Heel spurs can be uncomfortable, but the right insert may help cushion your heel and reduce pressure while you walk or stand. The best choice depends on where you feel pain, how much room your shoes have, and whether you need heel cushioning alone or support across more of your foot. These five options include full-length orthotics, gel heel cups, and shorter inserts. An insert may ease discomfort, but it does not remove a heel spur or replace medical advice.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Type | Key feature | Best suited for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Scholl’s Plantar Fasciitis Relief Orthotic Insoles | Full-length orthotic | Arch support and deep heel cup | People who want support across the foot |
| Welnove Gel Heel Protector Cups | Gel heel cups | Breathable fabric and adjustable band | Targeted cushioning that stays in place |
| Figly Gel Heel Cups | Silicone heel cups | Medical-grade silicone and two size options | Soft, shock-absorbing heel cushioning |
| SQHT 3/4 Heel Insoles | Three-quarter-length insert | Heel support with an extra metatarsal pad pair | People who need more toe-box room |
| Black Deer Orthopedic Heel Supports | Structured heel cups | Non-silicone cushioning design | People who prefer a firmer feel than soft gel |
Our Picks: Best Shoe Inserts For Heel Spurs reviews
Dr. Scholl’s Plantar Fasciitis Relief Insoles: Best Full-Foot Support
Unlike a heel cup that cushions only the back of your foot, this full-length orthotic is designed to support the arch and distribute pressure across the foot. Its deep heel cup is intended to absorb shock and provide stability, while the arch support is meant to limit overstretching of the plantar fascia.
The insole can be trimmed to fit, which may help when you’re moving it into shoes with removable liners. It is a practical option if your discomfort seems connected to both heel impact and a need for arch support. The product description says it supports different arch types, including high arches, but comfort still depends on how the shape matches your foot.
Because it runs the full length of the shoe, check that your footwear has enough space before installing it. It may feel more substantial than a slim heel pad, and trimming or swapping out the original liner may be needed for a good fit. Compared with the other picks here, this is the broadest support option rather than a heel-only cushion.
Pros:
- Full-length design supports the arch as well as the heel.
- Deep heel cup is designed to cushion and stabilize the heel.
- Can be trimmed to fit the shoe.
- Designed for several arch types, including high arches.
Cons:
- May take up more shoe space than a heel cup.
- Requires trimming for some shoes and sizes.
Verdict: Choose this insole if you want heel cushioning paired with arch support and your shoes have room for a full-length insert.
Welnove Gel Heel Protector Cups: Best Adjustable Heel Cushion
Welnove’s heel protectors use thicker gel cushioning inside a fabric cup. Air holes in the design are intended to improve breathability, and an elastic band helps hold each cup around the heel. That band makes these different from inserts that simply sit inside the shoe.
The cups are designed for targeted cushioning and can be worn with several kinds of footwear, including boots, sneakers, and some sandals. The listed small size fits women’s shoe sizes 4.5–9 and men’s sizes 5–8; the product information suggests considering a larger size for wide feet. Check the current size options and fit details before ordering, especially if you plan to wear them in a close-fitting shoe.
These are a better match for people who want cushioning around the heel without adding a full-length insole. The trade-off is that the band and cup may not suit every shoe or wearer, and the product listing notes they work best with larger or wider shoes. They also do not provide the same arch support as the Dr. Scholl’s orthotic.
Pros:
- Thicker gel is designed to cushion heel impact.
- Elastic band helps keep the cups in place.
- Fabric design includes air holes for breathability.
- Can be used with several footwear styles.
Cons:
- The listed small size may not fit every foot; check the size guidance carefully.
- May take up too much room in snug shoes.
Verdict: Consider Welnove if you want a heel-focused gel cushion with a band to help keep it positioned, and your footwear has enough room.
Figly Gel Heel Cups: Best Soft Silicone Cushioning
Figly’s heel cups are made from medical-grade silicone and use thick gel padding to cushion the heel. Their cup shape is designed to hold the heel and spread pressure through the pad, making them a straightforward option if you want cushioning without a full insole.
The product is offered in small/medium and large sizes, with sizing guidance intended for men, women, and children. It also has a sweat-resistant coating and is described as suitable for different shoe styles. Check the size chart before choosing: a heel cup that is too large or small may not sit securely or comfortably in your shoe.
This option focuses on cushioning and heel stabilization rather than arch support. The soft silicone feel may suit people who want a pliable pad, but it will not provide the broader foot support of a full-length orthotic. The product title identifies a four-pack, so check the package details for the included pieces and configuration when ordering.
Pros:
- Silicone gel is designed to absorb shock and cushion the heel.
- Two size options provide a choice of fit.
- Cup shape is intended to stabilize and distribute pressure around the heel.
- Designed for use with multiple shoe styles.
Cons:
- Does not provide the arch support of a full-length orthotic.
- Fit depends on choosing the right size and having enough room in the shoe.
Verdict: Pick Figly if you prefer a soft silicone heel cup and want to choose between two size options rather than use a full-length insert.
SQHT 3/4 Heel Insoles: Best for Saving Toe-Box Space
SQHT’s three-quarter-length inserts are designed to support the heel and arch while leaving the front of the shoe more open than a full-length insole. The set includes a pair of heel inserts and an extra pair of metatarsal pads. The heel section has a deep U-shaped support, low arch, and a mix of PU foam and gel, with a velvet top layer and a PORON cushioning pad on the bottom.
The shorter design requires no trimming and may be useful if a full-length insert crowds your toes. The product information cautions against using these in low-top or narrow shoes, so check the shape and space inside your footwear before buying. Although the title specifies men, the description also presents the inserts as suitable for men and women.
Compared with simple gel cups, SQHT provides more of an insert-style base and includes a separate metatarsal pad pair. That added coverage may be helpful if you want more than a heel cushion, but the extra parts and 3/4 shape may take some adjustment to position comfortably. It is not the best pick for every shoe, particularly if the shoe is narrow or low-cut.
Pros:
- Three-quarter length leaves more toe-box room than a full-length insert.
- Includes an extra pair of metatarsal pads.
- Deep heel support combines foam and gel cushioning.
- No trimming is required.
Cons:
- Not recommended in low-top or narrow shoes.
- Positioning the insert and extra pads may take some care.
Verdict: Choose SQHT if you want a shorter insert with heel support and extra metatarsal pads, provided your shoes are roomy enough and not low-cut.
Black Deer Orthopedic Heel Supports: Best Structured, Non-Silicone Option
Black Deer’s heel supports are designed to cushion the heel and absorb impact in shoes such as sneakers, work shoes, and boots. Unlike the silicone and gel-focused choices in this roundup, the product is described as using a structured, non-silicone material intended to provide a firmer, more stable feel.
The design is aimed at targeted heel support rather than arch support across the whole foot. That can make it a simpler alternative to a full-length orthotic if your main concern is heel cushioning. The product information does not specify detailed sizing or trimming instructions, so confirm fit and compatibility with your shoe before relying on it for everyday wear.
Its claimed compatibility with several shoe types is useful, but a heel support can still feel different depending on the space and shape inside each shoe. If you want a soft, flexible gel cup, Figly or Welnove may be a closer match. If you want an insert that supports the arch too, consider Dr. Scholl’s or SQHT instead.
Pros:
- Structured material offers an alternative to silicone heel pads.
- Designed for heel cushioning and shock absorption.
- Intended for sneakers, work shoes, boots, and daily footwear.
- Focused heel support avoids adding a full-length insole.
Cons:
- Does not provide the broad arch support of a full-length orthotic.
- The supplied product information gives limited detail about sizing.
Verdict: Consider Black Deer if you prefer a more structured, non-silicone heel support and do not need full-foot arch coverage.
How to Choose Shoe Inserts for Heel Spurs
Decide whether you need heel cushioning or broader support
A heel cup targets the heel and can be a simple choice if you mainly want cushioning at the back of your foot. A full-length orthotic or 3/4 insert covers more of the foot and may suit you better if arch support is also a priority. These designs feel different, so consider where you feel discomfort and what kind of support you can comfortably wear.
Match the insert to your shoe’s space and shape
Check whether your shoe has a removable liner and enough room for an added insert. Full-length orthotics can occupy more space, while heel cups may crowd the heel area or alter how your shoe fits. Shorter inserts leave more room at the toes, but the SQHT product information advises against low-top and narrow shoes.
Choose a material and feel you can tolerate
Gel and silicone heel cups are designed to provide soft, targeted cushioning. Structured materials may feel firmer and offer a different kind of stability. Since personal comfort varies, consider whether you prefer a soft pad or a more supportive insert, and pay attention to any material or design details that could affect fit in your shoes.
Check the size details before ordering
Heel cups depend on a good fit to sit comfortably, and size ranges vary by product. Welnove lists specific shoe-size guidance for its small option and suggests a larger size for wide feet. Figly offers two size options and a size chart. When sizing information is limited, confirm the current product details before purchasing.
Consider how long you wear your shoes
If you stand or walk for long periods, think about whether you want a heel-only cushion or support across more of your foot. A heel cup is easy to move between shoes, while an insole may work better when left in a particular pair. Try a new insert for a limited period at first and stop using it if it increases discomfort.
Know when to seek medical advice
Heel pain can have causes other than a heel spur, and the presence of a spur does not always explain the pain. Inserts may help with comfort, but they do not diagnose or treat the underlying cause. If pain is severe, persistent, getting worse, or interfering with walking, consult a health professional for guidance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can shoe inserts get rid of a heel spur?
No. Inserts are intended to cushion or support the foot, which may help with comfort, but they do not remove a heel spur. A health professional can help assess ongoing heel pain and discuss appropriate care.
Are heel cups or full-length insoles better for heel spurs?
It depends on your needs. Heel cups focus cushioning around the heel. Full-length insoles cover more of the foot and may add arch support. Consider your comfort, the location of your pain, and the space available inside your shoes.
Can I wear heel cups in different shoes?
Some heel cups are designed for several footwear styles, but fit can vary from shoe to shoe. Check that the cup sits securely and does not make your shoe feel too tight. Welnove also notes that its product works best with larger or wider shoes.
Will a full-length insole fit every shoe?
No. A full-length insert can take up space, especially in a shoe with a snug toe box. Some products can be trimmed, but check the shoe and product instructions first. A shorter insert may leave more room at the front of the shoe.
How do I choose the right heel cup size?
Use the size chart and shoe-size guidance supplied for the specific product. For Welnove, the listed small size covers women’s shoe sizes 4.5–9 and men’s sizes 5–8, with a suggestion to size up for wide feet. Figly offers small/medium and large options.
Should I keep wearing an insert if it makes my heel hurt more?
No. Stop using an insert if it increases pain or causes new discomfort. Check its fit and placement, and seek medical advice if the problem continues or affects your ability to walk.
Conclusion
For support across the heel and arch, Dr. Scholl’s full-length orthotic is the most versatile choice in this group, as long as your shoes have enough room. If you want cushioning focused on the heel, Figly and Welnove offer gel-based options, while Black Deer provides a structured non-silicone alternative. SQHT is worth considering when you want a shorter insert and extra metatarsal pads, but it is not intended for low-top or narrow shoes. Choose based on fit and support needs, and consult a health professional if heel pain persists or worsens.
