Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Buying Guide

Best Large Cocktail Ice Cube Maker: Top 5 Picks Compared

Updated 10 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 10minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

Large cocktail ice cubes chill a drink with less exposed surface area than small cubes, which can help slow melting and dilution. The right maker depends on what matters most to you: clear ice, a larger batch, easy storage, or straightforward removal. Here are five options, compared by their listed features and practical trade-offs.

Quick Comparison

ProductIce per batchStandout featureBest suited for
True Cubes Crystal Clear Ice Cube Maker4 large cubesDirectional freezing for clear iceClear cubes for a few carefully made drinks
FDDBI Large Ice Cube Trays, 2-Pack12 large cubesLids and a steel-reinforced rimRegular batches and tidy freezer storage
TINANA 2-Inch Clear Ice Cube Tray8 clear cubesClear-ice design with a stated 30–36-hour freezeMaking several clear cubes at once
GGUW Large Ice Cube Trays, 3-Pack18 large cubesThree lidded trays with reinforced rimsEntertaining or stocking up
Salty Squid Clear Ice Cube Maker10 large cubesInsulated directional-freezing designClear ice in a larger batch

Our Picks: Best Large Cocktail Ice Cube Maker reviews

True Cubes: A Clear-Ice Maker for Small Batches

The True Cubes mold is designed to make four clear, two-inch cubes per batch using directional freezing. It is a focused option for cocktails where the look of the ice matters as much as its size. The maker says to fill the tray with tap water and freeze it for 18–22 hours; no special additives or equipment are required.

The listed design uses BPA-free silicone, and the maker says its freezing process helps purify the water, including removing 98% of total dissolved solids and metals. Treat that as a product claim rather than a reason to skip clean water or careful handling. Compared with the multi-tray options below, its main trade-off is output: four cubes is a modest batch, so it may not suit frequent hosting.

Its stated freezing time is useful to know when planning ahead. This is not a quick-fill tray you can expect to freeze in a few hours, and the clear-ice process takes more freezer time than an ordinary open-cavity mold.

Pros:

  • Designed to make four clear, two-inch cubes per batch
  • Uses tap water without special additives or tools
  • BPA-free silicone construction
  • Clear-ice method is aimed at cocktails and spirits

Cons:

  • Four cubes per batch may be limiting for a gathering
  • Requires a long freeze of 18–22 hours

Verdict: Choose True Cubes if clear ice and a simple process matter more to you than making a large supply at once.

FDDBI 2-Pack: Lidded Trays for Everyday Use

This set includes two trays, each with six cavities for two-inch cubes, for a total of 12 cubes per batch. The individual cavities are made to let you push cubes out from the bottom, which is more convenient than twisting a full rigid tray. A removable lid helps keep ice covered in the freezer.

The silicone-wrapped steel rim is designed to add stability when carrying a filled tray. That detail matters with flexible silicone: without a firm edge, a full tray can be awkward to move from the sink to the freezer. The trays are also listed as dishwasher safe.

Unlike the clear-ice molds in this roundup, this set is primarily a practical large-cube tray; its description does not promise crystal-clear ice. The lids also need to be fitted carefully, so check that they are seated before stacking or carrying a filled tray.

Pros:

  • Two trays make 12 two-inch cubes per batch
  • Individual cavities are designed for easy release
  • Lids help shield ice from freezer odors
  • Steel-reinforced rims add stability when moving the trays

Cons:

  • Not specifically designed to make clear ice
  • Needs enough freezer space for two trays

Verdict: Pick the FDDBI set if you want a useful supply of large cubes and value covered, stackable storage over clear-ice results.

TINANA: Eight Clear Cubes in a Single Batch

The TINANA tray is built around making eight two-inch clear cubes at a time. Its description says the freezing design pushes air and impurities away from the cubes. That makes it a middle ground between the four-cube True Cubes mold and the higher-capacity clear-ice option from Salty Squid.

To use it, fill the cavities, close the lid, and freeze for 30–36 hours, according to the maker. That long wait means it is best for planning ahead rather than making ice on the day you decide to serve cocktails. The silicone construction and smooth surface are intended to help with releasing the finished cubes.

The eight-cube yield is handy if you serve clear ice regularly, but the product information does not specify the same reinforced frame described for some of the ordinary cube trays. Take care when moving it if it is full of water, and allow enough time for the longer freezing process.

Pros:

  • Makes eight two-inch cubes per batch
  • Designed to produce clear ice for cocktails and spirits
  • Flexible silicone is intended to make cube release easier
  • Higher clear-ice yield than the four-cube True Cubes mold

Cons:

  • Requires a stated freeze time of 30–36 hours
  • Needs advance planning for cocktail hour or entertaining

Verdict: Choose TINANA if you want a moderate batch of clear two-inch ice and can plan around its long freeze time.

GGUW 3-Pack: High Capacity for Parties and Gatherings

For sheer output, the GGUW set offers three trays with six cavities each, making 18 two-inch cubes per batch. Each tray has a fitted silicone lid, and the description says the trays can be stacked to save freezer space. That combination makes this set a practical choice when you want to prepare a larger supply of ordinary large cubes.

The silicone-wrapped steel frame is designed to help keep the trays steady while you carry them. Flexible cavities make it easier to push cubes out from below, and the trays are listed as dishwasher safe. They can also be used for freezing measured portions of food, though their main appeal here is cocktail ice.

This set is not described as a directional-freezing mold, so it is not the pick to choose specifically for clear ice. Its three trays may also take up more room than a single mold, even if the lids let you stack them. Consider your freezer space before buying.

Pros:

  • Three trays make 18 two-inch cubes per batch
  • Lids help keep ice covered and allow stacking
  • Reinforced rims are designed to make carrying easier
  • Dishwasher-safe trays offer convenient cleanup

Cons:

  • Not specifically designed to make clear ice
  • Three trays require more freezer room than a single mold

Verdict: Choose the GGUW set if batch size is your priority and you have room to store multiple lidded trays.

Salty Squid: A Larger Batch of Clear Cocktail Ice

The Salty Squid mold is designed to make 10 large, two-inch clear cubes in one batch. Its insulated design uses directional freezing to help push trapped air and impurities downward. It does not need an electric ice machine, making it an option for home bartenders who want clear ice without a powered appliance.

Its capacity sits between the eight-cube TINANA tray and the 12-cube FDDBI set, while also focusing on clear ice. Flexible silicone is intended to make removal easier. The maker says the large cubes melt more slowly than smaller ice, which can help reduce how quickly a drink dilutes; actual results will depend on the drink and serving conditions.

The supplied details do not give a specific freezing time or describe a reinforced carrying frame. You may need to plan ahead and handle the filled mold with care. If your main goal is simply to stock a freezer with large cubes, a multi-tray set may be a more straightforward fit.

Pros:

  • Makes 10 large, two-inch cubes per batch
  • Directional-freezing design is intended to create clear ice
  • Does not require an electric ice machine
  • Flexible silicone is designed for easier cube removal

Cons:

  • The supplied product details do not state a freezing time
  • Not as high-capacity as the 18-cube GGUW set

Verdict: Pick Salty Squid if you want clear ice in a larger batch than the four- or eight-cube molds provide.

How to Choose a Large Cocktail Ice Cube Maker

Decide Whether Clear Ice Matters

Clear ice is a visual choice as well as a functional one. If you want transparent cubes for drinks such as an Old Fashioned, look for a mold specifically described as using directional freezing. True Cubes, TINANA, and Salty Squid make that claim. The FDDBI and GGUW trays focus on large cubes, lids, and batch capacity rather than clear-ice production.

Match the Batch Size to Your Use

A smaller mold may be enough if you usually make one or two drinks at a time. For regular entertaining, count how many cubes the product makes in one batch: the options here range from four to 18. Remember that the listed number is a batch yield, not a guarantee that every cube will be used at once or that multiple trays will fit in your freezer.

Check the Freezing Time

Clear-ice molds can require a long freeze. The supplied details state 18–22 hours for True Cubes and 30–36 hours for TINANA. The Salty Squid description does not give a specific time, and the ordinary cube trays do not list one either. If you are planning for a gathering, prepare your ice well ahead and follow the instructions that come with the mold.

Consider Freezer Space and Stability

Look at both the number of trays and how they are built. Lidded trays can help keep ice covered, and some can stack. A silicone-wrapped steel rim, listed on the FDDBI and GGUW sets, is intended to make a filled tray easier to carry. If your freezer is crowded, a large multi-tray set may be less convenient than one compact mold.

Think About Cube Release and Cleaning

Flexible silicone and individual cavities can make it easier to push cubes out than with a rigid tray. Check whether the product is described as dishwasher safe if easy cleanup matters to you; the FDDBI and GGUW descriptions say their trays are dishwasher safe. With any flexible mold, handle it carefully when full of water and follow the maker’s cleaning instructions.

Choose the Right Balance of Practicality and Presentation

If you want everyday large cubes, a lidded tray set may offer the most straightforward mix of yield and storage. If clear ice is the main goal, focus on a mold designed for that process and accept that it may need more time and planning. Neither type makes sense for every drink or household, so base your choice on how often you serve cocktails and what you want the ice to look like.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do large ice cubes melt more slowly than small cubes?

Large cubes have less exposed surface area relative to their volume than smaller cubes, which can help them melt more slowly. The exact result depends on the drink, glass, and serving conditions.

Which of these makers is designed to produce clear ice?

True Cubes, TINANA, and Salty Squid are described as clear-ice makers. The FDDBI and GGUW products focus on making large cubes and do not specifically promise clear ice.

How long does it take to make clear ice?

The listed instructions say to freeze True Cubes for 18–22 hours and TINANA for 30–36 hours. The supplied Salty Squid details do not list a specific freezing time. Follow the instructions for your chosen mold.

Which option makes the most cubes in one batch?

The GGUW three-pack makes 18 two-inch cubes per batch, according to its description. The FDDBI two-pack makes 12, Salty Squid makes 10, TINANA makes eight, and True Cubes makes four.

Are silicone ice cube trays easy to empty?

Flexible silicone trays are designed to let you push cubes out from the bottom, and several products in this list describe their molds as easy-release. Results can depend on how firmly the ice has frozen, so follow the maker’s directions and avoid forcing the tray if cubes stick.

Can I stack trays in the freezer?

The FDDBI and GGUW descriptions say their lidded trays can be stacked. Make sure the lids are fitted and the trays are stable before stacking, especially if they are full of water.

Final Recommendation

For clear ice with the shortest stated freeze time among the clear-ice options here, True Cubes is a strong fit if four cubes per batch are enough. If you want a larger clear-ice batch, consider Salty Squid; if you prefer a lidded supply of ordinary large cubes for hosting, the GGUW three-pack offers the highest listed yield. Choose based on the ice you want, how many cubes you need, and how much freezer space you can spare.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment