A plastic butter container with a lid can keep a stick covered between meals, make countertop storage neater, or help you organize butter in the refrigerator. The right choice depends on the size and style of butter you buy, whether you want an airtight seal, and which extras—such as measurement marks or a knife—would make serving easier.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Capacity or fit | Standout features |
|---|---|---|
| KITCHENDAO Airtight Butter Dish | Eastern and Western butter | Sealing ring, tablespoon marks, non-slip bottom |
| KITCHENDAO Large Airtight Butter Dish | Up to two sticks of Eastern butter | Sealing ring, tablespoon marks, knife rests |
| Dehov Butter Dish with Knife | East Coast or West Coast butter sticks | Included stainless steel knife, dishwasher-safe design |
| pw61 Extra Large Airtight Butter Dish | Full butter stick, with room for extras | 850 ml capacity, magnetic knife, silicone seal |
| Signoraware Butter Dish with Lid | Butter sticks | Stackable design, clear lid, microwave-safe claim |
Our Picks: Best Plastic Butter Container With Lid reviews
1. KITCHENDAO Airtight Butter Dish: Best for Measured Portions
This clear plastic butter dish is designed for countertop or refrigerator-door storage. Its built-in sealing ring is intended to help keep the butter covered, while the clear sides let you see what is inside without lifting the lid.
Small practical details make this model stand out. The tray has tablespoon marks and a slight recess to help hold butter in place, and the non-slip bottom is meant to steady the dish while you cut or scoop. Stops at both ends provide a place to rest or scrape a knife. The container is listed as dishwasher safe.
This is a good fit if you want portion guides and a more secure base without needing a large dish. Its listed fit includes Eastern and Western butter, but the product details do not give a specific capacity. If you regularly store more than one stick, the larger KITCHENDAO model or the 850 ml pw61 dish gives clearer capacity information.
Pros:
- Sealing ring helps limit exposure to air and outside contaminants.
- Table-spoon markings can help with portioning.
- Non-slip bottom and end stops support easier serving.
- Listed as dishwasher safe.
Cons:
- Specific capacity is not provided in the product details.
- A butter knife is not listed as included.
Verdict: Choose this KITCHENDAO dish if you want a compact covered holder with portion marks and a sealing ring, and you do not need a stated multi-stick capacity.
2. KITCHENDAO Large Airtight Butter Dish: Best for Two Sticks
This larger version of the KITCHENDAO butter dish is made for households that want more room in one container. The product details say it can hold up to two sticks of Eastern butter and also list European-style butter and cream cheese among its intended uses.
Like the smaller KITCHENDAO option, it has a built-in sealing ring, tablespoon marks, a recessed tray, and an anti-slip bottom. Stops at both ends are designed to help you scoop butter and scrape excess from a knife. The dish is listed as dishwasher safe.
The extra capacity makes this a more practical pick for frequent cooking, family meals, or keeping a larger supply ready on the counter. The capacity claim is specific to Eastern butter, so check the dimensions and fit against the butter style you usually buy before ordering. Compared with the pw61 model, it offers portion markings, while the pw61 lists a magnetic knife and an 850 ml capacity.
Pros:
- Holds up to two sticks of Eastern butter, according to the product details.
- Sealing ring is designed to help keep butter fresh.
- Table-spoon markings and end stops add serving convenience.
- Listed as dishwasher safe.
Cons:
- Exact dimensions are not included in the supplied product details.
- A knife is not listed as included.
Verdict: Pick this model if you want the measured-serving features of the smaller KITCHENDAO dish with more room for butter.
3. Dehov Butter Dish with Knife: Best for an All-in-One Set
The Dehov set pairs a black plastic butter dish with a stainless steel knife that clips onto the lid. Keeping the utensil with the dish can save you from searching for a separate spreading knife at breakfast or dinner.
The listing describes the tray as spacious enough for East Coast or West Coast butter sticks, as well as homemade butter. It also says the plastic is food grade and BPA-free, and that the lid helps keep out dust and odors. Both the dish and tray are listed as dishwasher safe for top-rack cleaning.
This is a useful choice if having a dedicated knife matters more to you than measurement marks or a specifically described airtight seal. The listing does not provide a capacity figure, and it does not mention a sealing ring. If you want more detailed portioning or a stated airtight design, consider one of the KITCHENDAO dishes instead.
Pros:
- Includes a stainless steel knife that clips onto the lid.
- Designed to fit East Coast or West Coast butter sticks.
- Listing identifies the plastic as food grade and BPA-free.
- Dish and tray are listed as top-rack dishwasher safe.
Cons:
- No capacity figure or portion markings are specified.
- A sealing ring is not listed.
Verdict: Choose the Dehov if keeping a knife with your butter is your priority and you want a dishwasher-safe set.
4. pw61 Extra Large Airtight Butter Dish: Best for Extra Storage
This 850 ml dish is the highest-capacity option in this group. Its product details say it fits a full butter stick along with cream cheese, jam, or margarine, and that it works with East Coast, West Coast, and European butter sizes.
The lid has a silicone sealing ring, and an L-shaped knife attaches magnetically to it. The dish is made from food-grade AS plastic, which the listing describes as BPA-free, shatter-resistant, odor-resistant, and dishwasher safe. Its bright yellow design is a more noticeable countertop choice than the clear or black options here.
The extra room may suit anyone who likes to keep butter and another spread together, but it also means this is not the most compact pick. The listing does not mention tablespoon marks, which the KITCHENDAO models provide. Check the full dimensions before choosing it for a crowded refrigerator shelf or a small counter.
Pros:
- 850 ml capacity accommodates a full stick plus another spread, according to the listing.
- Silicone ring is designed to seal the lid.
- Magnetic knife attaches to the lid for convenient storage.
- Listed as BPA-free and dishwasher safe.
Cons:
- Its extra-large design may take up more counter or refrigerator space.
- Bright yellow may not suit every kitchen style.
Verdict: Select the pw61 if you want the most clearly specified capacity and like the idea of storing a knife and extra spread with your butter.
5. Signoraware Butter Dish: Best for Stackable Storage
The Signoraware butter dish has a red base and a clear lid, so you can see how much butter is left at a glance. Its simple covered design is intended for countertop, refrigerator, or table use, and the product details say the container is nestable and stackable to save storage space.
A low lip inside the dish helps hold butter in place and is described as providing an airtight seal. The listing identifies the plastic as BPA-free and food safe. It also says the container is microwave safe for softening butter, but it does not clarify whether every component is microwave safe; follow the manufacturer’s instructions before heating.
This is the most straightforward option for someone who values a clear lid and space-saving storage over added serving features. It does not list measurement marks, an included knife, or a sealing ring. For more secure sealing details or built-in portion guidance, the KITCHENDAO models offer more specific features.
Pros:
- Clear lid makes it easy to check the remaining butter.
- Nestable and stackable design can help save storage space.
- Listing describes the plastic as BPA-free and food safe.
- Product details state that the container is microwave safe.
Cons:
- No knife or measurement marks are listed.
- Microwave-safe details for individual components are not specified.
Verdict: Choose the Signoraware if you want a simple, stackable dish with a clear lid and do not need an included utensil or portion guide.
How to Choose a Plastic Butter Container With a Lid
Match the Dish to Your Butter Size
Butter styles and stick sizes can vary, so check the product’s stated fit before you buy. The smaller KITCHENDAO dish is described for Eastern and Western butter, while its larger version specifies room for up to two sticks of Eastern butter. The Dehov listing mentions East Coast and West Coast sticks, and the pw61 listing covers East Coast, West Coast, and European styles. If the product does not list dimensions or a clear capacity, compare those details with the butter you normally use.
Decide How Much Capacity You Need
A single-stick dish can be easier to fit on a crowded counter or refrigerator shelf. A larger container may be more useful if you keep extra butter ready or want to store another spread alongside it. Of these options, the KITCHENDAO large model gives a two-stick capacity claim, while the pw61 states an 850 ml capacity. Avoid choosing by the word “large” alone; look for a capacity or fit description that suits your routine.
Look at the Lid and Seal Design
A lid helps cover butter from dust and other outside contaminants, but not every covered dish is described as airtight. The KITCHENDAO models specify a built-in sealing ring, and the pw61 specifies a silicone sealing ring. Signoraware describes a low lip as providing an airtight seal. If keeping butter covered on the counter is important, compare the seal details rather than assuming every lid offers the same level of closure.
Consider Serving and Portion Features
Measurement marks can help you estimate portions, while a dedicated knife means one less utensil to find. Both KITCHENDAO models list tablespoon marks and knife rests or scraping stops. The Dehov includes a stainless steel knife that clips onto the lid, and the pw61 has a magnetically attached knife. The Signoraware focuses on basic storage instead. Choose the features you will use instead of paying for extras that may sit unused.
Check Cleaning and Material Details
Dishwasher guidance varies by product, so check which components are listed as dishwasher safe and whether the instructions specify a rack. The KITCHENDAO dishes are listed as dishwasher safe, Dehov specifies top-rack cleaning, and the pw61 is also listed as dishwasher safe. Signoraware describes its container as microwave safe, but the supplied details do not say which parts can be heated. Follow the maker’s care instructions, especially before using a lid or any attached utensil in an appliance.
Think About Counter and Refrigerator Space
A dish that fits your butter may still be awkward if it takes up too much room. The Signoraware is specifically described as stackable and nestable, while the pw61 has an extra-large capacity. If you plan to use a refrigerator-door shelf, measure the shelf and compare it with the dish’s listed dimensions before ordering. A clear lid can also make it easier to check the contents without opening the container.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best plastic butter container with a lid?
The best choice depends on what matters most to you. The smaller KITCHENDAO dish includes tablespoon marks and a sealing ring, the large KITCHENDAO model is designed for up to two sticks of Eastern butter, and the pw61 offers an 850 ml capacity with a magnetic knife.
Which option includes a butter knife?
The Dehov dish comes with a stainless steel knife that clips onto the lid. The pw61 includes an L-shaped knife that attaches magnetically to the lid.
Which butter dish has portion markings?
Both KITCHENDAO models list tablespoon marks on the tray. The supplied details for the other three options do not mention measurement markings.
Can these butter dishes be used in the refrigerator?
The product descriptions identify the KITCHENDAO dishes, Dehov dish, and pw61 as suitable for refrigerator storage. The Signoraware listing also describes use in the refrigerator. Check the product’s dimensions against your shelf before ordering.
Are these plastic butter dishes dishwasher safe?
The KITCHENDAO dishes are listed as dishwasher safe, Dehov specifies top-rack cleaning, and the pw61 is described as dishwasher safe. The Signoraware details provided do not state that it is dishwasher safe, so check the manufacturer’s care instructions.
Can I put a plastic butter dish in the microwave?
The Signoraware listing says its container is microwave safe, but it does not clarify which components that applies to. The supplied details for the other options do not claim microwave safety. Check the manufacturer’s instructions before heating any plastic dish or lid.
Is an airtight seal necessary for a butter dish?
A seal can help limit exposure to air and outside odors, especially when the dish is stored in the refrigerator. If you plan to keep butter on the counter, remember that a lid does not replace safe food-storage practices. Follow the butter packaging and food-safety guidance that applies to your situation.
Final Recommendation
For a balanced set of everyday features, the KITCHENDAO Airtight Butter Dish is a sensible pick if you want a sealing ring, tablespoon marks, and a non-slip base. Choose the larger KITCHENDAO model when you need more room, the Dehov or pw61 when an included knife matters, or the Signoraware when stackable storage is your main concern. Compare the stated fit and dimensions with your butter and available shelf space before making your choice.