Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Cookware & Kitchen Tools

Best Pot Pie Pans With Lids

Updated 10 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 10minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

Choosing the best pot pie pan with a lid depends on the serving size you want, how much filling you need to hold, and whether you plan to bake a few pies or prepare a batch for an event. The options here are mostly disposable aluminum pans with clear plastic lids, so they can work for baking and make it easier to store or transport individual portions. Keep the lid off while baking, and check the product listing for the pan’s dimensions and capacity before ordering.

Quick Comparison: Best Pot Pie Pans With Lids

ProductSize or capacityPack detailsBest for
Durable Packaging Extra-Deep Pot Pie Pan5¾ inches; 14 ounces25 pans with lidsBatch baking and deeper individual pies
KitchenDance 5-Inch Mini Tart Pan5 inchesPack quantity not specifiedSmall pies, tarts, and portion-controlled servings
PACTOGO 5¾-Inch Pot Pie Pan12 ounces; 1½-inch vertical depth12 pans with lidsSmaller individual pot pies
Jijukor 5-Inch Mini Aluminum Pan9 ounces20 pans with lidsCompact single servings and meal prep
PACTOGO Extra-Deep Pot Pie Pan14.6 ounces; 1 13/16-inch vertical depth12 pans with lidsDeeper individual pies and generous fillings

The supplied listing information marks the Jijukor and second PACTOGO options as unavailable. Availability can change, so check the product page before planning a purchase.

Our Picks: Best Pot Pie Pans With Lids reviews

1. Durable Packaging Extra-Deep Pan: Best for Baking a Batch

This 5¾-inch aluminum pan is designed for individual meat pies and other small baked dishes. Its listed 14-ounce capacity and extra-deep profile give you more room for filling than a shallow mini pie tin. The package includes 25 pans and clear snap-on lids, making it a practical option when you’re preparing several portions at once.

The product description specifies 30-gauge aluminum and says the pans are designed to resist warping in the oven. Each lid adds 1¾ inches above the pan, which can help protect a finished pie during storage or transport. Remove the plastic lid before baking, and use a sheet pan underneath when moving filled foil pans for extra support.

This is the strongest fit for batch cooking, catering, or making individual pies ahead of time. Compared with the 12-ounce PACTOGO option, its listed capacity is larger; compared with the 5-inch tart pan, it is more clearly suited to a substantial savory serving. The trade-off is that it is disposable rather than a reusable bakeware choice.

Pros:

  • 25 pans and matching lids for batch preparation
  • 14-ounce capacity and extra-deep design
  • 30-gauge aluminum construction
  • Aluminum is described as recyclable

Cons:

  • Disposable construction is not ideal if you want reusable pans
  • The clear plastic lid should not be used in the oven

Verdict: Choose this pan if you need a larger pack of deeper individual pans for pot pies, casseroles, or similar dishes.

2. KitchenDance 5-Inch Mini Pan: Best for Smaller Portions

This 5-inch foil pan is intended for individual pies, tarts, cobblers, cakes, and other small baked goods. Its compact size can suit a modest pot pie portion or a dessert that you want to bake and serve without transferring it to another dish. The product information highlights even heat distribution and says the pans can be baked at temperatures up to 500°F.

Unlike the other options here, the supplied description does not state the pack quantity, pan capacity, or detailed depth. That makes it harder to compare serving size directly with the 12-ounce and 14-ounce choices. Check the listing dimensions and package details before ordering if you need a specific amount or size.

The listing describes the pans as recyclable and reusable, but they are still thin disposable-style foil pans rather than rigid reusable bakeware. This is a flexible pick for mini pies and mixed baking projects; for a deep, generously filled pot pie, one of the explicitly deep pans may be a better match.

Pros:

  • 5-inch size suits small individual portions
  • Can be used for pies, tarts, cobblers, and cakes
  • Product information lists baking up to 500°F
  • Described as recyclable and reusable

Cons:

  • Capacity and pack quantity are not specified in the supplied details
  • Less clearly suited to deep, heavily filled pot pies

Verdict: Pick this option for small pies and varied baking, but confirm its dimensions and package quantity if those details matter to your recipe.

3. PACTOGO 12-Ounce Pan: Best for Smaller Savory Pies

This PACTOGO set includes 12 aluminum pans and 12 matching clear dome lids. Each pan has a listed 12-ounce capacity, a 1½-inch vertical depth, and a 5¾-inch top-out diameter. That combination makes it a specific option for individual pot pies when you want a defined portion size without stepping up to the deeper 14.6-ounce model.

The product description calls the pans sturdy and says they are made with American-sourced aluminum. The dome lids are useful for covering baked goods or packing them for transport, but they are not cooking lids; remove them before the pans go into the oven. Since foil pans can flex under a heavy filling, carrying them on a baking sheet or tray is a sensible precaution.

Compared with the first pick, this set contains fewer pans and has a smaller stated capacity. It may suit a smaller household or a recipe that calls for less filling per pie. The dimensions are clearly provided, which helps if you are matching the pans to a particular recipe or storage space.

Pros:

  • Includes 12 pans and 12 matching dome lids
  • 12-ounce capacity is clearly stated
  • Listed 5¾-inch top-out diameter and 1½-inch depth aid size comparisons
  • Made with American-sourced aluminum, according to the product description

Cons:

  • Smaller capacity than the 14-ounce and 14.6-ounce options
  • Disposable foil may need support when carrying a filled pan

Verdict: Choose this set when a 12-ounce individual pie is the portion you want and a 12-pan pack is enough.

4. Jijukor 9-Ounce Mini Pan: Best for Compact Meal Prep

The Jijukor set is described as a 20-pack of 5-inch aluminum pans with matching clear plastic lids. Each pan holds 9 ounces, making it the smallest stated capacity among these options. That compact size may work for a light individual meal, a side, or a small dessert, though it offers less room for filling than the larger pot pie pans.

The product details describe the aluminum containers as oven-safe and the lids as snug-fitting for storage and transport. They also clearly state that the plastic lids are not oven- or microwave-safe. Remove the lid before heating, and do not put the aluminum pan in a microwave.

The 20-pan quantity can be convenient for meal prep or serving a group, but the supplied listing data marks this product as unavailable. If it is not offered when you check, the 5-inch KitchenDance pan is another compact option, though its capacity and pack quantity are not specified in the supplied details.

Pros:

  • 20 pans with matching clear lids
  • Compact 5-inch size and stated 9-ounce capacity
  • Product information describes the pans as oven-safe
  • Lids are described as a snug fit for storage and transport

Cons:

  • Smaller capacity than the other pot pie pans with stated capacities
  • Listing information supplied for this article marks it unavailable

Verdict: Consider this set if you want compact, 9-ounce portions, but check availability and avoid the plastic lids during heating.

5. PACTOGO 14.6-Ounce Deep Pan: Best for a Roomier Filling

This PACTOGO option is the deepest pan in the lineup based on the listed vertical measurements. Each pan is 1 13/16 inches deep and has a stated capacity of 14.6 fluid ounces. The pack includes 12 pans and 12 matching dome lids, making it suitable for individual pies with more filling than the 12-ounce PACTOGO model can hold.

The product description says the pans are sturdy, made with American-sourced aluminum, and recyclable. It also gives top-out, top-in, and bottom measurements, which is useful if you need to check fit in a carrier or compare the pan with a recipe. As with the other foil choices, use the plastic lid for covering or transport rather than baking.

This pan’s higher stated capacity makes it a strong match for deeper savory pies, but the supplied listing data marks it as unavailable. If you cannot find it, the 14-ounce Durable Packaging pan is the closest listed alternative by capacity and also comes with clear lids, though its pack size and depth differ.

Pros:

  • Largest stated capacity in this comparison at 14.6 ounces
  • 1 13/16-inch vertical depth for deeper fillings
  • Includes 12 pans and 12 dome lids
  • Product description identifies the aluminum as recyclable

Cons:

  • Listing information supplied for this article marks it unavailable
  • Smaller pack than the 25-count Durable Packaging option

Verdict: This is a good specification match for a deeper, generously filled personal pie if it is available; otherwise, compare the Durable Packaging 14-ounce pan.

How to Choose Pot Pie Pans With Lids

Match the capacity to your serving size

Capacity is a useful way to compare pans when the dimensions are close. The options with stated capacities range from 9 ounces to 14.6 ounces. A smaller pan can suit a modest portion or a side dish, while a larger capacity gives you more room for filling. Keep in mind that the amount you can use also depends on your crust and recipe, so leave room at the top rather than filling a pan to its brim.

Check diameter and depth together

A pan’s diameter alone does not tell you how much it can hold. Compare the top and bottom measurements, where provided, along with the vertical depth. The deeper PACTOGO pan is listed at 1 13/16 inches, while the other PACTOGO model is 1½ inches deep. If you have a specific recipe or storage container in mind, check the full dimensions before buying.

Choose a pack size that fits your plans

A large pack can make sense if you bake for a group, prepare freezer meals, or use pans for more than one type of dish. The Durable Packaging set includes 25 pans, while the PACTOGO sets include 12 each. The Jijukor product is described as a 20-pack. For the KitchenDance pan, the supplied product details do not state a quantity, so confirm that information on the listing.

Think about how you will use the lids

Clear lids are useful for covering a cooled pie and helping protect it during storage or transport. They are not a substitute for an oven-safe cover. The Jijukor product information explicitly says its plastic lids are not oven- or microwave-safe; for the other options, the listings describe the lids as covers rather than cooking lids. Remove plastic lids before baking or reheating.

Consider how you will move filled foil pans

Disposable aluminum pans are lightweight, but they can flex more than rigid bakeware, especially when filled with a dense pie. Set a filled pan on a baking sheet before placing it in the oven, and carry it on a flat tray when possible. This also makes it easier to move several individual pies at once.

Decide whether disposable or reusable suits you

Disposable foil pans are convenient when you want to bake, serve, or transport portions without washing a pan afterward. Some of the listings describe their aluminum pans as recyclable, but recycling rules vary by location, and pans should be clean enough for your local program. If you bake pot pies often and prefer long-term use, a reusable pan may be a better fit than the disposable options in this comparison.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I bake with the clear lid on?

No. These products pair aluminum baking pans with clear plastic lids intended for covering, storage, or transport. Remove the lid before putting the pan in the oven.

Are aluminum pot pie pans safe to put in a microwave?

Do not put these aluminum pans in a microwave. Aluminum is metal, and the Jijukor product details specifically warn that its plastic lids are not microwave-safe either. Use an appropriate microwave-safe dish if you need to reheat a portion in a microwave.

Which option has the largest stated capacity?

The PACTOGO extra-deep pan has the largest stated capacity in this comparison at 14.6 fluid ounces. Its supplied listing information marks it as unavailable, so check the product page or consider the 14-ounce Durable Packaging pan as an alternative.

Which pan is best for making several pot pies at once?

The Durable Packaging option includes 25 pans and lids, the largest stated pack in this group. It also has a listed 14-ounce capacity, which may suit deeper individual pies.

Are these pans reusable?

They are disposable-style aluminum pans. Some product descriptions say the pans can be reused, but they are not presented as rigid, permanent bakeware. Handle them carefully, especially when filled, and follow the manufacturer’s care guidance.

What should I do if a product is listed as unavailable?

Availability can change. Check the product page for current status, or compare the stated capacity and depth with another option in this guide. For example, the 14-ounce Durable Packaging pan is a possible alternative to the unavailable 14.6-ounce PACTOGO pan.

Final Recommendation

For most people who want a larger batch of lidded individual pans, the Durable Packaging 14-ounce set is the best all-around fit: it includes 25 pans, has an extra-deep design, and provides a clearly stated capacity. Choose the 12-ounce PACTOGO set if you want a smaller portion in a 12-pan pack. For the deepest listed pan, the 14.6-ounce PACTOGO is appealing on paper, but confirm its availability before planning around it.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment