Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Cookware & Kitchen Tools

Best Pizza Pan For Frozen Pizza: Crispy Crust Picks Compared

Updated 10 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 10minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

A good pizza pan can help a frozen pizza bake more evenly and make it easier to move and serve. For a crispier bottom, look for a perforated pan that lets moisture escape; for broader kitchen use or a coating-free surface, a solid stainless steel pan may suit you better. Before buying, check the pan’s diameter against your pizza and oven, and follow the pizza package’s baking directions.

Quick Comparison

ProductSize and materialStandout featureBest for
GoodCook AirPerfect 16-Inch Pizza Pan16-inch carbon steelPerforations, cutting guides, and feetA crisp crust and easy serving
HONGBAKE 14-Inch Pizza Pan, 2-Pack14-inch perforated carbon steel pansWide handles and molded feetMaking two pizzas or keeping a spare
Kirecoo 16-Inch Stainless Steel Pizza Pans, 2-Pack16-inch stainless steel pansNo coating and dishwasher-safe designCoating-free versatility
Calphalon Titan Steel 16-Inch Pizza Pan16-inch steel-core panPFOA-free nonstick coating and reinforced rimEasy release from a solid pan
AWTBDP 13½-Inch Stainless Steel Pizza Pans, 2-Pack13½-inch stainless steel pansSloped edges and a two-pan setSmaller pies and everyday baking

Our Picks: Best Pizza Pan For Frozen Pizza reviews

GoodCook AirPerfect: Best Overall for a Crispier Crust

The GoodCook AirPerfect is a 16-inch carbon steel pan with a perforated surface. Those holes allow more airflow beneath the pizza, which can help reduce moisture at the crust. That makes this a strong choice if you prefer a crispier bottom than you tend to get from a solid tray.

Its nonstick coating is designed to make serving and cleanup easier. Cutting guides help you divide the pie into even slices, while feet on the bottom keep the hot pan elevated when it is set down. The feet are useful for countertop clearance, though you will still want to use care when handling a hot pan.

The 16-inch size works for larger pizzas, but measure your oven and check the frozen pizza’s diameter before ordering. Its perforations may not suit every pizza style or package direction, so use the pizza maker’s instructions as your guide.

Pros:

  • Perforated surface is designed to reduce moisture under the crust.
  • Nonstick coating helps with release and cleanup.
  • Cutting guides make it easier to portion slices evenly.
  • Bottom feet keep the hot pan raised off the countertop.

Cons:

  • The 16-inch diameter may be too large for some ovens or pizzas.
  • Perforations may not match every pizza’s preferred baking method.

Verdict: Choose the GoodCook if you want a large perforated pan with practical serving features and your oven and pizza can accommodate its size.

HONGBAKE 14-Inch Set: Best Two-Pan Option

This set includes two 14-inch perforated carbon steel pans. Their holes are intended to improve airflow beneath the pizza, while molded feet are designed to help with heat circulation. The pans also have wide handles, which give you more area to grip when moving a loaded pan.

The listed pan diameter is 14 inches, and the overall size with handles is 15.75 inches. Check both measurements against your oven and storage space. The pans have a nonstick coating, and the product information says they are designed to resist warping up to 450°F. That temperature limit is worth checking against your frozen pizza’s instructions.

A two-pan set can be convenient if you bake more than one pizza or want a second pan ready for another meal. On the other hand, these pans are smaller than the 16-inch options here, so they are not the best fit for larger pies.

Pros:

  • Two perforated pans provide a second tray for another pizza or baking task.
  • Nonstick surface is designed for easier release.
  • Wide handles offer a larger gripping area.
  • Product information lists a temperature limit of 450°F.

Cons:

  • The 14-inch pan diameter may not fit larger frozen pizzas.
  • Nonstick coatings require care to avoid damaging the surface.

Verdict: Pick the HONGBAKE set if two smaller perforated pans and wide handles matter more to you than having a single large tray.

Kirecoo Stainless Steel: Best Coating-Free 16-Inch Set

Kirecoo’s set comes with two 16-inch stainless steel pans. Unlike the coated options in this roundup, the product description presents these as stainless steel pans without a coating. That may appeal if you prefer a plain metal cooking surface or want pans that can handle more than frozen pizza.

The pans are listed as oven-safe up to 450°F and dishwasher-safe. Their solid, smooth surfaces can support a pizza, but they do not have the perforations found on the GoodCook and HONGBAKE pans. If crisping the underside is your main goal, a perforated option may be a better match.

These pans are also described for flatbreads, leftovers, cookies, vegetables, and serving. The set’s 16-inch size gives you room for larger pies, but confirm your oven’s usable space. The product information recommends drying the pans thoroughly after washing to help with storage and upkeep.

Pros:

  • Two large stainless steel pans are included.
  • No nonstick coating is listed in the product description.
  • Dishwasher-safe design can simplify cleanup.
  • Suitable for uses beyond pizza, including flatbreads and reheating leftovers.

Cons:

  • The solid surface lacks the airflow of a perforated pan.
  • The product information lists a maximum oven temperature of 450°F.

Verdict: Choose Kirecoo if you want two large, coating-free stainless steel pans for pizza and other kitchen tasks, rather than a perforated tray focused on crust crisping.

Calphalon Titan Steel: Best Solid Pan with Nonstick Coating

The Calphalon Titan Steel is a 16-inch solid pan with a reinforced steel core and a PFOA-free nonstick coating. Its solid surface supports the pizza across the base, while the coating is intended to help food release cleanly after baking. A rolled, reinforced rim is designed to resist warping.

Unlike the perforated pans in this guide, this one does not have holes to let moisture escape beneath the pizza. That makes it a practical option if you prefer a continuous surface, but it may not be the first choice if your priority is maximizing airflow under the crust.

The product information says to hand wash this pan. That is a useful detail to consider if you prefer dishwasher-safe bakeware. As with any 16-inch pan, check your oven’s interior dimensions and the frozen pizza’s size before buying.

Pros:

  • Steel-core construction is designed for even heat distribution.
  • PFOA-free nonstick coating helps with food release.
  • Reinforced rim is designed to resist warping.
  • Solid surface supports the pizza across the pan.

Cons:

  • Hand washing is required.
  • It has no perforations for airflow beneath the crust.

Verdict: The Calphalon is a good fit if you want a large, solid nonstick pan and do not mind washing it by hand.

AWTBDP Stainless Steel: Best Smaller Two-Pan Set

This two-pan set includes 13½-inch stainless steel trays with gently sloped edges. The smaller diameter may work better for compact pizzas or ovens where a 16-inch pan would be a tight fit. The edges are intended to help contain toppings, while the pans can also be used for other baking and serving jobs.

The product description emphasizes stainless steel and says the pans are dishwasher-safe. However, the product title calls them “non-stick,” while the detailed description describes stainless steel without a coating. Because those details do not clearly agree, confirm the surface material with the seller if having a nonstick coating is important to you.

These are solid pans, not perforated ones, so they will not provide the same open airflow beneath a pizza as the GoodCook or HONGBAKE options. Their size and two-pan format may still make sense for smaller pies, reheating, or general kitchen use.

Pros:

  • Two pans are included in the set.
  • The 13½-inch size may suit smaller pizzas and ovens.
  • Sloped edges help contain toppings.
  • Product information lists dishwasher-safe cleanup.

Cons:

  • The solid design has no perforations for airflow beneath the crust.
  • The title and description differ on whether the pans have a nonstick surface.

Verdict: Consider this set for smaller pizzas and general use, but clarify the surface description before buying if nonstick performance is a must.

How to Choose a Pizza Pan for Frozen Pizza

Match the Pan Diameter to Your Pizza and Oven

Start by checking the frozen pizza’s diameter and your oven’s usable interior space. A 16-inch pan offers more room but can be oversized for a smaller pizza or oven. The 14-inch HONGBAKE pans and 13½-inch AWTBDP pans are smaller options. Also account for handles when checking the HONGBAKE set, which measures 15.75 inches across with handles.

Choose Between Perforated and Solid Surfaces

Perforated pans have holes that allow airflow beneath the pizza and are designed to reduce moisture at the crust. The GoodCook and HONGBAKE models have this feature. Solid pans offer a continuous surface to support the pizza, but do not provide the same airflow through the base. Consider the crust texture you prefer and follow the frozen pizza package directions.

Consider the Pan Material and Surface

Carbon steel pans in this list have nonstick coatings, while the Kirecoo and AWTBDP products are described as stainless steel. A coating can make release easier, but the AWTBDP listing has conflicting wording about whether its surface is nonstick. Stainless steel may suit shoppers who prefer a pan described without a coating; check each product’s care instructions before use.

Check Temperature Limits and Care Instructions

Match the pan’s stated temperature limit to the baking temperature on your pizza packaging. The HONGBAKE, Kirecoo, and AWTBDP descriptions list oven use up to 450°F. Calphalon specifies hand washing, while the Kirecoo and AWTBDP descriptions say their pans are dishwasher-safe. When product details do not list a limit or care method, check the seller’s current instructions rather than guessing.

Think About Handling and Serving

Handles, feet, and cutting guides can make a pan more convenient after baking. HONGBAKE includes wide handles, GoodCook has cutting guides and feet, and the other pans have their own shapes and surface designs. Remember that a hot pan needs careful handling, and use a suitable heat-safe surface when setting it down.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a perforated pizza pan better for frozen pizza?

It depends on the crust and the baking directions. Perforations allow airflow beneath the pizza and are designed to reduce moisture, which may help the bottom crisp. If the package gives specific instructions for a solid tray or oven rack, follow those directions.

What size pizza pan should I buy?

Choose a pan that fits both the frozen pizza and your oven. Compare the pizza’s stated diameter with the pan’s size, and remember to account for handles or other parts that extend beyond the pan itself.

Can I use a nonstick pan for frozen pizza?

Yes, if the pan’s instructions allow it and the baking temperature is within its stated limit. Follow the pan’s care directions to help protect its coating, and check the pizza packaging for its recommended baking method.

Is stainless steel a good choice for a pizza pan?

Stainless steel can be a useful choice if you want a solid pan without a listed nonstick coating. The stainless steel options here can also serve other kitchen purposes. They are not perforated, so they do not provide the same airflow beneath the crust as the perforated pans.

Can I cut pizza directly on the pan?

Check the pan’s care instructions before cutting on it. The GoodCook pan has cutting guides, but that does not by itself confirm that cutting directly on its coated surface is recommended. For coated pans especially, avoid assuming that a knife is safe for the finish.

Should I follow the pizza package directions or the pan’s directions?

Use both sets of instructions. The pizza package provides its recommended baking method and temperature, while the pan’s instructions explain its safe temperature range and care. If the guidance conflicts, choose a method that stays within the pan’s limits.

Final Recommendation

The GoodCook AirPerfect is the strongest all-around choice here if you want a large perforated pan with cutting guides and countertop feet. Choose HONGBAKE if you prefer a two-pan set with wide handles, Kirecoo if you want large coating-free stainless steel pans, or Calphalon if a solid nonstick surface is your priority. For a smaller set, the AWTBDP pans are worth considering, but confirm their surface details before ordering. Whichever you choose, check the size and temperature guidance against your pizza and oven.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment