The best juicer for making orange juice depends on how much you make and how much control you want over pulp. A compact press-and-juice model can suit a glass at breakfast, while a larger pitcher or adjustable pulp settings can help when you’re serving more people. These five electric citrus juicers cover a range of needs, from a simple 24-ounce model to options with a stainless steel body or multiple pulp settings.
Quick Comparison
| Juicer | Capacity or standout feature | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Elite Gourmet 24 oz Electric Citrus Juicer | 24-ounce capacity; 40W motor; auto-reversing reamer | Small home batches and compact kitchens |
| Eurolux Premium Electric Orange Juicer | 120W motor; soft-grip handle press; stainless steel construction | Handle-operated juicing and a sturdier countertop design |
| Cuisinart Pulp Control Citrus Juicer | Three pulp settings; final-spin feature | Choosing how much pulp stays in your juice |
| BLACK+DECKER 32 oz Electric Citrus Juicer | 32-ounce pitcher; adjustable pulp control | Making a larger batch or measuring juice for recipes |
| Martha Stewart Electric Citrus Juicer | Two reamer sizes; pulp-control filter | Juicing different sizes of citrus fruit |
Our Picks: Best Juicer For Making Orange Juice reviews
Elite Gourmet: A Compact Pick for Small Batches
The Elite Gourmet is a straightforward electric citrus juicer with a 24-ounce, or 3-cup, capacity. Its 40W motor and auto-reversing reamer are designed to extract juice as you press fruit onto the cone. The listed capacity makes it a practical size for a few servings without taking up space like a larger batch-focused machine might.
A built-in spout and pulp-and-seed filter help keep pouring simple. The removable parts are top-rack dishwasher safe, though hand washing is recommended for the longest product life. Its BPA-free materials, compact design, and ETL listing may also appeal if you want a small appliance for a dorm, apartment, RV, or limited counter space.
The trade-off is capacity: 24 ounces may be limiting if you regularly make juice for a group. This model also provides a pulp-and-seed filter rather than multiple adjustable pulp settings, so it’s less suited to households that want to fine-tune the texture. Compared with the larger BLACK+DECKER pitcher or the Cuisinart’s three pulp settings, its appeal is simplicity and a smaller footprint.
Pros:
- Compact design with a 24-ounce capacity
- 40W motor and auto-reversing reamer
- Built-in pour spout and pulp-and-seed filter
- Removable parts are top-rack dishwasher safe
Cons:
- Smaller capacity than the 32-ounce BLACK+DECKER
- No listed adjustable pulp settings
Verdict: Choose the Elite Gourmet if you want a compact, easy-to-use citrus juicer for a few servings at a time.
Eurolux: A Handle-Press Juicer with Stainless Steel Construction
The Eurolux is an electric citrus juicer with a soft-grip handle press. Press the handle down to start the juicing process and release it to stop. Its 120W motor is described as quiet and powerful, while the automatic on/off function keeps the operation tied to pressing the handle rather than a separate switch.
Its integrated filter is designed to catch seeds and unwanted residue, and the one-size-fits-all cone is intended for different fruit shapes and sizes. The stainless steel construction gives it a more substantial countertop presence than a compact plastic-bodied option. The trade-off is that its larger design may be less convenient if you have little counter or storage space.
Unlike the Cuisinart and BLACK+DECKER, the supplied details do not list adjustable pulp settings or a measured juice container capacity. That makes the Eurolux a better match if handle operation and stainless steel construction matter more to you than a specific batch size or precise pulp adjustment.
Pros:
- Handle press starts and stops the juicing process
- 120W motor with automatic on/off operation
- Stainless steel construction
- Integrated filter and a cone designed for different citrus sizes
Cons:
- Larger design may take up more counter space
- Supplied details don’t specify a juice-container capacity or adjustable pulp settings
Verdict: Pick the Eurolux if you prefer a handle-operated press and stainless steel construction, and have room for a larger juicer.
Cuisinart: The Most Pulp Control in This Lineup
The Cuisinart Pulp Control Citrus Juicer stands out for its three pulp settings: low, medium, and high. Its adjustable reamer lets you choose a smoother or pulpier pour, which is useful when people in your household prefer different textures. The auto-reversing cone is designed for citrus ranging from small limes to large grapefruit, so it can handle more than oranges.
A final-spin feature is designed to extract more juice from the pulp, and the extra-long snap-up spout helps direct juice into a glass while reducing drips. The removable parts are dishwasher safe, and the product includes a limited three-year warranty. The supplied details don’t state the container capacity, so consider that if you plan to make larger batches in one go.
Compared with the Elite Gourmet’s simple filter, the Cuisinart gives you more control over pulp. The BLACK+DECKER lists a larger 32-ounce container, while the Cuisinart’s standout benefit is texture adjustment rather than a stated batch size.
Pros:
- Three pulp settings: low, medium, and high
- Auto-reversing cone and final-spin feature
- Long snap-up spout designed to reduce drips
- Dishwasher-safe parts and a limited three-year warranty
Cons:
- Container capacity isn’t stated in the supplied product details
- May be more features than you need if you prefer simple, unadjusted juice
Verdict: The Cuisinart is the strongest fit if choosing your pulp level is more important than having a specified large-capacity pitcher.
BLACK+DECKER: A Larger Pitcher for Batch Juicing
The BLACK+DECKER CJ625 pairs a 32-ounce clear juice container with adjustable pulp control. That larger stated capacity makes it worth considering if you want to make more than a glass or two before pouring. The container has measurement markings, a handle, and a spout, so you can use it to check the yield or serve juice directly.
Its auto-reversing cones are designed to help extract juice, while the removable pulp basket collects pulp for disposal or use in recipes. Pressure activation keeps operation simple: press the fruit onto the reamer to juice. The parts are dishwasher safe, according to the supplied product details.
Its batch-friendly pitcher gives it an advantage over the 24-ounce Elite Gourmet for larger servings. However, the product details don’t specify motor wattage or a set of pulp levels like the Cuisinart’s three options. If you want more precise pulp selection, the Cuisinart is the clearer match; if capacity and measurement markings are your priority, this BLACK+DECKER is more directly suited to the task.
Pros:
- 32-ounce clear container with measurement markings
- Adjustable pulp control and removable pulp basket
- Auto-reversing juicing cones
- Pitcher-style container has a handle and pour spout
Cons:
- Larger pitcher may be less compact than smaller juicers
- Supplied details don’t specify motor wattage or exact pulp settings
Verdict: Choose the BLACK+DECKER if you want a larger, marked container for making and serving a batch of citrus juice.
Martha Stewart: Two Reamer Sizes for Mixed Citrus
This Martha Stewart electric citrus juicer includes two reamer sizes for fruit ranging from small lemons and limes to oranges and grapefruit. Press the fruit onto the reamer to start juicing. Its removable pulp-control filter lets you choose between smoother juice and a more pulpy result, while the anti-drip spout holds juice until you’re ready to pour.
The compact design and non-slip base are intended to make it convenient for regular countertop use. All removable parts are listed as dishwasher safe, though hand washing is recommended. The supplied details don’t provide a capacity or motor wattage, so it’s harder to compare its batch size or power directly with the Elite Gourmet, Eurolux, and BLACK+DECKER.
Its two reamer sizes give it an advantage if you often switch between small citrus and larger fruit. For orange juice alone, that flexibility may matter less than the BLACK+DECKER’s stated pitcher capacity or the Cuisinart’s three pulp settings. It’s a versatile option for someone who wants one juicer for several kinds of citrus.
Pros:
- Two reamer sizes for different citrus fruit
- Removable pulp-control filter
- Anti-drip spout and non-slip base
- Compact design; removable parts are dishwasher safe
Cons:
- Supplied details don’t state capacity or motor wattage
- Two reamer sizes may be unnecessary if you only juice oranges
Verdict: The Martha Stewart juicer is a useful choice if you want a compact citrus tool with two reamer sizes and a pulp-control filter.
How to Choose an Electric Juicer for Orange Juice
Match the capacity to your usual batch
Think about how many glasses you make at once. The Elite Gourmet’s 24-ounce capacity is suited to a smaller batch, while the BLACK+DECKER’s 32-ounce container provides more room before you need to pour. The Cuisinart and Martha Stewart product details don’t state a container capacity, so check the product listing if batch size is a deciding factor.
Decide how much pulp control you want
If you like to adjust the texture, look for a juicer with clearly stated settings. The Cuisinart offers low, medium, and high pulp choices. The BLACK+DECKER has adjustable pulp control, though the supplied details don’t specify levels. The Elite Gourmet includes a pulp-and-seed filter, and the Martha Stewart has a removable pulp-control filter. These options differ, so consider whether you want set adjustments or simply a filter.
Consider the fruit you plan to juice
All five products are designed for citrus, but some offer more flexibility with fruit size. The Cuisinart is described as accommodating limes through grapefruit, while the Martha Stewart includes two reamer sizes for smaller and larger citrus. Eurolux describes its cone as a one-size-fits-all design. If you mainly make orange juice, a single reamer may be enough; if you also juice lemons, limes, or grapefruit, versatility may be useful.
Choose the operating style that feels right
The Elite Gourmet uses push-down activation, and the BLACK+DECKER uses pressure activation. The Eurolux uses a handle press that starts when you press down and stops when you release. The Martha Stewart also starts when you press fruit onto the reamer. Consider whether you prefer holding fruit directly or using a handle to press it.
Think about cleanup and storage
Removable parts can make it easier to rinse away pulp and seeds. The Elite Gourmet, Cuisinart, BLACK+DECKER, and Martha Stewart product details list dishwasher-safe parts, with hand washing recommended for the Elite Gourmet and Martha Stewart. A compact design may suit a small kitchen, while a larger juicer or pitcher may be a better fit if you have room to keep it on the counter.
Compare materials and listed features—not wattage alone
The Eurolux lists a 120W motor and stainless steel construction, while the Elite Gourmet lists a 40W motor. The supplied details don’t list wattage for the other models. Wattage alone doesn’t tell you the full experience, so weigh it alongside capacity, pulp control, operating style, construction, and cleanup. Also check the product listing for any detail that matters to you but isn’t provided here.
Frequently Asked Questions
What type of juicer is best for making orange juice?
An electric citrus juicer is designed to extract juice from oranges using a reamer. Choose a model based on your preferred batch size, pulp level, and how much counter space you have.
Which juicer in this list has the largest stated capacity?
The BLACK+DECKER has a 32-ounce juice container. The Elite Gourmet has a 24-ounce capacity. Capacity isn’t stated in the supplied details for the other three models.
Which option gives me the most control over pulp?
The Cuisinart lists three pulp settings: low, medium, and high. The BLACK+DECKER offers adjustable pulp control, but its supplied details don’t list specific levels.
Can these juicers handle fruit besides oranges?
They are citrus juicers, and their listed uses include fruit such as lemons, limes, or grapefruit. The Cuisinart is described as accommodating citrus from small limes to large grapefruit. The Martha Stewart model includes two reamer sizes for different citrus fruit.
Are the parts dishwasher safe?
The supplied details list dishwasher-safe removable parts for the Elite Gourmet, Cuisinart, BLACK+DECKER, and Martha Stewart models. For the Elite Gourmet and Martha Stewart, hand washing is recommended for product care. Check the product instructions for cleaning guidance.
Do I need a high-wattage juicer for oranges?
Not necessarily. Wattage is one feature to compare, but the supplied details don’t provide it for every model. Capacity, reamer design, pulp control, and ease of cleaning may matter just as much for your routine.
Final Recommendation
For a compact juicer with a stated capacity and a simple setup, the Elite Gourmet is a strong all-around choice for smaller batches. If you need more room for a batch, consider the BLACK+DECKER and its 32-ounce pitcher. Choose the Cuisinart for three pulp settings, the Eurolux for its handle press and stainless steel construction, or the Martha Stewart model if two reamer sizes are useful for your mix of citrus.