Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Buying Guide

Best Natural Soap For Dry Skin

Updated 10 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 10minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

Dry skin often feels tight or uncomfortable after washing, so the right soap should clean without making that feeling worse. The options below range from plant-oil bars to goat milk and tallow formulas, with different scents and ingredient choices. Compare the details carefully: “natural” does not guarantee that a soap will suit every skin type, and essential oils or fragrance can bother sensitive skin.

Quick Comparison

SoapNotable featuresBest suited for
Crate 61 Organics Handmade Bar SoapPlant oils, shea butter, essential oils, and clayShoppers who want a plant-based bar with natural scents
Erbaid Dead Sea Magnesium SoapDead Sea magnesium, coconut oil, lavender, and chamomilePeople interested in a lightly scented bar
Natrulo Grass-Fed Tallow SoapUnscented, dye-free formula made with grass-fed tallowThose seeking an unscented, animal-fat-based option
Erbaid Oatmeal and Calendula SoapOatmeal soap and calendula; intended for face and bodyShoppers looking for a gentle-feeling bar for dry skin
Southern Natural Goat Milk SoapGoat milk, olive oil, coconut oil, and fragrance oilThose who want a three-bar set with a sweet scent

Our Picks: Best Natural Soap For Dry Skin reviews

1. Crate 61 Organics: A Plant-Based Bar With Essential Oils

Crate 61 Organics makes this cold-process bar by hand in Canada. Its listed ingredients include olive oil, coconut oil, shea butter, avocado oil, and kaolin clay. The brand says it uses essential oils for aroma and mineral, clay, and plant extracts for color, rather than synthetic dyes.

The formula may appeal if you want a plant-based bar with a traditional soap-making approach. The brand offers multiple scents, so check the selected option before ordering. Essential oils are still fragrant ingredients, though, and may not be the right choice if your skin is sensitive to scent.

Compared with the unscented Natrulo tallow bar, this one is a better fit for shoppers who specifically want a scented, plant-based soap. It is less straightforward for fragrance-sensitive households. The product details also do not list the exact ingredient proportions, so you may want to check the package information if you have known sensitivities.

Pros:

  • Made with several plant oils and shea butter
  • Uses essential oils and natural colorants, according to the brand
  • Packaged in recycled kraft paperboard
  • Offers a choice of scents

Cons:

  • Essential oils may not suit fragrance-sensitive skin
  • The listed information does not give ingredient proportions

Verdict: Choose Crate 61 if you want a plant-based, scented cold-process bar; consider an unscented option if fragrance tends to bother your skin.

2. Erbaid Dead Sea Magnesium Soap: A Lightly Scented Bar

This bar is made with Dead Sea magnesium, coconut oil, and essential oils including lavender and chamomile. It is described as a daily-use soap for different skin types, including dry and sensitive skin. The brand also says it is made in the USA and is cruelty-free.

The lavender and chamomile give this option a clear place in the comparison: it is for someone who wants a scented bar, not an unscented one. The listing describes the soap as exfoliating and soothing, but those product claims should not be taken as a promise to treat itching, muscle tension, or a skin condition. A rinse-off soap is not a substitute for care from a health professional.

For dry skin, the coconut oil may be a welcome ingredient, but the product details do not provide a full ingredient breakdown or specific proportions. If you are sensitive to essential oils, check the full label before use. Compared with Crate 61, this bar has a more specific magnesium-and-essential-oil focus; compared with Natrulo, it is fragranced.

Pros:

  • Includes coconut oil and Dead Sea magnesium
  • Lavender and chamomile provide a naturally scented option
  • Described as suitable for daily use and multiple skin types
  • Brand states it is cruelty-free

Cons:

  • Essential oils may be unsuitable for people who avoid fragrance
  • Claims about soothing or exfoliating are not a guarantee of results

Verdict: Consider this bar if you want a scented magnesium soap for everyday cleansing, but choose a fragrance-free formula if your skin reacts to essential oils.

3. Natrulo Grass-Fed Tallow Soap: An Unscented Choice

Natrulo’s bar is made with grass-fed tallow and described as unscented, dye-free, and hypoallergenic. The listing says it is handmade in small batches in the USA and can be used on the face and body. Its simple scent profile may be appealing if you prefer to avoid essential oils and added fragrance.

This is the clearest option here for shoppers looking for a fragrance-free bar, though “unscented” does not mean every ingredient will suit every person. The product is animal-derived, so it will not fit a vegan or fully plant-based routine. If you have a known sensitivity, read the complete label rather than relying only on broad terms such as “gentle” or “hypoallergenic.”

Compared with the plant-oil bars in this list, Natrulo takes a different approach by using tallow as its central ingredient. Its face-and-body positioning makes it a versatile option, but it is not presented as a treatment for eczema or other skin conditions. Stop using any soap that causes irritation.

Pros:

  • Described as unscented and dye-free
  • Made with grass-fed tallow
  • Intended for both face and body
  • Handmade in small batches in the USA, according to the brand

Cons:

  • Not suitable for shoppers who avoid animal-derived ingredients
  • The listed description does not provide a full ingredient breakdown

Verdict: Natrulo is a strong option to consider if you want an unscented tallow bar and do not require a plant-based formula.

4. Erbaid Oatmeal and Calendula Soap: A Face-and-Body Bar

This Erbaid bar is described as a goat milk soap made with oatmeal soap and calendula. It is intended for face and body use and marketed for dry, itchy, and sensitive skin. The brand says it is handmade in the USA and made with natural ingredients and essential oils.

Its focus on oatmeal and calendula may make it worth considering if you want a bar positioned for gentle cleansing. However, the product description makes claims about relief for eczema, psoriasis, and irritation. Those are health-related claims, not a guarantee that the soap will treat or prevent a condition. If you have persistent or severe symptoms, ask a healthcare professional for advice.

One detail to note: despite the oatmeal reference, the listing says this soap does not contain oatmeal or honey. Check the full ingredient list if you are looking for a bar with a particular ingredient or need to avoid a potential trigger. Since the listing also mentions essential oils, this may not be the best pick for someone avoiding fragrance.

Pros:

  • Designed for use on both face and body
  • Includes goat milk and calendula, according to the description
  • Made for shoppers seeking a bar marketed to dry and sensitive skin
  • Handmade in the USA, according to the brand

Cons:

  • The listing says it does not contain oatmeal or honey
  • Contains essential oils, which may not suit fragrance-sensitive skin

Verdict: Consider this bar if you want a goat milk soap marketed for face and body, but verify the ingredient list and do not rely on it to treat a skin condition.

5. Southern Natural Goat Milk Soap: A Three-Bar Oatmeal Milk and Honey Set

This set includes three goat milk soap bars in an Oatmeal Milk & Honey scent. The listed ingredients include olive oil, coconut oil, and goat milk. Southern Natural describes the soap as suitable for face and body and says the scent comes from fragrance oil without parabens or sulfates.

The three-bar format may suit a household that wants multiple bars on hand or prefers to stock up. Its sweet scent is a key difference from Natrulo’s unscented option. Although the name includes oatmeal and honey, the product description specifically says the soap does not contain oatmeal or honey, so do not choose it expecting those ingredients.

The brand describes the bar as moisturizing and suitable for several age groups, but individual skin can react differently to fragrance and soap ingredients. If you are shopping for someone with sensitive skin, check the full label and consider a fragrance-free product first. Compared with the other picks, this set offers a clearly stated multi-bar format and a scented goat milk formula.

Pros:

  • Three bars are included in the set
  • Contains goat milk, olive oil, and coconut oil
  • Intended for face and body use
  • Fragrance oil is described as free of parabens and sulfates

Cons:

  • The product does not contain oatmeal or honey despite the scent name
  • The fragrance may not suit people who prefer unscented soap

Verdict: Choose Southern Natural if you want a three-bar goat milk set with a sweet fragrance, but skip it if you need actual oatmeal or honey in the formula.

How to Choose a Natural Soap for Dry Skin

Read the full ingredient list

Look beyond the product name and marketing claims. Check the complete label for oils, fats, fragrances, essential oils, and other ingredients you may want to avoid. If you have a known allergy or sensitivity, compare the ingredient list with products you already know you tolerate. “Natural” is not a guarantee that a formula will be gentle for everyone.

Decide whether you want fragrance

Some bars in this guide use essential oils or fragrance oil, while Natrulo is described as unscented. Fragrance can be an important part of the bathing experience, but it can also be a concern for people with sensitive skin. If you are unsure how your skin will respond, an unscented option may be a more cautious starting point.

Choose ingredients that fit your preferences

These soaps use different base ingredients, including plant oils, goat milk, and tallow. Consider whether you prefer a plant-based formula, want to avoid animal-derived ingredients, or are interested in a particular soap base. Product names can be misleading: Southern Natural’s scented soap does not contain oatmeal or honey, and Erbaid’s oatmeal-and-calendula listing says it does not contain oatmeal or honey. Verify the details before buying.

Be careful with skin-condition claims

Some products are marketed for eczema, psoriasis, itching, or irritation. A soap’s marketing does not prove that it can treat a skin condition. If you have ongoing, painful, or severe symptoms, consult a healthcare professional. Stop using a product if it causes burning, redness, or worsening irritation.

Think about how you plan to use the bar

Several of these products are described for both face and body, but your facial skin may react differently from the rest of your skin. Check the maker’s directions and consider trying a new soap on a small area first. A soap bar also needs to dry between uses; a draining soap dish can help limit how long it sits in water.

Compare pack size and scent selection

Southern Natural’s product is listed as a three-bar set, while the other product descriptions focus on individual bar formulas or scent choices. Check the listing for the selected size, scent, and package details before ordering. The right choice depends on whether you want to try one bar, keep extras on hand, or choose among several aromas.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is natural soap always better for dry skin?

No. “Natural” does not guarantee that a soap will suit your skin. Ingredients such as essential oils and fragrance can bother some people, so check the full label and choose based on your own sensitivities.

Which soap in this guide is described as unscented?

Natrulo Grass-Fed Tallow Soap is described as unscented and dye-free. Check the product label for the complete ingredient list, especially if you have a known sensitivity.

Can these soaps treat eczema or psoriasis?

The product descriptions include claims related to eczema or psoriasis, but this article cannot confirm that any bar treats those conditions. For persistent or severe symptoms, seek advice from a healthcare professional.

Does the Southern Natural soap contain oatmeal and honey?

No. Although the scent is called Oatmeal Milk & Honey, the product description says the soap does not contain oatmeal or honey. Check the full ingredient list if those ingredients matter to you.

Can I use these bars on my face?

Some of the products are described for face and body use. Still, facial skin can be more sensitive than body skin, so follow the product directions and stop if you notice irritation.

What should I do if a new soap makes my skin feel worse?

Stop using it and rinse the area with water. If irritation continues or is severe, contact a healthcare professional. If you know which ingredient caused a reaction, check future product labels for it.

Final Recommendation

For a plant-based bar with essential oils and multiple scent options, Crate 61 Organics is the most direct fit. If avoiding fragrance is your priority, Natrulo is the clearest choice in this group, though it is made with animal-derived tallow. Erbaid’s magnesium bar and Southern Natural’s goat milk set suit shoppers who want scented formulas, while the other Erbaid bar is worth considering for its face-and-body positioning. Compare ingredient lists and avoid relying on soap to treat a skin condition.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment