Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Cookware & Kitchen Tools

Best Large Pizza Pan With Holes: 5 Top Picks Compared

Updated 10 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 10minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

A large perforated pizza pan lets hot air reach the underside of your pie, which can help reduce a soft or damp bottom crust. The right choice depends on more than diameter: consider how much usable baking space your oven has, whether you want one pan or a set, and whether features like cutting guides or handles matter to you. These five options include oversized 16-inch pans and smaller sets for everyday pizza nights.

Quick Comparison

Pizza PanSize and SetStandout FeatureBest For
GoodCook AirPerfect 16-Inch Pizza Pan16-inch, one panCutting guides and elevated feetLarge pizzas and easier serving
HONGBAKE 14-Inch Pizza Pan Set14-inch, two pansWide handles and molded feetBack-to-back batches
Nordic Ware Naturals 16-Inch Pizza Pan Set16-inch, two pansNatural aluminum constructionLarge pizzas and even heating
GoodCook AirPerfect 14-Inch Pizza Pan14-inch, one panInsulated design and cutting guidesEveryday family-sized pies
ritonis 14.7-Inch Pizza Pan Set14.7-inch, two pansStackable pans with nonstick finishMeal prep and different toppings

Our Picks: Best Large Pizza Pan With Holes reviews

GoodCook AirPerfect 16-Inch: Best Overall for a Large Pie

The GoodCook AirPerfect gives you a 16-inch baking surface for larger homemade or frozen pizzas. Its perforated design is intended to reduce moisture beneath the dough, while the nonstick carbon steel surface supports easier release. Cutting guides are built into the pan to help you portion slices more evenly.

Small details make this model practical beyond baking. Molded feet elevate the hot pan when you set it down, helping keep it off the countertop. The large diameter is its main advantage over the 14-inch GoodCook model, though you should check your oven’s usable rack space before choosing it.

The nonstick coating may make cleanup and serving simpler, but it also calls for care. Use utensils and cleaning methods that are suitable for coated bakeware, and avoid assuming the pan is safe for temperatures beyond the product’s stated directions.

Pros:

  • Large 16-inch size suits bigger pizzas.
  • Perforations help airflow beneath the crust.
  • Cutting guides support more even portions.
  • Elevated feet keep the hot pan off the counter.

Cons:

  • The large diameter may not fit comfortably in every oven.
  • Its nonstick coating requires careful handling.

Verdict: Choose this GoodCook if you want a large, coated pan with helpful serving features and have enough oven space for its 16-inch size.

HONGBAKE 14-Inch Two-Pack: Best for Easy Handling

This HONGBAKE set includes two 14-inch perforated pans. Each pan has a nonstick surface, molded feet, and wide handles. The handles extend the listed overall width to 15.75 inches, so allow for that extra space when checking storage or oven clearance.

The pans are made from 0.8 mm carbon steel, and the product description says they are designed not to warp at temperatures up to 450°F. That stated limit makes checking your recipe’s oven temperature important. The two-pan format can also be useful when you want to prepare a second pizza while the first is baking.

Compared with the 16-inch picks, these pans offer less room for a single large pie. Their handles may make them easier to grip and move, but they also add to the space the pans take up. The nonstick coating is another reason to follow the maker’s care instructions.

Pros:

  • Two pans support back-to-back baking.
  • Wide handles offer a dedicated grip area.
  • Perforations and molded feet promote airflow around the pan.
  • Product details specify a 450°F temperature limit.

Cons:

  • The 14-inch baking surface is smaller than the 16-inch options.
  • Handles increase the overall width beyond the pan diameter.

Verdict: Pick this set if you value two pans and wide handles more than having the largest possible baking surface.

Nordic Ware Naturals 16-Inch Set: Best for Aluminum Construction

Nordic Ware’s set includes two oversized 16-inch perforated aluminum pizza pans. The product description lists an interior diameter of 15.2 inches, an important distinction when comparing the usable cooking area with the pan’s overall size. The perforated center is designed to let air circulate beneath the crust.

Natural aluminum is the key difference here. Nordic Ware describes it as a material chosen for even heating and for helping shield the pizza from burning. Unlike the GoodCook picks, this set is not described as having a nonstick coating or cutting guides, so you may want to plan how you will release and portion your pizza.

Two large pans can help when you are preparing multiple pies, but they need more storage room than a single pan. As with any large bakeware, measure your oven and storage space before buying. The product is described as made in the USA.

Pros:

  • Includes two oversized 16-inch pans.
  • Perforated centers allow airflow beneath the pizza.
  • Natural aluminum is selected for even heating.
  • Product details specify a 15.2-inch interior diameter.

Cons:

  • No nonstick coating is specified.
  • The set needs more storage space than a single pan.

Verdict: This set is a strong fit if you want two large aluminum pans and prefer that material over a coated carbon steel design.

GoodCook AirPerfect 14-Inch: Best for Cutting Guides

This 14-inch GoodCook pan uses an insulated, perforated design to help reduce moisture during baking. It has a nonstick carbon steel surface and cutting guides, making it a practical option for homemade pizza, frozen pies, and reheating slices.

Like the 16-inch GoodCook model, it has molded feet to elevate the hot pan off a countertop. The smaller diameter may be easier to fit in compact ovens or store in a crowded kitchen, but it gives you less room for a large pie. Its cutting guides are a useful extra if you want help dividing the pizza into even portions.

This model is a more compact alternative to the 16-inch GoodCook, not a different approach to baking. Choose between them based mainly on the size of pizza you make and the space available in your oven.

Pros:

  • 14-inch size suits family-sized pies without the footprint of a 16-inch pan.
  • Perforated, insulated design is intended to support a crispier crust.
  • Cutting guides help with portioning.
  • Nonstick carbon steel supports easier release.

Cons:

  • Smaller baking surface than the 16-inch models.
  • Coated surfaces need appropriate care to help preserve the finish.

Verdict: Choose this pan if you want GoodCook’s cutting guides and elevated feet in a more compact 14-inch size.

ritonis 14.7-Inch Two-Pack: Best for Stacking and Meal Prep

The rიტonis set has two 14.7-inch perforated carbon steel pans with a nonstick finish. The holes are intended to let hot air move beneath the dough, while the coating is designed to help pizza release and reduce baked-on residue. The pans are described as stackable for more organized storage.

Each pan is made from 0.5 mm carbon steel and weighs about 478 grams, according to the product details. That gives you a stated material thickness and weight to compare with the HONGBAKE set, which lists thicker 0.8 mm carbon steel. The rитonis pans are also a little larger in diameter than the 14-inch options, though the product advises checking your oven space before ordering.

Two pans can be useful for preparing separate pizzas with different toppings or for baking in batches. The trade-off is that this set lacks the listed handles and cutting guides found on some alternatives. Its stated coating test information may interest shoppers comparing food-contact coating details, but it does not replace following the manufacturer’s use and care instructions.

Pros:

  • Two pans can support separate toppings or consecutive batches.
  • Perforations are designed to promote airflow beneath the crust.
  • Stackable design helps with storage.
  • Nonstick finish is intended to support food release and cleanup.

Cons:

  • Product details list thinner 0.5 mm carbon steel than the HONGBAKE pans.
  • No handles or cutting guides are specified.

Verdict: Consider this set if stackable storage and two nonstick pans matter more to you than built-in handles or cutting guides.

How to Choose a Large Pizza Pan With Holes

Match the Pan Size to Your Oven

A pan’s listed diameter is not always the same as its usable cooking area. The Nordic Ware set, for example, has an overall 16-inch diameter and a listed 15.2-inch interior diameter. Handles can add width, too: the HONGBAKE pans measure 15.75 inches across when the handles are included. Check your oven’s rack and door clearance, not just the rack width.

Think About How Perforations Fit Your Pizza Style

Perforations let air reach the underside of the dough, which is why these pans are designed to help make a crisper crust. They are a useful feature for homemade and frozen pizza, but they may not suit every dough or topping combination. If you use a particularly wet dough or a lot of toppings, consider how the pan’s holes could affect the way you handle and bake your pie.

Choose a Material and Finish You Can Maintain

Carbon steel and aluminum are both represented here. The GoodCook, HONGBAKE, and rитonis pans use carbon steel; Nordic Ware uses natural aluminum. Several options have a nonstick coating, while the Nordic Ware product details do not specify one. If you choose a coated pan, follow its care directions and use suitable utensils and cleaning methods.

Decide Whether One Pan or Two Is More Useful

A single pan takes up less storage space and may be enough for occasional pizza nights. A two-pan set can help you prepare separate pies or move on to another batch without waiting for the first pan to cool. Sets are larger to store, so consider where you will keep them between uses.

Look for Features That Make Serving Easier

Cutting guides can help you divide a pie into more even slices, while molded feet elevate a hot pan from the counter. Wide handles give you a dedicated grip area, but add to the pan’s overall footprint. Prioritize the feature you will use most rather than paying for a design detail that does not fit your routine.

Check Temperature and Care Information

Do not assume every pan has the same oven limit or care requirements. HONGBAKE specifies that its pans are designed not to warp up to 450°F; the other product descriptions do not provide a matching temperature limit. Check the product instructions and make sure your recipe’s baking temperature falls within the stated guidance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do holes in a pizza pan help make the crust crisp?

Perforations allow hot air to circulate beneath the pizza. These pans are designed to reduce moisture under the crust and encourage a crisper result, though the outcome also depends on your dough, toppings, oven, and baking method.

Will a 16-inch pizza pan fit in a standard oven?

It depends on the oven’s usable rack space and the pan’s overall dimensions. Measure the interior width and depth, and account for any handles or raised edges. The Nordic Ware product lists a 16-inch overall diameter and a 15.2-inch interior diameter.

Are perforated pizza pans suitable for frozen pizza?

The GoodCook 16-inch and 14-inch product descriptions specifically list frozen pizza among their uses. HONGBAKE and rитonis also describe their pans for frozen or everyday pizza baking. Check your pizza’s instructions and the pan’s care details before use.

Should I choose carbon steel or aluminum?

That depends on your preference and the features you need. Most pans here use carbon steel, and several have nonstick coatings. The Nordic Ware set uses natural aluminum and is described as designed for even heating. Compare material, coating, size, and care instructions together.

Are nonstick pizza pans dishwasher-safe?

The supplied product details do not confirm dishwasher safety for these pans. Check the care instructions for the specific model rather than assuming it can go in the dishwasher. For coated pans, follow the manufacturer’s guidance to care for the finish.

What is the benefit of buying a two-pan set?

A pair can help you prepare two pizzas with different toppings or bake another pie in a separate pan. The trade-off is the extra storage space needed. If you make pizza only occasionally, a single pan may be enough.

Final Recommendation

For a large single pan with practical serving features, the GoodCook AirPerfect 16-Inch is the most balanced choice: it combines perforations, a nonstick surface, cutting guides, and elevated feet. If you want two oversized aluminum pans, consider Nordic Ware; if you prefer two pans with wide handles, look at HONGBAKE. Before ordering any of them, confirm the pan’s full dimensions fit your oven and storage space.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment