Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Storage & Dining

Best Food Scrap Container For Countertop: 5 Top Picks Compared

Updated 10 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 10minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

A countertop food scrap container gives you a handy place to collect peels, coffee grounds, and other kitchen waste before you take them to an outdoor compost pile or food-waste collection point. The right choice depends on how much space you have, how often you empty the bin, and whether you prefer a charcoal filter, a sealed lid, or a removable inner bucket. These five options offer different approaches to capacity, cleanup, and odor control.

Quick Comparison

ProductCapacityMaterial or designOdor-control approachBest for
Utopia Kitchen Countertop Compost Bin1.3 gallonsStainless steelCharcoal filtersA durable, classic countertop bin
OXO Good Grips Easy-Clean Compost Bin1.75 gallonsSmooth interior; bag-tucking designSoft-close, ventilated lidBusy kitchens needing more capacity
Holismo Kitchen Countertop Compost Bin1.3 gallons / 5 litersCoated galvanized ironReplaceable charcoal filterA family-sized bin with a filter cartridge
Epica Kitchen Compost Bin1.3 gallonsStainless steel, one-piece bodyReplaceable charcoal filterSimple stainless-steel construction
Dullrout Compost Bin for Countertop1.13 gallonsStainless-steel exterior and plastic inner bucketAirtight flip lidEasy emptying and a compact footprint

Our Picks: Best Food Scrap Container For Countertop reviews

Utopia Kitchen: A Durable Stainless-Steel Bin for Daily Scraps

The Utopia Kitchen bin is a straightforward choice if you want a countertop container with a familiar stainless-steel look. Its 1.3-gallon capacity gives you room for everyday scraps, while its cylindrical shape keeps the design simple. It measures 7.2 inches wide and 11.2 inches high, so check your available counter or cabinet clearance before choosing a spot.

A lid with charcoal filters is designed to help trap odors while scraps collect. The metal body is described as resistant to scratching, cracking, and chipping, which makes it a practical option for regular kitchen use. The bin does not have a removable inner bucket, so emptying means lifting and tipping the container itself.

For easier care, the product information recommends draining excess moisture and lining the bottom with newspaper or cardboard to absorb liquid. A weekly rinse with water and mild soap or vinegar is also suggested. Compared with the Dullrout, it has a slightly larger stated capacity but lacks that model’s removable inner bucket.

Pros:

  • 1.3-gallon capacity for routine food scraps
  • Stainless-steel body with a classic countertop appearance
  • Charcoal filters help reduce odors
  • Simple shape and care instructions

Cons:

  • At 11.2 inches high, it may not fit under every cabinet
  • No removable inner bucket for carrying scraps to an outdoor bin

Verdict: Choose the Utopia Kitchen bin if you want a simple stainless-steel container with charcoal odor control and do not need a removable liner.

OXO Good Grips: A Larger Bin with a Stay-Open Lid

The OXO Good Grips bin has the largest stated capacity in this group at 1.75 gallons. Its bag-tucking design helps keep a liner edge out of sight, while the smooth interior is intended to make cleaning easier. The lid can stay open while you prepare food, then close softly when you are finished.

Unlike the charcoal-filter models here, this bin’s odor-control approach uses a lid that allows oxygen to flow through. The product information says this design contains odors and helps reduce pests, but it does not list a charcoal filter. The lid is removable for emptying, which can make access easier.

One important buying consideration is availability: the supplied product information marks this item as unavailable. Availability can change, so check the listing before planning around this option. If it is available, its larger capacity may suit a busy kitchen; if not, the 1.3-gallon bins provide similar everyday collection in a smaller size.

Pros:

  • Largest stated capacity of these five options
  • Stay-open lid makes it easier to add scraps during food prep
  • Smooth interior is designed for easier cleaning
  • Removable lid and bag-tucking design

Cons:

  • Marked unavailable in the supplied product information
  • Uses a ventilated lid rather than a charcoal filter

Verdict: Consider the OXO if you want more capacity and a lid that stays open, but verify availability and make sure its ventilated design fits your odor-control preferences.

Holismo: A Family-Sized Bin with a Replaceable Filter Cartridge

The Holismo bin holds 1.3 gallons, or 5 liters, and measures 7.08 by 7.08 by 8.66 inches. That relatively compact footprint may be useful when counter space is limited, while the stated capacity gives you room to collect a range of kitchen scraps. Its coated galvanized-iron body has handles for carrying the container.

Ventilation holes in the lid allow air to circulate, and a charcoal filter cartridge is included to help absorb odors. The manufacturer says each cartridge lasts three to four months and is replaceable. That planned filter replacement is worth considering if you want odor control without replacing the whole bin.

The listing describes this as easy to clean, but does not specify a removable inner bucket. Compared with the taller Utopia Kitchen and Epica models, the Holismo’s listed height is shorter. Its coating and filter features are appealing, though you will need to keep up with filter replacement and clean the container regularly.

Pros:

  • 1.3-gallon capacity in a shorter listed design
  • Coated galvanized-iron construction with carrying handles
  • Charcoal filter cartridge is replaceable
  • Ventilation holes allow air circulation through the lid

Cons:

  • Filter replacement adds an ongoing maintenance step
  • No removable inner bucket is specified

Verdict: The Holismo is a good fit if you want a compact, 1.3-gallon bin with handles and a replaceable charcoal filter cartridge.

Epica: A One-Piece Stainless-Steel Bin with Replaceable Filters

The Epica is a 1.3-gallon stainless-steel countertop bin with a one-piece molded body. Its listed dimensions are 7.16 inches in diameter and 11 inches high, making it similar in capacity and general footprint to the Utopia Kitchen model. The stainless-steel construction is described as resistant to rust and scratches, and the body is designed to resist leaks.

Its lid uses a replaceable activated-charcoal filter to help reduce kitchen odors. The product information says a filter lasts three to six months with regular use. Epica recommends emptying and cleaning the bin weekly, and says filters can be rinsed gently and air-dried to extend their life; they should not be saturated.

The one-piece body may mean fewer interior parts to manage, but it also means there is no removable inner bucket listed for carrying scraps. Compared with the Holismo, the Epica has a taller, rounder profile and a stated filter lifespan that varies across a wider range. It suits shoppers who prefer stainless steel and a simple, hand-washable design.

Pros:

  • 1.3-gallon capacity with stainless-steel construction
  • One-piece body is designed to resist leaks
  • Replaceable charcoal filter helps reduce odors
  • Filter can be gently rinsed and air-dried, according to the product information

Cons:

  • At 11 inches high, it may not fit beneath low cabinets
  • No removable inner bucket is specified

Verdict: Pick the Epica if you want a traditional stainless-steel bin with a one-piece body and a replaceable charcoal filter.

Dullrout: A Compact Bin with a Removable Inner Bucket

The Dullrout has a 1.13-gallon capacity and a low, rectangular shape. Its listed dimensions are 9.9 inches long, 7.4 inches wide, and 6.8 inches high, so it may work where a taller cylindrical bin would be inconvenient. The exterior combines stainless steel and plastic, and the product information describes the materials as resistant to fingerprints, scratches, cracks, and chips.

Instead of a charcoal filter, this model uses a flip lid that closes to help contain odors. A press button opens the lid, and an anti-slip base is intended to keep the bin stable on the counter. The removable inner bucket is a useful difference: you can lift it out for emptying and washing without carrying the entire exterior container.

Its capacity is smaller than the 1.3-gallon options and much smaller than the OXO, so it may need more frequent emptying in a busy household. On the other hand, its lower profile and removable bucket make it a practical choice for shoppers who value easy handling and cleanup over maximum volume.

Pros:

  • Low-profile shape can suit counters with limited vertical clearance
  • Removable inner bucket simplifies emptying and washing
  • Flip lid is designed to help contain odors
  • Anti-slip base helps keep the bin stable on the counter

Cons:

  • Smallest stated capacity among the five options
  • Uses a sealed lid rather than a charcoal filter system

Verdict: Choose the Dullrout if a low profile and removable inner bucket matter more to you than maximum capacity.

How to Choose a Countertop Food Scrap Container

Match the capacity to your routine

Think about how many scraps your household produces and how often you plan to empty the bin. A larger container can hold more between trips, but it may take up more counter space and allow scraps to sit longer. The OXO has the largest stated capacity at 1.75 gallons, while the Utopia Kitchen, Holismo, and Epica each hold 1.3 gallons. The Dullrout is smaller at 1.13 gallons.

Measure your counter and cabinet clearance

Check both the space the bin will occupy and the room above it. The Utopia Kitchen and Epica are about 11 inches tall, while the Holismo is listed at 8.66 inches and the Dullrout at 6.8 inches. The OXO’s dimensions are not provided in the product information, so confirm them on the product listing if fit is a concern.

Choose an odor-control style

Several options use charcoal filters: the Utopia Kitchen has charcoal filters, and the Holismo and Epica use replaceable charcoal filters. The Holismo and Epica include stated replacement intervals, so factor in filter upkeep. The OXO uses a soft-close, ventilated lid, while the Dullrout relies on a flip lid that closes to help contain odors. No countertop bin can replace regular emptying and cleaning.

Consider how you will empty and wash it

A removable inner bucket can make it easier to carry scraps and clean the container, which is a feature listed for the Dullrout. The OXO has a removable lid and smooth interior. The Utopia Kitchen, Holismo, and Epica do not specify a removable inner bucket in the supplied details. If you prefer to avoid lifting a full outer bin, look closely at the emptying design before choosing.

Pick materials that suit your kitchen

Stainless steel gives the Utopia Kitchen, Epica, and Dullrout a metal exterior. The Holismo uses coated galvanized iron, while the OXO’s product information emphasizes its smooth interior and bag-tucking design rather than a specific body material. Consider the look you want, how you prefer to clean the bin, and whether you want a visible container that blends with your kitchen.

Remember that the bin only collects scraps

A countertop food scrap container is a temporary holding place, not a complete composting system. You still need to take the collected waste to a compost pile, food-waste collection service, or another suitable destination. Emptying the container regularly and following its care instructions can help keep the collection routine manageable.

Frequently Asked Questions

What can you put in a countertop food scrap container?

These containers are intended for collecting kitchen food waste. The Holismo product information gives examples such as tea leaves, flowers, coffee grounds, eggshells, fruit cores, and vegetable peels. Check the rules for your local composting program or destination, since accepted materials can vary.

Does a charcoal filter make a bin odor-free?

Charcoal filters are designed to help reduce odors, but they do not guarantee that a bin will never smell. The type and amount of scraps, how long they sit, moisture, cleaning, and filter condition can all matter. Empty and wash the bin as directed, and replace filters according to the product instructions.

How often should you empty a countertop bin?

It depends on the bin’s capacity, how much food waste you produce, and your household routine. The Utopia Kitchen information says scraps can build up for a full week with its charcoal filters, while Epica recommends emptying and cleaning weekly. If scraps become wet or smell sooner, empty the container more often.

Which option is easiest to empty?

The Dullrout has a removable inner bucket, making it possible to lift out the inner container rather than carry the full bin. The OXO’s lid is removable, which can make access easier. The other listed models do not specify a removable inner bucket.

Is the OXO bin currently available?

The supplied product information marks the OXO Good Grips bin as unavailable. Availability can change, so check its Amazon listing before deciding to buy it.

Can you use a liner in these bins?

The OXO’s design is described as keeping bags tucked inside for a neat look. The Utopia Kitchen information suggests lining the bottom with newspaper or cardboard to absorb liquid. The other supplied product details do not specify a particular bag or liner, so check the product instructions before adding one.

Final Recommendation

For a balanced everyday pick, the Utopia Kitchen offers a 1.3-gallon capacity, stainless-steel construction, and charcoal odor control. Choose the Epica for a similar-capacity stainless-steel option with a one-piece body and replaceable filter, or the Holismo if you prefer a shorter design with carrying handles. The Dullrout stands out for its removable inner bucket and low profile. If you want the most capacity, the OXO is the largest listed option, but check whether it is available before you choose it.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment