Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Storage & Dining

Best Plastic Tops For Mason Jars: 5 Wide and Regular Mouth Picks

Updated 9 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 9minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

Plastic mason jar tops make glass jars easier to reuse for pantry staples, leftovers, drinks, and other everyday storage. The key is choosing the right mouth size: wide-mouth and regular-mouth lids are not interchangeable. These five options include single-size packs and mixed sets, with differences in sealing features, quantity, and intended fit.

Quick Comparison

ProductFitPack detailsStandout feature
AOZITA Wide-Mouth LidsWide mouth10 lidsIncluded sealing rings
AOZITA Mixed Regular and Wide-Mouth SetRegular and wide mouth10 of each sizeUseful mixed-size assortment
Ball Leak-Proof Wide-Mouth LidsWide mouth12 lids totalBall-branded storage option
AOZITA Regular-Mouth LidsRegular mouth12 lidsSealing rings included
Masontops Tough TopsWide mouthPack quantity not specified in the supplied detailsFaceted sides and silicone gaskets

Our Picks: Best Plastic Tops For Mason Jars reviews

Best Basic Wide-Mouth Set: AOZITA 10-Pack Lids

This AOZITA set includes 10 white plastic lids for wide-mouth mason jars. The listed fit is for jars with an outer mouth diameter of 3.38 inches (86 mm), including compatible Ball and Kerr jars. Each lid has a sealing ring, which is intended to help create a better seal when the lid is in place.

The food-grade plastic is described as BPA-free and dishwasher safe. The product is also described for refrigerator, freezer, dry-storage, and liquid-storage use. That makes this a straightforward choice if most of your jars share the wide-mouth size and you want lids for foods, drinks, or pantry items.

The main limitation is the single-size selection: these will not fit regular-mouth jars. The supplied description calls the lids leak-proof, but a good fit and properly seated sealing ring still matter, especially when carrying a jar with liquid. These are storage caps, not replacements for canning lids used to process jars.

Pros:

  • Includes 10 wide-mouth lids
  • Sealing rings are included
  • Described as dishwasher safe, BPA-free, and suitable for freezer and refrigerator storage
  • Fits compatible wide-mouth Ball, Kerr, and other jars

Cons:

  • Only fits wide-mouth jars
  • White plastic may not suit shoppers looking for colored lids

Verdict: Choose this set if you want a simple supply of wide-mouth storage lids with included sealing rings.

Best Mixed Set: AOZITA Regular and Wide-Mouth Lids

This 20-piece AOZITA set provides 10 regular-mouth lids and 10 wide-mouth lids. The regular size is listed for jars with a 2.75-inch (70 mm) outer mouth diameter, while the wide size fits a 3.38-inch (86 mm) outer diameter. Having both sizes on hand is useful if your jar collection includes a mix of openings.

The lids are described as food-grade, BPA-free, dishwasher safe, and airtight and leakproof. The product details also mention freezer and refrigerator storage and use with both dry and liquid foods. Its anti-scratch surface is another small practical feature for lids that may be handled or stacked often.

A mixed set is less efficient if you only own one jar size, since some lids may go unused. Before ordering, check the opening of your jars rather than relying on the jar’s capacity or brand name alone. The set is for storage; it should not be treated as a canning-process closure.

Pros:

  • Includes 10 lids in each of the two common mouth sizes
  • Lists the compatible outer mouth diameters for both sizes
  • Described as BPA-free and dishwasher safe
  • Useful for dry foods and liquids in refrigerator or freezer storage

Cons:

  • May include an unnecessary size if all your jars have the same opening
  • White is the only color listed in the supplied details

Verdict: This is the most flexible pick if you need storage lids for a collection with both regular- and wide-mouth jars.

Best Ball-Branded Pick: Ball Leak-Proof Wide-Mouth Lids

These Ball plastic lids are designed for wide-mouth Ball glass mason jars and are intended for everyday storage. The supplied details describe them as reusable and leak-proof, for uses such as keeping juice, jam, pickled foods, sauces, dry ingredients, and leftovers covered.

The listing describes two packs of six lids, for 12 wide-mouth lids total. Compared with the AOZITA wide-mouth set, this option is specifically presented as a Ball-branded lid and does not list the same food-grade, BPA-free, dishwasher-safe, or freezer-use details in the supplied product information. Check the product listing for any care guidance you need before use.

These lids are a focused choice if you mainly use compatible wide-mouth Ball jars. They are not a mixed-size solution, and their wide-mouth design will not fit regular-mouth jars. Like other plastic storage caps, they are for covering jars during storage, not for processing home-canned food.

Pros:

  • 12 wide-mouth lids total, according to the supplied description
  • Designed for compatible wide-mouth Ball glass jars
  • Reusable plastic construction
  • Listed for a range of everyday food-storage uses

Cons:

  • Only intended for wide-mouth jars
  • The supplied details do not specify dishwasher or freezer safety

Verdict: Pick these if you want a Ball-branded wide-mouth storage lid and do not need a regular-mouth size.

Best Regular-Mouth Set: AOZITA 12-Pack Lids

For jars with regular-size openings, this AOZITA set supplies 12 plastic lids. The listed fit is a 2.75-inch (70 mm) outer diameter, and the product description names compatible Ball, Kerr, and other regular-mouth jars. Each lid includes a sealing ring to help improve the seal.

The lids have an anti-scratch surface and are described as food-grade, BPA-free, dishwasher safe, and suitable for refrigerator and freezer storage. The supplied details also describe them for dry and liquid foods, including pantry ingredients and drinks. Those features make this a practical option when you want several matching lids for regular-mouth jars.

Its biggest drawback is also its defining feature: it is a regular-mouth-only set. Measure or check the mouth size of your jars before buying, since a lid that looks close may not thread on correctly. The product is described as leakproof for storage, but it is not a substitute for a canning closure used during processing.

Pros:

  • Includes 12 regular-mouth lids
  • Sealing rings are included
  • Described as BPA-free and dishwasher safe
  • Listed for freezer, refrigerator, dry, and liquid storage

Cons:

  • Does not fit wide-mouth jars
  • Only one color is listed

Verdict: This set is a solid fit for shoppers who need multiple regular-mouth storage lids with sealing rings.

Best Grip-Focused Design: Masontops Tough Tops

Masontops Tough Tops are reusable plastic lids made for wide-mouth mason jars. Their defining feature is a faceted outer edge designed to give you a more secure grip when opening and closing the lid. The supplied description also says the faceted sides can help keep a jar from rolling if it falls onto its side.

These lids use silicone gaskets and are described as providing an airtight, leak-proof seal. The plastic is stated to be food safe, BPA-free, and free of phthalates. The product details also say the lids can go in the dishwasher and freezer, which makes them a useful option for people who want one lid style for a variety of storage tasks.

Compared with the AOZITA wide-mouth set, Tough Tops emphasize grip and a precision-engineered gasket rather than a stated 10-piece count. The supplied details do not specify the pack quantity, so check the listing if you need a particular number of lids. They are wide-mouth only and are not intended to replace canning lids during processing.

Pros:

  • Faceted sides are designed to make the lids easier to grip
  • Silicone gaskets are intended to create an airtight, leak-proof seal
  • Described as food safe, BPA-free, and phthalate-free
  • Listed as dishwasher and freezer safe

Cons:

  • Only fits wide-mouth jars
  • Pack quantity is not specified in the supplied product details

Verdict: Choose Tough Tops if an easy-grip design and silicone gasket matter more to you than a clearly stated multi-lid count.

How to Choose Plastic Tops for Mason Jars

Match the Lid to the Jar Opening

Start by identifying whether your jar is regular mouth or wide mouth. The products in this guide list regular-mouth openings at 2.75 inches (70 mm) and wide-mouth openings at 3.38 inches (86 mm), measured by outer diameter. A mixed set can cover both types, while a single-size pack is a better fit if your jars all share the same opening. Check the jar or product details if you are unsure.

Consider How Many Lids You Need

Think about how many jars you use at once for leftovers, meal prep, drinks, or pantry storage. The listed sets range from 10 lids in one size to a mixed set with 10 of each size, while the Ball option lists 12 total. The Masontops details provided here do not specify a pack quantity, so confirm the listing if quantity is important to your choice.

Look at the Seal Design

Some lids include sealing rings or silicone gaskets. These features are intended to help the lid seal against the jar, which can be useful when storing liquids or foods that need to stay covered. A leak-proof claim does not mean every jar-and-lid combination will seal perfectly in every situation, so make sure the lid is compatible and seated correctly before moving a jar.

Check the Care and Storage Guidance

Dishwasher, freezer, and refrigerator suitability can vary by product. The AOZITA options and Masontops Tough Tops are described as dishwasher safe, and the supplied details also list freezer or refrigerator use. The Ball product information provided here does not specify those care details. Follow the instructions on the product listing rather than assuming all plastic lids can be used in the same conditions.

Separate Storage Lids from Canning Lids

Plastic tops are convenient for covering jars used for everyday storage, but they are not the same as the closures used to process jars for shelf-stable canning. If you are preserving food through a canning process, use the appropriate canning equipment and instructions. Choose a plastic lid for storage after opening or for foods and supplies that do not require canning processing.

Choose Features That Fit Your Routine

A simple lid set may be enough for basic refrigerator or pantry use. If you frequently open and close jars, a grip-focused edge may be worth considering. If you use both jar sizes, a mixed set can save you from buying separate packs. Base your choice on the jars you own and the kind of storage you do most often.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are regular-mouth and wide-mouth mason jar lids interchangeable?

No. They have different opening sizes. The products here list regular-mouth lids for a 2.75-inch (70 mm) outer diameter and wide-mouth lids for a 3.38-inch (86 mm) outer diameter. Check your jar’s mouth size before ordering.

Can plastic mason jar lids be used for canning?

The lids in this guide are described as storage caps. They should not be treated as replacements for the closures and equipment required to process jars for canning. Follow a reliable canning method and use the specified canning supplies.

Are these lids suitable for liquids?

Several options are described for liquid storage, and some are specifically called leak-proof. For best results, confirm the lid fits the jar, seat it properly, and handle jars with liquids carefully.

Can I put plastic mason jar lids in the dishwasher?

The AOZITA lids and Masontops Tough Tops are described as dishwasher safe. The supplied details for the Ball lids do not state whether they are dishwasher safe, so check the product instructions before washing them that way.

Can these lids go in the freezer?

The AOZITA options and Masontops Tough Tops are described for freezer use. The Ball lid details supplied here do not specify freezer suitability. Check the instructions for the specific lid you choose.

What is the best option if I own both jar sizes?

The AOZITA mixed set includes 10 regular-mouth and 10 wide-mouth lids, making it the clearest choice in this list for a collection with both opening sizes.

Which pick is best for a wide-mouth jar collection?

The AOZITA 10-pack is a straightforward choice if you want a stated quantity and included sealing rings. Masontops Tough Tops are worth considering if you prefer faceted sides and a silicone gasket, while the Ball option is a brand-specific alternative.

Final Recommendation

For most people who need a dependable supply of wide-mouth storage caps, the AOZITA 10-pack offers a clear combination of stated fit, included sealing rings, and described refrigerator and freezer use. If your jars have both opening sizes, the AOZITA mixed set is more practical. Whichever option you choose, confirm the mouth size and use plastic tops for storage rather than as a substitute for canning closures.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment