For a sham that looks full rather than flat, the right insert matters as much as the cover. Check the insert’s size, fill, and firmness against your sham and how you plan to use it: a decorative Euro sham may call for a large square insert, while a bed pillow can offer a firmer, more supportive feel. These three options range from a pair of 26-inch Euro inserts to extra-firm bed pillows that can also fill shams.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Size and set | Fill and feel | Best for | Availability in supplied data |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FAVRIQ 26 x 26 Euro Pillow Inserts | Two 26-inch square inserts | 3D polyester fill; soft with support | Large Euro shams and decorative covers | Available |
| Pillowtex 20 x 20 Throw Pillow Inserts | Two 20-inch square inserts | Polyester fill; extra firm and high loft | Smaller square shams that need a dense shape | Listed as unavailable |
| Pillowtex Classic Extra Firm Polyester Pillows | Two queen-size pillows | Overstuffed polyester fill; firm, high loft | Bed shams and side sleepers who prefer firm support | Listed as unavailable |
Our Picks: Best Overstuffed Pillows For Shams reviews
FAVRIQ 26-Inch Euro Inserts: Best for Large Square Shams
This two-pack of 26-inch square inserts is the most direct match here for large Euro shams. Each insert has a cotton cover and 3D polyester fill, which the product description says is designed to feel like traditional down without feathers. The square shape also suits decorative pillow covers for a bed, sofa, or chair.
The fill is described as balancing softness with support, rather than being especially firm. That makes these inserts a flexible choice if you want a pillow that can dress up a sham and still feel comfortable to lean against. For a fuller look, FAVRIQ advises ordering an insert one size larger than the cover; for a softer fit, choose the same size.
A hidden zipper lets you remove the fill for cleaning, and the insert itself is listed as machine washable on a gentle cycle. After unpacking, the compressed pillow may need to be pressed, squeezed, and folded to help it regain its shape. Unlike the Pillowtex options below, these are specifically sized as Euro inserts, so they’re easier to match to large square covers.
Pros:
- Two large 26-inch square inserts suit Euro shams.
- Cotton covers and polyester fill offer a feather-free alternative to down.
- Hidden zippers allow access to the fill.
- Listed as machine washable on a gentle cycle.
Cons:
- The soft-to-supportive feel may not satisfy shoppers who want a very firm insert.
- The inserts need fluffing after unpacking from vacuum packaging.
Verdict: Choose the FAVRIQ pair if you need large, versatile inserts for Euro shams and want a removable, washable design.
Pillowtex 20-Inch Inserts: Best for a Firm, Compact Shape
This Pillowtex two-pack contains 20-inch square inserts filled with polyester. They’re described as extra firm and high loft, so they’re aimed at shoppers who want a dense pillow shape rather than a loose, soft look. Their smaller dimensions can work well in square shams that would be overwhelmed by a 26-inch insert.
The product description says the inserts are designed to hold their shape and are intended for decorative use in bedrooms and living rooms. That firmness may help a sham look structured on a bed or sofa, but it may feel less comfortable if you prefer a pillow that compresses easily when you lean on it.
These inserts arrive compressed and vacuum sealed, so plan to allow time for them to regain their loft after opening. The supplied product information lists this item as unavailable, so check the product page before choosing it. Compared with the FAVRIQ inserts, this set is smaller and firmer, but its description provides less detail about care and construction.
Pros:
- Two 20-inch square inserts fit smaller decorative covers.
- Extra-firm, high-loft fill is designed for a dense appearance.
- Polyester fill is suitable for shoppers seeking a non-down option.
Cons:
- May feel too firm for shoppers who want a soft, yielding pillow.
- Listed as unavailable in the supplied product information.
Verdict: Consider this set if you want firm 20-inch inserts for compact square shams, but confirm availability before planning around it.
Pillowtex Queen Pillows: Best for Firm Bed-Sham Support
Unlike the two square decorative inserts, this Pillowtex set contains two queen-size bed pillows. Each is described as overstuffed with polyester fiber and wrapped in a cotton cover. The product is designed for side sleepers who prefer firm, high-loft support, and the description also presents the pillows as sham stuffers for standard, queen, and king bedding.
The firmer construction could be useful when you want a bed sham to look full and stay upright. It may also suit you if you plan to use the pillow for sleeping after removing it from the sham. However, the listing describes a queen-size sleeping pillow, not a square decorative insert. Check your sham’s dimensions and closure before buying; the pillow’s shape may not give a square cover the same crisp fill as a dedicated square insert.
The cotton cover and hypoallergenic polyester fill are notable features, but the supplied information does not specify care instructions for this particular set. It is also listed as unavailable in the supplied product data. Compared with the FAVRIQ pair, this set is more focused on firm bed support than versatile decorative use.
Pros:
- Two queen-size pillows have an overstuffed, high-loft design.
- Firm polyester fill is intended for side-sleeper support.
- Cotton covers provide a breathable fabric surface.
- Can serve as bed-sham stuffers as well as sleeping pillows.
Cons:
- The bed-pillow shape may not fit square decorative shams well.
- Listed as unavailable in the supplied product information.
Verdict: Pick these if you need firm queen-size pillows that can also fill bed shams, but choose a square insert for square decorative covers.
How to Choose Overstuffed Pillows for Shams
Match the Insert Shape to the Sham
Start with the sham’s shape and dimensions. Square decorative covers usually work best with square inserts, while bed shams are often made for bed-pillow shapes. A pillow that is too small can leave loose corners or a sagging center; one that is too large may be hard to insert or strain the seams and closure.
Choose the Right Insert Size
Measure the sham before you shop, and compare its stated dimensions with the insert size. For a plump look, a slightly larger insert is a common choice, but the right amount depends on the cover’s fabric, construction, and how firm you want the finished pillow to feel. FAVRIQ specifically suggests sizing up for a fuller, firmer result and choosing the same size for a softer fit.
Think About Firmness and How You’ll Use It
Firm inserts tend to hold a more structured shape, while softer fills are easier to compress and lean against. Decide whether your pillow is mainly for display, back support, or sleeping. The Pillowtex options are described as extra firm, while the FAVRIQ inserts are described as balancing softness and support.
Consider the Fill and Cover
Polyester fill is used in all three options, but their shapes and stated feels differ. The FAVRIQ inserts have cotton covers and 3D polyester fill; the queen Pillowtex pillows have cotton covers and hypoallergenic polyester fill. Check the product details for the features that matter to you, especially if you want a removable cover, a particular fabric, or a feather-free fill.
Check Care Instructions
Decorative pillows can collect dust and need occasional cleaning, so care details are worth checking before you buy. The FAVRIQ inserts are described as machine washable on a gentle cycle and have hidden zippers for removing the fill. Care instructions are not provided in the supplied information for the two Pillowtex products, so verify the listing or product label rather than assuming they can be washed the same way.
Allow Time for Compressed Inserts to Fluff
Some inserts are shipped vacuum sealed to reduce package size. Both the FAVRIQ and 20-inch Pillowtex descriptions mention compression, so the pillows may need fluffing after you open them. Follow the product’s instructions and give the fill time to expand before judging how it looks inside your sham.
FAQs
Should a pillow insert be larger than its sham?
A slightly larger insert can help create a fuller look, but the best fit depends on the cover’s dimensions, fabric, and desired firmness. Check the product’s sizing guidance and make sure the insert will still fit through the sham’s opening.
Which option is best for a large Euro sham?
The FAVRIQ 26-inch square inserts are the clearest match among these picks for large Euro shams. They come as a pair and are designed for decorative covers.
Are the Pillowtex 20-inch inserts suitable for firm-looking shams?
They’re described as extra firm and high loft, which may suit a smaller square sham when you want a dense shape. Check the sham measurements and product availability before purchasing.
Can bed pillows be used as sham stuffers?
Yes, a bed pillow can fill a bed sham if the shape and dimensions fit. The Pillowtex queen-size pillows are described as usable in bed shams, but they may not suit square decorative covers as well as square inserts.
Are these pillows filled with down or feathers?
The supplied descriptions list polyester fill for all three options. The FAVRIQ description specifically presents its fill as a feather-free alternative to traditional down.
Can I wash these inserts?
The FAVRIQ inserts are described as machine washable on a gentle cycle, with low-heat tumble drying. The supplied information does not give care instructions for the Pillowtex options, so check their product details or labels before washing.
Are both Pillowtex options available?
Both Pillowtex products are listed as unavailable in the supplied product information. Availability can change, so check each product page before making a decision.
Final Recommendation
For most shoppers looking for overstuffed inserts specifically for shams, the FAVRIQ 26-inch Euro pair is the most straightforward choice: it has a square shape, a large size for Euro covers, and clear care instructions. Choose the Pillowtex 20-inch set only if you need a smaller, firmer square insert and can confirm it is available. The queen Pillowtex pillows make more sense for bed shams and firm sleeping support than for square decorative covers.
