Best Silicone Ice Cube Tray Dishwasher Safe: Our 5 Top Picks Compared

If you have ever dug a stubborn cube out of a rigid plastic tray with a butter knife, you already know why silicone has become so popular. A good silicone ice cube tray flexes enough to release clean cubes, and the best models also hold up to repeated washing. Since many shoppers want trays they can toss in the dishwasher, this guide focuses on five dishwasher-safe options. We compare their sizes, lids, cube counts, and everyday strengths so you can pick the one that fits your freezer and your drinks.

Quick Comparison Table

Our Picks: Best Silicone Ice Cube Tray Dishwasher Safe reviews

Amytor 14-Ice Silicone Trays With Removable Lid for Stacking and Storage

This two-pack from Amytor gives you 28 cubes in total, split across two silicone trays. Each tray has a removable lid, which is the main reason to consider it. The lid helps keep freezer odors and dust away from your ice, and it lets you stack trays in the freezer without taking up extra room. For anyone who keeps a crowded freezer, that stacking feature is more useful than it sounds.

The trays are made from silicone with a PP component and are labeled as 100% BPA free. The listing recommends boiling the trays for 30 minutes or so before first use, then filling them with pure water. That step is a common recommendation for new silicone molds, and it is worth doing before your first batch. The bottom of each tray uses a firmer material that helps the cubes release. Each cube sits in its own compartment, so you can push one out from below without bending the whole tray.

In everyday use, these trays suit home bars and kitchens that make a steady supply of ice for drinks. Many owners appreciate the lids, since they allow you to store filled trays without worrying about the ice picking up freezer smells. The cleanup is simple, as the listing states the trays can be rinsed by hand or run through the dishwasher. The silicone is flexible, so the trays pop cubes out with little effort, although very large batches can feel a bit bulky to handle when you are filling them.

Compared with the OXO option, this set produces smaller cubes and offers more cubes per tray. If you want big, slow-melting cubes for spirits, the OXO is the better match. If you want a practical, covered set that makes plenty of ice for guests, this one is a strong pick. Because the UrbAmerican set shares nearly the same design and cube count, the choice between them comes down to small details and price.

Pros:

• Removable lids help keep ice fresh and make stacking in the freezer easier
• Two trays provide 28 cubes, which is enough for entertaining
• Flexible silicone and individual cube compartments make release simple
• Dishwasher safe, with a quick hand-rinse option for busy days

Cons:

• The listing calls for a boil-in-water step before first use, which adds a small setup task

Verdict: The Amytor set is a practical, all-around choice for households that want plenty of covered ice cubes and easy cleanup. If you mainly want large cubes for sipping spirits, look at the OXO instead.

OXO Good Grips Covered Tray for Large, Slow-Melting Ice Cubes

The OXO Good Grips covered tray is designed for people who prefer large cubes. It makes six cubes that measure about 1¾ inches across, which is a good size for whiskey, bourbon, and other drinks you want to sip slowly. Larger cubes melt more slowly than small ones, so they chill a glass without diluting it as quickly. The tray comes in dark blue and includes a lid.

The tray is built from flexible silicone, which is the key to its easy release. A separate base supports the silicone tray while you fill it, carry it to the freezer, and store it. That base is a practical touch, since a floppy silicone tray can spill water on the way to the freezer. The cover helps protect the ice from freezer odors and lets you stack several trays, which saves space on crowded shelves.

Many owners appreciate that the base and cover make the tray easy to handle from start to finish. Filling it, moving it, and storing it all feel more controlled than with a loose silicone tray. The trade-off is that six cubes is a small yield compared with the 28-cube sets on this list. You will need to fill it more often if you host guests or keep a large ice supply on hand.

When you compare this model with the Tovolo set, the difference is clear. The OXO gives you fewer, bigger cubes with better handling accessories. The Tovolo gives you more, smaller cubes for coffee and cocktails. If your main goal is a sturdy, tidy tray that makes premium-looking ice for a few drinks at a time, this is the stronger option.

Pros:

• Large 1¾-inch cubes melt slowly and suit spirits well
• A supportive base makes filling and transporting the tray easier
• The cover helps block freezer odors and allows stacking
• Labeled as dishwasher safe for simple cleanup

Cons:

• Only six cubes per tray means it may not keep up with larger groups

Verdict: The OXO is the best pick if you want large, slow-melting cubes and a well-built tray with a base and cover. It is less suited to anyone who needs high ice output for a crowd.

Amazon Basics Large Square Silicone Trays for Freezer Use Beyond Ice

The Amazon Basics set is a good choice if you want trays that do more than make ice. The listing points to uses such as frozen pudding, cake, biscuits, and chocolate, so these molds can serve as small portioning tools in the kitchen. Each tray measures 4.25 x 4.25 x 1.77 inches, which gives you a generous square shape. The black silicone is simple and unfussy, and the set is marketed as freezer, refrigerator, and dishwasher safe.

The design includes a non-slip quality that helps the trays sit steady on counters and tables. That matters when you are moving a full tray in and out of the freezer, since a sliding tray can spill. The molds are also stackable, which helps when your freezer shelves are already packed. The listing does not specify a cube count per tray, so you should check the product details before you buy if you need a particular yield.

In practical use, these trays are a strong fit for families or cooks who like to freeze homemade treats and sauces in measured portions. The square shape and larger footprint also make them suitable for bigger ice cubes. Some owners may find the trays a little bulky for a small freezer, but the stacking design helps reduce the space they take. Because the molds are more versatile than a dedicated ice tray, they make sense for people who want one set to cover several jobs.

Compared with the Tovolo or Amytor sets, this option is less focused on drink-ready ice and more focused on general freezer use. If you want a tray that works well for cocktails and also handles frozen desserts or purees, the Amazon Basics set offers flexibility. If you want a covered tray with lids for odor protection, the Amytor or OXO is a better match.

Pros:

• Versatile molds that work for ice, frozen treats, and portioned foods
• Non-slip design helps keep trays stable on counters
• Stackable shape saves freezer space
• Marketed as dishwasher, refrigerator, and freezer safe

Cons:

• The listing does not state a cube count per tray, which makes yield harder to plan

Verdict: The Amazon Basics set is a sensible choice for cooks who want one flexible, dishwasher-safe mold set for more than just ice. Those who only need covered ice cubes may prefer a model with lids.

Tovolo Perfect Cube Trays for Smaller Cubes and Cocktail Use

The Tovolo Perfect Cube set is built for drinks that need uniform, clean-looking ice. This two-tray pack makes 30 cubes in total, with 15 square cavities per tray. Each cube measures 1.25 inches, a size the listing positions for whiskey cocktails and iced coffee. The trays are charcoal in color, and the silicone is described as food-grade and BPA free.

Having two trays is a practical advantage. You can keep one batch freezing while you use ice from the other, which is handy when you are hosting or making drinks all evening. The listing describes the silicone as fade resistant and says it keeps its flexibility through repeated freezing. That matters because brittle or cracked molds are a common frustration, and flexible silicone is more forgiving to handle over time. Release is simple, as you twist the tray gently to pop out individual cubes while the rest stay frozen.

The listing says the trays can go in the dishwasher, or be rinsed with a mix of water and vinegar. Having both options makes upkeep easy for busy households. In everyday use, smaller cubes chill drinks quickly, so they fit coffee, iced tea, and smoothies well. The trade-off is that small cubes melt faster than the large ones from the OXO, so spirit drinkers may want larger shapes for slow dilution.

Compared with the 14-ice sets from Amytor and UrbAmerican, this pack gives you more cubes and a more focused use case. You do not get lids, so odor protection depends on how you store the trays. If you care most about cube count and drink-friendly size, the Tovolo is a very strong option. If you want covered storage, a lidded set will serve you better.

Pros:

• Two trays provide 30 cubes, which suits entertaining
• The 1.25-inch cubes work well for coffee, cocktails, and iced drinks
• Flexible silicone supports easy release and fade-resistant use
• Dishwasher safe, with a vinegar-and-water rinse as an alternative

Cons:

• No lids are included, so the ice is less protected from freezer odors

Verdict: The Tovolo set is a top choice for anyone who wants plenty of uniform, drink-sized cubes and two trays to rotate between. Choose a lidded model instead if covered storage is a priority.

UrbAmerican Silicone Trays With Lids for Simple Stacking

The UrbAmerican set is a close relative of the Amytor option. It is a two-pack that yields 28 cubes in total, and each tray has a removable lid for covered storage and stacking. The materials are described as silicone and PP, and the product is labeled as BPA free. Like the Amytor set, the listing recommends boiling the trays for about 30 minutes before first use, then filling them with pure water.

What sets this listing apart is its emphasis on easy release. The flexible silicone base is meant to let you pop cubes out without much effort, which is the most important performance point for any ice tray. The lids also help keep stored ice clean and reduce the chance of it picking up freezer odors, while making the trays easy to stack. Cleanup is flexible, since the trays can be rinsed by hand or washed in the dishwasher and then air dried.

In everyday use, this set suits people who want a simple, covered tray for regular drinks and entertaining without spending much time on setup. The cube size is a standard shape rather than a premium oversized one, so it works well for everyday drinks and less well for slow-melting spirit service. Because the design closely mirrors the Amytor set, most of the decision comes down to which brand listing feels more appealing and which price point suits your budget.

Among the five options, this set is a dependable, no-frills pick. It offers the same practical strengths as the Amytor model, including covered storage, stackable trays, and dishwasher-safe cleanup. It lacks the premium look of the OXO or the cocktail-focused sizing of the Tovolo, but it covers the basics well for most kitchens.

Pros:

• Removable lids help protect ice and allow neat freezer stacking
• Flexible silicone base supports easy cube release
• Two trays provide 28 cubes for everyday and party use
• Dishwasher safe, with hand-rinse cleaning as an option

Cons:

• The recommended boil-in-water setup step adds time before first use

Verdict: The UrbAmerican set is a solid, practical choice for anyone who wants covered, stackable silicone trays that release cubes easily. It is a sensible alternative to the Amytor model, and a good fit for everyday ice needs.

How to Choose the Right Dishwasher-Safe Silicone Ice Cube Tray

Cube Size and How Fast Your Drinks Will Melt

Cube size affects both the look and the taste of your drinks more than most shoppers expect. Large cubes, such as the 1¾-inch cubes from the OXO tray, melt slowly. That makes them a good match for whiskey, bourbon, and other spirits that you want to sip without much dilution. Smaller cubes, like the 1.25-inch cubes from the Tovolo set, chill drinks quickly and fit well into coffee cups and tall glasses. Before you buy, think about what you drink most often. A tray that fits your glasses and your drinking habits will get more use than one that looks impressive but does not match your routine.

Cube Count and Batch Planning

Cube count determines how often you need to refill your trays, and that matters when you host. A six-cube tray can work for a couple of drinks in the evening, but it will feel slow for a party. Two-tray sets like the Tovolo, with 30 cubes, let you rotate batches so that one set is always freezing while the other is in use. The Amytor and UrbAmerican sets offer 28 cubes across two trays, which is a good middle ground for families. Count your typical use, then add a little extra for guests. This simple step helps you avoid buying too few trays or more than your freezer can comfortably hold.

Lids, Stacking, and Freezer Odors

Lids are a practical feature that many shoppers overlook until they open a freezer and find ice that smells like last week’s leftovers. A covered tray helps block odors and dust, and it lets you stack filled trays without spilling. The Amytor, UrbAmerican, and OXO options all include covers, which makes them a good fit for crowded freezers. The Tovolo set does not include lids, so you will need to store it carefully or use a separate container to keep the ice fresh. If your freezer is small or shared by the whole household, covered storage is worth prioritizing.

Silicone Quality and Release Performance

The main job of a silicone tray is to release cubes cleanly. Look for a flexible base that bends easily and separates each cube from its neighbors. Many of the trays here use individual compartments, so you can push one cube out from the bottom without disturbing the rest. Material labels also matter. Several listings mention food-grade or BPA-free silicone, and that is a useful indicator of quality. Some listings also recommend boiling the trays before first use, which is a common step for new silicone molds. Following the maker’s instructions will help you get the best performance and the longest life from your tray.

Dishwasher Safety and Cleaning Routine

Dishwasher safety is a major reason many people choose silicone over rigid plastic. Every product in this guide is listed as dishwasher safe, which makes cleanup quick after a party or a busy week. The Tovolo set also offers a water-and-vinegar rinse, which is useful if you prefer hand cleaning or want to remove residue from hard water. Whatever method you choose, dry the trays fully before stacking or storing them. Moisture left in lids and seams can lead to odors over time. A simple routine of washing, drying, and storing the trays in a dry spot keeps them in good shape for longer.

Versatility Beyond Ice

Some silicone trays are designed only for ice, while others can handle a wider range of kitchen tasks. The Amazon Basics square molds are described for frozen pudding, cake, biscuits, and chocolate, which makes them a flexible addition to a freezer drawer. If you like to freeze sauces, purees, or herbs in measured portions, a versatile mold can save you from buying extra kitchen tools. If you only need ice, a purpose-built tray with a lid may be the better buy. Consider how many jobs you want one set to handle before you decide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are silicone ice cube trays really dishwasher safe?

All five trays in this guide are listed as dishwasher safe, which is one of their biggest advantages. Silicone holds up well to the heat and detergent of a dishwasher cycle, so cleanup is quick. Still, check the care details that come with your specific tray, and dry the trays completely before storing them to prevent odors.

Should I boil new silicone ice trays before using them?

Some listings, including the Amytor and UrbAmerican sets, recommend boiling the trays for about 30 minutes before the first use. This step is a common practice for new silicone molds and is meant to prepare the material before it touches food or drinks. Following the product’s instructions is the safest approach, and it takes only a few minutes of effort.

Do covered ice cube trays keep ice fresher?

A lid helps block freezer odors and dust, which can improve the taste of your ice over time. It also makes stacking easier and reduces the chance of spills when you move a full tray. Covered trays are especially useful in shared freezers or small kitchens where space is tight.

Which tray is best for whiskey and other spirits?

The OXO covered tray is the strongest choice for spirits because it produces large 1¾-inch cubes that melt slowly. Slower melting keeps your drink from becoming watery too quickly. The Tovolo set also works for cocktails, but its smaller 1.25-inch cubes chill drinks faster, which suits coffee and iced drinks better.

How many ice cubes do I need for a party?

A good rule is to plan for several cubes per guest per hour, then adjust for the size of your drinks and how many people stay for the evening. The two-tray sets from Tovolo, Amytor, and UrbAmerican offer 30 or 28 cubes, which can cover small gatherings with some refilling. For larger groups, you will likely want to rotate multiple sets or plan for a second batch.

Can I use silicone trays for foods other than ice?

Yes, many silicone trays can hold purees, sauces, herbs, juice, and small frozen portions. The Amazon Basics square molds are specifically described for frozen pudding, cake, biscuits, and chocolate, which makes them a good fit for broader kitchen use. Check each product’s listing for its intended uses, and choose a tray that matches what you plan to freeze.

Which silicone ice tray should I buy?

For most households, the Amytor set is a practical starting point because it combines covered storage, stackable design, 28 cubes, and dishwasher-safe cleaning. If you prefer large cubes for spirits, the OXO covered tray is the better buy, while the Tovolo set is ideal for smaller cubes and frequent entertaining. Budget-minded shoppers will find the UrbAmerican set a close match to the Amytor model. Think about your cube size, your freezer space, and how often you host, and the right choice will become clear.

Final Recommendation

For the best all-around pick, choose the Amytor set. It offers covered, stackable trays, 28 cubes in total, and dishwasher-safe cleaning, which covers most everyday needs. If you want large, slow-melting cubes for whiskey and other spirits, the OXO covered tray is the most refined choice. Entertainers who want the most cubes and a rotating two-tray system should consider the Tovolo set, while the Amazon Basics molds suit anyone who wants a versatile freezer tool. The UrbAmerican set is a dependable alternative with a simple design and easy release. Match the cube size, lid feature, and cube count to your habits, and you will end up with a tray that fits your kitchen well.