to the size guidance: this ball is described as a fit for active small-to-medium dogs weighing 10–27 pounds. Although Australian Shepherds are named in the product description, the weight range may not fit many adult dogs of the breed. Check your dog’s weight before choosing it rather than relying on the breed name alone.
The maker also gives a specific inflation instruction: continue pumping until the cover is smooth and taut. That can help the ball take its intended shape, but it’s still important to check the cover and bladder for damage during use. It’s designed for herding, not chewing.
Pros:
- Reinforced, double-layer cover described for outdoor play
- Includes a pump for inflation
- Designed around pushing and chasing games
Cons:
- Listed weight range is only 10–27 pounds
- Not intended as a chew toy
Verdict: Consider this ball only if your dog fits the listed weight range; its herding-focused design may be appealing, but the fit is a key limitation for many Australian Shepherds.
Jolly Pets Jolly Egg: Erratic Rolling for Chase Games
The Jolly Egg uses an egg shape to roll unpredictably when a dog nudges it. Its hard, smooth surface is designed so a dog pushes and chases rather than picks it up in its mouth. The 8-inch size is listed for dogs up to 40 pounds, so check that limit against your dog’s weight before buying.
This toy floats, which adds the option of supervised play near a pool, lake, or beach. Its simple shape is different from a covered inflatable ball: there’s no bladder to pump or fabric cover to remove, but the hard surface may not suit every dog or every play space. The maker recommends supervision and says to discard the toy if parts become loose, detached, or damaged.
Compared with the other herding toys here, the Jolly Egg is a straightforward choice for dogs that like to push an unpredictable object. It isn’t a soft toy or a chew toy, and its size guidance may rule it out for larger dogs.
Pros:
- Egg shape creates an erratic roll for chasing
- Floats for supervised water play
- Does not require inflation or a removable cover
- Made in the USA, according to the product description
Cons:
- 8-inch size is listed for dogs up to 40 pounds
- Hard surface may not fit every dog’s play style
Verdict: Pick the Jolly Egg for a simple, hard-surface chase toy if your dog is within the listed size guidance and enjoys pushing rather than carrying toys.
MWATT 18-Inch Herding Ball: A Large Outdoor Play Option
This 18-inch ball is designed for outdoor herding-style play, with a fabric cover and grab straps for interactive games. The product description says the cover has reinforced stitching and describes the ball as weather-resistant and waterproof. Those are manufacturer claims, so inspect the toy regularly rather than assuming it cannot be damaged.
The straps offer a way to guide or move the ball during play, but they can also become a point of wear. Keep play supervised and check the stitching, cover, and ball before each session. The maker also presents it as an option for other large animals, but for a pet dog, the most relevant use is supervised pushing, chasing, and interaction outdoors.
Compared with the Pet Deluxe ball, both are 18-inch herding toys, but the Pet Deluxe listing provides a narrow weight range while the MWATT description does not give a dog weight limit. That makes it especially important to consider your dog’s size and play style, and to ask the seller for sizing guidance if needed.
Pros:
- 18-inch size and grab straps for interactive outdoor play
- Product description highlights reinforced stitching
- Maker describes the design as weather-resistant and easy to rinse
Cons:
- Product description does not provide a dog weight range
- Durability claims should not replace regular inspection and supervision
Verdict: This may suit an Australian Shepherd that enjoys outdoor pushing games, but confirm the fit and treat the durability statements as product claims rather than a reason to leave play unsupervised.
How to Choose a Dog Toy for an Australian Shepherd
Match the toy to your dog’s play style
Start with what your dog actually enjoys. A dog that likes to push and chase may get more out of a herding ball or egg, while a dog that seeks out something to gnaw may prefer a chew toy. These toys serve different purposes, so a ball is not a substitute for a chew and a chew toy won’t provide the same active chasing game.
Check size and weight guidance
Look beyond the breed label and compare the product’s size guidance with your dog’s actual weight. For example, the Pet Deluxe ball is described for dogs weighing 10–27 pounds, while the Jolly Egg’s 8-inch size is listed for dogs up to 40 pounds. If your dog falls outside the stated range—or the maker gives no range—check the product details before ordering.
Know whether it is for chewing or pushing
Herding balls are made for dogs to push or chase, not to chew. The YHPCZP product specifically warns against use by aggressive chewers. A nylon chew toy has a different purpose, but it still needs supervision and regular checks. Choose the right category for your dog, and remove any toy that is damaged or coming apart.
Consider where you will play
Inflatable balls need space to roll and may need setup before use. A covered model can offer a different surface from the Jolly Egg’s hard shell, while the Jolly Egg’s floating design may be useful for supervised water play. Think about your yard or play area, nearby obstacles, and whether you want a toy that can be carried or stored easily.
Plan for supervision and upkeep
Check the toy before and after play for loose stitching, damaged covers, cracks, or exposed inner parts. Follow the maker’s setup and cleaning instructions, and supervise active play—especially when a toy has straps or an inflatable bladder. For the Frienhund chew toys, the product description recommends sessions of about 10 minutes at a time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What kind of toy is best for an Australian Shepherd?
It depends on your dog’s habits. A herding ball or egg can encourage pushing and chasing, while a nylon chew toy is intended for dogs that like to gnaw. You may find that your dog benefits from having options for different types of play.
Can Australian Shepherds chew on herding balls?
Herding balls in this guide are designed mainly for pushing and chasing, not chewing. The YHPCZP listing specifically says it is not a chew toy and advises against it for aggressive chewers. Supervise play and put the ball away if your dog starts biting or tearing at it.
How do I choose the right herding ball size?
Check the product’s size and weight guidance and compare it with your dog’s weight. The Pet Deluxe listing gives a 10–27-pound range for its 18-inch ball, and the 8-inch Jolly Egg is listed for dogs up to 40 pounds. When a listing doesn’t give a weight range, confirm fit with the seller.
Is the Jolly Egg suitable for a large Australian Shepherd?
The 8-inch Jolly Egg is listed for dogs up to 40 pounds. If your dog weighs more than that, this size may not be the right fit; check whether another size is available before choosing it.
Are nylon chew toys indestructible?
No toy should be considered indestructible. Supervise chewing, follow the maker’s instructions, and inspect the toy for damage. Remove it if it becomes loose, broken, or unsafe to use.
Can these herding toys be used indoors?
They are best suited to areas where a dog can safely push and chase them without hitting furniture or other obstacles. The product descriptions emphasize outdoor settings, so check the available space and supervise your dog wherever you play.
Final Recommendation
For an Australian Shepherd that loves to push and chase, the Jolly Pets Jolly Egg offers a simple erratic-roll design, while the YHPCZP and MWATT balls provide larger covered-ball options for outdoor games. The Pet Deluxe ball may suit smaller dogs within its listed weight range. If your dog prefers chewing, the Frienhund nylon pack is the dedicated chew option here. Whichever toy you choose, match it to your dog’s size and play style, supervise use, and replace it if it becomes damaged.
