A good Pack and Play mattress cover should fit securely, help protect the mattress from spills, and be easy to wash. The right choice depends on your playard’s mattress size and whether you want a quilted waterproof pad, a zippered encasement, or a simple fitted sheet. These five options include different styles, so check the fit details before choosing.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Cover style | Fit details | Standout feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| Biloban Quilted Waterproof Protector, 2-Pack | Fitted quilted protector | 39 × 27 inches; fits mattresses up to 5 inches deep | Waterproof layer and padded surface |
| Biloban Zippered Mattress Encasement | Zippered encasement | 38 × 26 inches; 1.5-inch depth | Removable cover with non-slip bottom |
| Yoofoss Quilted Waterproof Protector, 2-Pack | Fitted quilted protector | 39 × 27 inches; fits mattresses up to 5 inches deep | Two protectors and OEKO-TEX certification stated in the listing |
| Joey + Joan Waterproof Protector, 2-Pack | Fitted quilted protector | Listed as compatible with Graco Pack n Play | Bamboo-derived viscose surface and TPU backing |
| BROLEX Stretchy Pack n Play Sheets, 2-Pack | Fitted sheet set | For mini cribs, playards, and Pack n Play mattresses | Simple soft-sheet option |
Our Picks: Best Pack And Play Mattress Cover reviews
Biloban Quilted Protector: A Padded, Waterproof Two-Pack
This Biloban set pairs a quilted mattress protector with a fitted-sheet style design. The listing gives its dimensions as 39 × 27 inches and says the elasticized skirt fits mattresses up to 5 inches deep. Its microfiber surface and fiber filling add a padded layer, while a TPU backing is intended to guard against everyday spills and stains.
The two-pack can be handy when one cover is in the wash or when you want a spare ready for a mess. The product is described as machine washable and dryer friendly. Its broader dimensions may suit many standard playard mattresses, but they are not a substitute for measuring your own mattress first.
Compared with the zippered Biloban option below, this one is easier to take on and off like a fitted pad, but it does not fully encase the mattress. Choose it if you want a quilted surface and a spare cover; skip it if your mattress needs a close-fitting encasement.
Pros:
- Includes two fitted protectors.
- Quilted, padded surface.
- Waterproof TPU layer is designed to block everyday liquids.
- Listed as machine washable and dryer friendly.
Cons:
- The 39 × 27-inch size may not suit every playard mattress.
- A fitted protector does not cover the mattress with a zipper.
Verdict: This is a practical pick if your mattress matches the listed fit and you want two padded, waterproof covers.
Biloban Zippered Encasement: A Close-Covering Option
Unlike a fitted pad that covers the top and sides, this Biloban model is a zippered mattress encasement. It measures 38 × 26 inches with a listed depth of 1.5 inches. The product description names Graco Pack n Play, Dream On Me, and Pamo Babe as compatible, while specifically excluding 4moms Breeze Plus Portable, 4moms Breeze GO Portable Travel, and Lotus Travel Crib playards.
The cover has a bamboo-derived viscose jacquard surface, a waterproof TPU layer, and non-slip gripping dots on the bottom. Its zipper allows the cover to be removed for washing. The listing says to machine wash cold on a gentle cycle and tumble dry on low; it also advises against bleaching, ironing, and dry cleaning.
This is the most specialized fit in the group, so checking your mattress measurements and model matters. It is a useful option if you want a zippered cover and your mattress matches the stated dimensions. Its listed depth is shallower than the two quilted 39 × 27-inch options.
Pros:
- Zippered design covers the mattress more fully than a fitted pad.
- Waterproof TPU layer and non-slip bottom are specified.
- Removable and machine washable.
- Compatibility details include both suitable and excluded playard models.
Cons:
- Fit is limited to the listed dimensions and compatible models.
- Not compatible with the named 4moms and Lotus models.
Verdict: Choose this encasement if its dimensions match your mattress and you prefer a zippered cover over a fitted protector.
Yoofoss Quilted Protector: Two Covers with a Broad Fit Range
Yoofoss offers two quilted waterproof protectors, each listed at 39 × 27 inches. The description says the deep pockets fit mattresses up to 5 inches thick and are designed for standard playards or portable and mini crib mattresses measuring 38 × 24 inches. Confirm your own mattress size before ordering, especially if your playard uses a nonstandard pad.
The soft, breathable fabric has a quilted construction, and the listing describes a waterproof layer intended to protect against spills, sweat, and other liquids. Yoofoss also states that the protectors are OEKO-TEX certified. The two-cover set gives you a spare while the other one is being washed.
This is similar in format to the Biloban two-pack above: both offer a fitted, quilted surface and waterproof protection. The key distinction in the supplied details is Yoofoss’s stated 38 × 24-inch mattress compatibility and OEKO-TEX certification. The product listing says the covers are washable and built to withstand repeated washing, but care instructions should still be checked before laundering.
Pros:
- Comes with two fitted protectors.
- Listed to fit mattresses up to 5 inches thick.
- Quilted fabric and a waterproof layer are specified.
- OEKO-TEX certification is stated in the product description.
Cons:
- The 39 × 27-inch cover may be too large or small for some playards.
- It is a fitted protector, not a zippered encasement.
Verdict: Consider Yoofoss if you want a two-pack of quilted protectors and your mattress matches the listed fit range.
Joey + Joan Waterproof Pad: A Graco-Compatible Two-Pack
This Joey + Joan set includes two fitted waterproof pads. The listing describes them as compatible with Graco Pack n Play playard mattresses and says the elastic around the edge is designed to provide a snug fit. It does not give specific mattress dimensions in the supplied product details, so check the product listing and your playard measurements before buying.
The quilted surface is made from bamboo-derived viscose with absorbent filling. A TPU backing is intended to help protect the mattress from spills and accidents. The listing also describes the surface as breathable and hypoallergenic, but those are product claims rather than a replacement for checking whether a material suits your child.
Compared with the Biloban and Yoofoss two-packs, Joey + Joan highlights bamboo-derived viscose and Graco compatibility rather than a listed universal size range. That makes it a more targeted choice for shoppers with a Graco playard, but less straightforward if you need an exact published measurement to confirm fit.
Pros:
- Includes two fitted protectors.
- Designed for Graco Pack n Play mattresses.
- Quilted viscose surface with absorbent filling.
- TPU backing is intended to protect against liquids.
Cons:
- The supplied description does not state exact cover dimensions.
- Compatibility is specified for Graco, not a broad range of playard models.
Verdict: This is worth considering for a Graco playard if the product listing confirms a match for your specific mattress.
BROLEX Stretchy Sheets: A Simple Two-Pack for the Top Surface
BROLEX is the simplest option here: a two-pack of stretchy fitted sheets for mini cribs, playards, and Pack n Play mattresses. The product description focuses on softness and a fitted-sheet design. It does not state that the sheets are waterproof or include a protective backing, so treat them as sheets rather than mattress protectors.
A spare sheet can be useful when you want a clean top layer ready to use. However, if your priority is blocking leaks or protecting the mattress from liquids, one of the waterproof pads or encasements in this guide is a closer match. The supplied description does not include exact dimensions, so check the listing for sizing details before purchasing.
Pros:
- Includes two fitted sheets.
- Designed for mini cribs, playards, and Pack n Play mattresses.
- Stretchy construction is intended to create a fitted feel.
Cons:
- The supplied description does not claim waterproof protection.
- Exact dimensions are not included in the available product details.
Verdict: Choose BROLEX if you need soft fitted sheets, not a waterproof mattress cover.
How to Choose a Pack and Play Mattress Cover
Measure the mattress before you shop
Start with the mattress itself, not just the playard brand name. Compare its length, width, and depth with the cover’s listed measurements. A cover that is too loose or too tight may not fit as intended. For example, the two quilted Biloban and Yoofoss options list a 39 × 27-inch cover and a maximum mattress depth of 5 inches, while the zippered Biloban encasement lists a 38 × 26-inch size and a 1.5-inch depth.
Choose between a fitted pad and an encasement
A fitted protector covers the top and sides of the mattress and is generally put on and removed like a fitted sheet. A zippered encasement wraps around the mattress and closes with a zipper. Think about how much of the mattress you want covered and how you prefer to change and wash the cover.
Decide whether waterproof protection matters
If you want help guarding against spills and leaks, look for a product that clearly lists a waterproof layer. The Biloban and Yoofoss quilted protectors, the zippered Biloban encasement, and the Joey + Joan pads all describe waterproof construction. The BROLEX listing describes fitted sheets but does not state that they are waterproof.
Consider the surface and amount of padding
Quilted protectors add a padded layer, while a standard fitted sheet is a simpler cover for the mattress surface. Product descriptions name materials such as microfiber, bamboo-derived viscose, and soft fabric. Consider the feel and construction you prefer, but do not assume that a cover changes the playard mattress itself or is suitable for every child.
Check care instructions and set size
A two-pack can provide a spare while one cover is being washed. Check the care directions too: the zippered Biloban listing specifies a cold, gentle machine wash and low-heat tumble drying, and advises against bleach, ironing, and dry cleaning. Follow the care instructions for whichever product you choose.
Keep the playard fit in mind
Compatibility can vary by model, even when products use similar size labels. The zippered Biloban listing names some compatible playards and excludes specific 4moms and Lotus models. Joey + Joan lists Graco compatibility. Confirm the fit for your exact mattress and follow the playard maker’s instructions for using its mattress and bedding.
FAQs
What is the difference between a mattress cover and a fitted sheet?
A fitted sheet covers the mattress surface. A mattress protector is designed to add protection, often with a waterproof layer. Some products combine a fitted-sheet shape with a waterproof backing, while an encasement uses a zipper to wrap around the mattress.
Are all Pack and Play mattress covers waterproof?
No. Check the product description for a clear statement about waterproof construction. The BROLEX product in this guide is described as a fitted sheet set, while the Biloban, Yoofoss, and Joey + Joan protectors specify waterproof layers.
Will a 39 × 27-inch cover fit every playard?
No. The size may work for some mattresses, but playard mattress dimensions can vary. Measure the mattress and compare both its length and width, along with its depth, to the cover’s listed fit details.
Should I choose a fitted protector or a zippered encasement?
A fitted protector may be more convenient if you want a pad that comes on and off like a sheet. A zippered encasement covers the mattress with a removable zip closure. Your mattress dimensions and model compatibility should guide the choice.
Can I use a mini crib cover on a Pack and Play mattress?
Only if the cover’s measurements and design match the Pack and Play mattress. Some products are described for both mini cribs and playards, but those labels alone do not confirm a fit for every model.
How many covers should I buy?
A two-pack gives you a spare while one cover is being washed. If you only need a top sheet and do not need waterproof protection, a two-pack of fitted sheets may be enough. Choose based on how often you want a clean replacement ready.
Final Recommendation
For a quilted waterproof option with a clearly stated fit range, compare the Biloban and Yoofoss two-packs against your mattress measurements. Choose the zippered Biloban if its specific dimensions and compatibility details match your playard. Joey + Joan may suit shoppers with a compatible Graco model, while BROLEX is the straightforward choice when you want fitted sheets rather than a waterproof protector. In every case, confirm the fit before use and follow your playard’s instructions.