Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Bedding & Pillows

Best Pillow Inserts For Throw Pillows: Top 5 Compared

Updated 11 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 11minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

The best pillow inserts for throw pillows should fit your covers well, stay plump enough for your preferred look, and offer the right balance of softness and support. The five options below are all 18-by-18-inch inserts, but they differ in pack size, filling, care instructions, and stated fill weight. Use the comparison table to narrow your choices, then check the buying guide for tips on getting the fit you want.

ProductPack sizeFilling and standout featureCare guidance
Utopia Bedding 18×18 Inserts, Set of 44 insertsVirgin fiber; 500 g per insertSpot clean; fluff after unpacking
MIULEE 18×18 Inserts, 4 Pack4 insertsVirgin fiber; 500 g per insertGentle machine wash for covers; tumble dry on warm with dryer balls
Utopia Bedding 18×18 Inserts, 2 Pack2 insertsVirgin fiber; high-rebound fillSpot clean; allow time to expand after unpacking
MIULEE 18×18 Inserts, 2 Pack2 insertsVirgin fiber; 500 g per insertSpot clean or dry clean
MIULEE 18×18 Inserts, Pack of 44 insertsMicrofiber and polyester fiber blend; 560 g per insertTumble dry on warm with dryer balls to fluff

Our Picks: Best Pillow Inserts For Throw Pillows reviews

Utopia Bedding 18×18 Inserts: A Practical Four-Pillow Set

This set includes four 18-by-18-inch inserts filled with 500 grams of virgin fiber each. The size is intended for 18-by-18-inch covers, making it a straightforward option if you are refreshing several pillows at once.

The inserts have a brushed 115 GSM fabric cover and high-rebound fiber filling. The listing describes them as lightweight and supportive, with fill designed to bounce back after use. They can serve as decorative cushions or as light back support on a sofa or bed.

One point to consider is the fit: an 18-inch insert in an 18-inch cover gives you a standard match, while a smaller cover can create a more stuffed look. The product information suggests using covers one size smaller for added fullness. These inserts arrive compressed, so expect to shake and pat them and give them time to recover. Spot cleaning is recommended.

Compared with the other four-pack options, this set offers a clear stated fill weight and simple care instructions. It may suit you if you want a matching set and prefer a basic virgin-fiber fill, but it is not the best choice if machine-washing the inserts is important to you.

Pros:

  • Four inserts are included for coordinating multiple covers.
  • Each insert has a stated fill weight of 500 grams.
  • Virgin fiber filling is described as lightweight and supportive.
  • Brushed fabric cover has a soft texture.

Cons:

  • Spot cleaning is recommended rather than machine washing.
  • The compressed inserts need fluffing and time to expand.

Verdict: Choose this set if you need four standard-size inserts with a stated fill weight and do not mind spot-cleaning them.

MIULEE 18×18 Inserts: Four-Pack with Gentle-Wash Cover Care

This MIULEE set comes with four 18-by-18-inch inserts, each filled with 500 grams of virgin fiber. The listing describes the fill as providing firm, flexible support and says it is intended to hold its shape over time.

The brushed fabric cover is listed at 110 GSM. For care, the product information says the covers can be machine washed on a gentle cycle and dried quickly. The inserts arrive vacuum-packed; the listing recommends using a dryer with dryer balls on warm for 20 to 30 minutes to help restore their fluff. Follow the care instructions supplied with the product before washing or drying.

This set is a useful alternative to the Utopia four-pack if you want four matching inserts and value the listed gentle-wash care option for the covers. The information does not give a detailed construction breakdown beyond the virgin-fiber fill and brushed fabric, so shoppers seeking a specific fill blend may prefer the MIULEE option below that lists both microfiber and polyester fiber.

As with other compressed inserts, these may need attention after opening rather than looking fully lofted straight from the package. They are intended for covers of the same stated size, and can also be used for back or lumbar support.

Pros:

  • Four 18-by-18-inch inserts are included.
  • Each insert has a stated fill weight of 500 grams.
  • The listing describes the fill as firm and flexible.
  • Cover care includes a gentle machine-wash option.

Cons:

  • The vacuum-packed inserts need fluffing after opening.
  • The listed drying method may not suit every household or care preference.

Verdict: Pick this set if you need four inserts and want a gentle machine-wash option for their covers, while keeping in mind that they need fluffing after unpacking.

Utopia Bedding 18×18 Inserts: A Two-Pack for Smaller Updates

This Utopia Bedding option provides two 18-by-18-inch inserts, making it a sensible pack size if you are replacing a pair of cushions rather than filling a whole room. The inserts use virgin-fiber filling and have a brushed 115 GSM cover.

The listing describes the fill as high-rebound and suitable for decorative use or light support behind your back. It also gives clear expansion guidance: after opening the compressed package, allow 48 to 72 hours for the inserts to fully expand. Patting them or tumbling them on low with tennis balls is suggested as another way to help restore fluffiness.

Unlike the four-pack from the same brand, this listing does not specify the amount of filling per insert. That makes it harder to compare fullness by fill weight alone. Spot cleaning is recommended, so these are less suited to anyone who wants a washable insert.

This is a practical choice for a two-cover refresh, especially if you want a familiar 18-inch size and clear instructions for bringing compressed inserts back to shape. If you need four inserts or want an explicit fill weight, consider one of the larger sets instead.

Pros:

  • Two inserts suit a small update or a pair of matching covers.
  • Virgin fiber is described as lightweight and supportive.
  • Brushed fabric cover has a soft feel.
  • Expansion instructions include a suggested recovery period and fluffing methods.

Cons:

  • The listing does not state the fill weight per insert.
  • Spot cleaning is recommended.

Verdict: Choose this two-pack for a simple replacement of a pair of 18-inch cushions, but look elsewhere if comparing fill weight is a priority.

MIULEE 18×18 Inserts: Two-Pack with a Stated Fill Weight

This two-pack from MIULEE includes 18-by-18-inch inserts filled with 500 grams of virgin fiber each. The 110 GSM brushed fabric cover is paired with fill that the listing describes as supportive and quick to rebound.

The inserts can be used in sofa, bed, chair, or car-seat covers, and the product information also mentions back and lumbar support. Care guidance is more limited than on the MIULEE four-pack: spot cleaning or dry cleaning is recommended. The inserts arrive vacuum-packed, so patting them from the sides toward the center can help bring back their shape.

The stated fill weight makes this option easier to compare with the other 500-gram inserts. Its main practical difference is the smaller pack size and the more cautious cleaning guidance. If you want four cushions, the four-pack may be more convenient; if you only need a pair and prefer to avoid machine washing, this set is a closer fit.

As with any pillow insert, the final look depends on your cover’s size and construction. These are listed as 18-by-18 inches, so check your cover measurements before ordering, particularly if you want a very full appearance.

Pros:

  • Two inserts are a convenient quantity for a pair of covers.
  • Each insert has a stated fill weight of 500 grams.
  • Virgin fiber is described as supportive and quick to rebound.
  • Brushed fabric cover is listed at 110 GSM.

Cons:

  • Spot cleaning or dry cleaning is recommended instead of machine washing.
  • The vacuum-packed inserts need fluffing after opening.

Verdict: This is a good match for shoppers who need two inserts with a stated fill weight and are comfortable with spot cleaning or dry cleaning.

MIULEE 18×18 Inserts: Four-Pack with a Fiber Blend

This MIULEE four-pack stands out for its listed blend of fluffy virgin microfiber and firmer polyester fiber. Each 18-by-18-inch insert has 560 grams of filling, the highest stated fill weight among the options here. The listing presents the blend as a way to balance a soft, plush feel with structure and support.

The inserts have a smooth 110 GSM brushed fabric cover and are intended for sofas, chairs, beds, offices, and cars. The product information suggests choosing inserts one to two inches larger than your covers for a plumper appearance. Because that fit can feel snug, check the cover’s measurements and closure before choosing a larger insert.

To fluff them, the listing recommends tumbling the inserts on warm with dryer balls for 20 to 30 minutes. This may appeal if you want a fuller look and do not mind using a dryer according to the product’s care guidance. The fiber blend and higher listed fill weight may make these feel more structured than the 500-gram virgin-fiber options, though the best choice still depends on your preferred firmness and cover fit.

Pros:

  • Four inserts are included.
  • Each insert has a stated fill weight of 560 grams.
  • The fiber blend is described as combining softness with structure.
  • Product guidance explains how to choose a fuller fit and restore loft.

Cons:

  • The suggested dryer method may not suit every care routine.
  • Oversizing can make inserts harder to fit into covers with limited stretch or small closures.

Verdict: Choose this set if you want four inserts with the highest stated fill weight here and prefer a blend designed to balance plushness with support.

How to Choose Pillow Inserts for Throw Pillows

Match the insert to your cover size

Start by checking the cover’s finished dimensions, not just its label. An 18-by-18-inch insert is designed for an 18-by-18-inch cover, but fabric stretch, seam depth, and the size of the opening can affect how easily it fits. A same-size insert gives you a standard fit. For a fuller look, some shoppers choose a slightly larger insert, but check that your cover can accommodate it without straining the seams or closure.

Choose the fill and feel you want

Fill type affects how a pillow feels and how it holds its shape. The options here use virgin fiber or a blend of virgin microfiber and polyester fiber. The listings describe these fills as soft, supportive, or resilient, but those terms do not guarantee a specific level of firmness. If you want a more structured cushion, look for a stated fill weight and a blend described as supportive. If you prefer a lighter, softer decorative pillow, a virgin-fiber insert may suit you.

Compare fill weight carefully

When a product lists the fill weight per insert, you can use it as one point of comparison between similar sizes. In this group, several inserts list 500 grams each, while the MIULEE blend lists 560 grams. A higher weight can suggest more filling, but it does not tell you everything about how firm or lofty the pillow will feel. Fiber type and how the filling is distributed also matter.

Pick the right pack quantity

Think about how many covers you want to fill before choosing a set. A two-pack may be more practical for replacing a pair of cushions, while a four-pack can help you coordinate several pillows at once. Check the quantity in the product title and compare it with your decorating plan so you do not end up with too many or too few inserts.

Check care instructions before buying

Care options vary among these inserts. Some listings recommend spot cleaning or dry cleaning, while another describes gentle machine washing for the covers. Some suggest using a dryer with dryer balls to restore fluffiness. Since cleaning guidance is product-specific, follow the instructions that come with your insert and avoid assuming that every pillow can be machine washed or tumble dried.

Plan for unpacking and fluffing

Several inserts arrive compressed or vacuum-packed and may not reach their intended shape immediately. Patting and shaking can help distribute the fill, and some product instructions recommend allowing time for the insert to expand or using a dryer with dryer balls. If you need pillows ready right away, factor in this recovery time when you plan your purchase.

FAQs

Should a pillow insert be the same size as its cover?

A same-size insert is a straightforward fit, such as an 18-by-18-inch insert for an 18-by-18-inch cover. For a fuller look, some people choose a slightly larger insert, but check the cover’s fabric, seams, and closure first.

Are these inserts suitable for 18-by-18-inch covers?

Yes. All five options in this guide are listed as 18-by-18-inch inserts. Measure your cover and check the product details before ordering to confirm the fit you want.

Which option has the highest stated fill weight?

The MIULEE four-pack with a microfiber and polyester fiber blend lists 560 grams of filling per insert. The Utopia four-pack and both MIULEE 500-gram options list 500 grams per insert. The Utopia two-pack does not state a fill weight in the supplied product information.

Can I machine wash a pillow insert?

Care instructions differ by product. The MIULEE four-pack listing says its covers can be machine washed on a gentle cycle, while other options recommend spot cleaning or dry cleaning. Check the care instructions for the specific insert before washing it.

How do I fluff inserts that arrive compressed?

Start by unpacking, shaking, and patting the insert to help spread the fill. Some product instructions also recommend allowing time for it to expand or using a dryer with dryer balls on the stated setting. Follow the care guidance for your particular insert.

Which pack should I choose if I only need two inserts?

Both the Utopia Bedding and MIULEE two-packs include two 18-by-18-inch inserts. The MIULEE option states a fill weight of 500 grams per insert; the Utopia option provides expansion instructions but does not list a fill weight in the supplied details.

Final Recommendation

For an easy way to fill several matching covers, the Utopia Bedding four-pack offers four 18-inch inserts with 500 grams of virgin fiber in each. If you want a fuller, more structured option with the highest stated fill weight in this group, consider the MIULEE four-pack with its microfiber and polyester blend. For a smaller update, either two-pack can work; choose between them based on the stated fill weight and the care instructions that best fit your routine.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment