Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Mattresses & Toppers

Best Thick Memory Foam Mattress Topper: 5-Inch Picks Compared

Updated 10 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 10minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

A thick memory foam mattress topper can add substantial cushioning to a mattress that feels too firm, but a taller profile is not automatically better for every bed or sleeper. The options below are all listed as 5-inch designs, with differences in fill, fit, breathability, and care. Compare those details with your mattress and comfort needs before choosing.

Quick Comparison

ProductDesignNotable featureAvailability note
SHOUREN 5-Inch Queen Memory Foam TopperGel and shredded foamFour corner straps and dot quiltingMarked available in supplied product data
SHOUREN 5-Inch Full Memory Foam TopperGel and shredded memory foamBreathable sides and 8–21-inch fit rangeMarked unavailable in supplied product data
NightHug 5-Inch Queen Mattress TopperShredded memory foam and down-alternative fillCotton top and deep-pocket designMarked available in supplied product data
SurChic 5-Inch Dual-Layer Queen TopperFoam layers with a plush pillow topRemovable, machine-washable coverMarked available in supplied product data
ELNIDO QUEEN 5-Inch Queen Memory Foam TopperSlow-rebound and gel memory foamFour straps and CertiPUR-US foam claimMarked available in supplied product data

Our Picks: Best Thick Memory Foam Mattress Topper reviews

1. SHOUREN 5-Inch Queen Topper: A Contouring Foam Blend

This SHOUREN topper combines gel memory foam with supportive shredded foam in a 5-inch profile. The design is intended to add a plush, body-contouring layer while keeping some support beneath your hips, shoulders, and back. That mix may appeal if your mattress feels firm and you want a deeper cushion than a thin pad can provide.

Dot quilting is designed to help keep the filling evenly distributed, while four elastic corner straps help hold the topper in place. The straps are a practical feature for sleepers who move around during the night, though the topper’s depth may make an already-tall mattress feel even higher.

The supplied product information recommends allowing 24–48 hours for the compressed topper to expand. This pick has a queen-size option and a straightforward foam-focused design. The description does not specify a removable or washable cover, so plan to use a fitted sheet or mattress protector for surface care.

Pros:

  • Combines gel memory foam and shredded foam.
  • Full 5-inch profile adds substantial cushioning.
  • Four corner straps help limit shifting.
  • Dot quilting is designed to keep filling in place.

Cons:

  • Its added height may not suit every bed setup.
  • The description does not list a removable, washable cover.

Verdict: Choose this SHOUREN model if you want a thick, foam-based queen topper with corner straps and an emphasis on contouring comfort.

2. SHOUREN 5-Inch Full Topper: Breathable Sides and Quilted Fill

This full-size SHOUREN topper uses soft gel memory foam and shredded memory foam in a 5-inch padded design. Its top is described as soft polyester, with breathable mesh fabric on both sides to encourage airflow. Dot quilting helps hold the filling in place and adds a gently cushioned surface.

Four elastic bands are designed for mattresses from 8 to 21 inches deep, giving this model a broad stated fit range. The topper is vacuum-compressed for shipping, and the product information advises patting it gently and allowing two to three days for it to regain its intended shape.

One important buying detail: the supplied product data marks this item as unavailable. Availability can change, so check the listing before making plans to buy. If it is in stock, its full size and breathable side panels make it a possible fit for someone who wants a thick foam blend with a quilted surface.

Pros:

  • 5-inch combination of gel and shredded memory foam.
  • Mesh sides are designed to support airflow.
  • Four corner bands fit the stated 8–21-inch mattress range.

Cons:

  • Marked unavailable in the supplied product data.
  • May need two to three days to fully expand.

Verdict: Consider this full-size option if it becomes available and you want a thick, quilted foam topper with breathable side panels.

3. NightHug 5-Inch Queen Topper: Plush Fill with a Deep Pocket

NightHug takes a layered approach, using shredded memory foam and down-alternative fill in a 5-inch queen topper. The foam is intended to contour to the body, while the softer fill adds a plush pillow-top feel. This blend may suit you if you want cushioning but prefer a padded surface over a topper made only from a solid foam slab.

The cover has a 100% cotton top and 3D air-mesh sides, which the product description says are designed to help airflow and moisture move away from the sleep surface. Its 15-inch extended deep-pocket design is stated to fit mattresses from 8 to 21 inches, with elastic around the edge to help hold the topper in place.

The trade-off is that its mixed fill may feel different from a more uniform memory foam layer, and the supplied details do not mention a removable or washable cover. It arrives compressed and may need gentle fluffing and up to 24 hours to expand.

Pros:

  • Combines shredded memory foam with down-alternative fill.
  • Cotton top and mesh sides are designed to support breathability.
  • Deep-pocket design fits the stated 8–21-inch mattress range.
  • Quilted checkerboard pattern adds texture to the surface.

Cons:

  • The plush mixed-fill feel may not suit shoppers seeking a uniform foam surface.
  • The description does not specify a removable, washable cover.

Verdict: Pick the NightHug if you want a thick queen topper with a plush, padded feel and a deep-pocket fit.

4. SurChic 5-Inch Dual-Layer Topper: A Removable Cover for Easier Care

This SurChic queen topper is described as a 5-inch dual-layer design combining a supportive foam base, cooling memory foam, and a plush pillow top. The layered construction aims to add cushioning while retaining a more supportive feel underneath. Its description highlights pressure relief around the shoulders, hips, and lower back, but comfort and pain relief can vary from person to person.

A 360-degree elastic skirt is designed to fit mattresses from 8 to 21 inches deep and help limit bunching. The product description also lists CertiPUR-US certified foam and an OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified pillow top. Its removable cover is described as machine washable; that care detail applies to the cover, not necessarily the foam layers.

This is the most care-focused option in the group based on the supplied product details. As with other compressed toppers, it needs 24–48 hours to expand. Check the care instructions before washing the cover, and make sure your fitted sheet can accommodate the added height.

Pros:

  • Layered construction combines foam support with a plush pillow top.
  • Removable cover is described as machine washable.
  • 360-degree elastic skirt fits the stated 8–21-inch mattress range.
  • Product information lists CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX certifications.

Cons:

  • Its layered, padded feel may be too plush for shoppers who want a firmer surface.
  • Needs time to expand after unpacking.

Verdict: Choose SurChic if easier cover care and a layered pillow-top feel matter more to you than a simple foam-only design.

5. ELNIDO QUEEN 5-Inch Topper: Gel Foam with a Secure Strap Fit

This ELNIDO QUEEN model combines slow-rebound foam and gel memory foam in a 5-inch queen topper. Its description presents the design as a balance of plushness and deeper support for different sleeping positions. It may be worth considering if you want a thick foam layer to soften a firm or aging mattress, rather than replace it.

The topper has a breathable polyester cover and an air-circulation foam layer, along with four elastic straps designed for mattresses from 8 to 21 inches deep. Fan-shaped quilting is intended to keep the fill evenly distributed. The supplied description states that the foam is CertiPUR-US certified and recommends allowing 24–48 hours for expansion.

The product description makes broad comfort claims for side, back, and stomach sleepers, but a thick topper can change how deeply you sink and may not suit every sleeping position. Its listed use cases include dorms, RVs, guest rooms, and camping, though you should check the available sleeping space and bed dimensions before buying.

Pros:

  • Combines slow-rebound foam and gel memory foam.
  • Four straps fit the stated 8–21-inch mattress range.
  • Quilting is designed to help keep the fill evenly distributed.
  • Product information states that the foam is CertiPUR-US certified.

Cons:

  • A 5-inch layer may noticeably change the mattress height and feel.
  • Requires time to expand after unpacking.

Verdict: The ELNIDO QUEEN is a strong fit to consider if you want a thick gel-and-slow-rebound foam blend with corner straps and a broad stated mattress-depth range.

How to Choose a Thick Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Match the topper to your mattress size and depth

Start with the exact mattress size, then measure its depth, including any existing pad or protector if those will stay in place. A topper that is too small can leave areas uncovered, while a deep mattress may need a generous skirt or straps to keep the layer secure. Several options here state a fit range of 8 to 21 inches, but check the current product listing and measure your own bed before ordering.

Think about how much cushioning you want

A 5-inch topper adds a substantial layer, so consider whether you want a softer, more cushioned surface or simply a small change in firmness. Foam blends, shredded foam, and pillow-top layers can feel different from one another. If you prefer a more uniform contouring feel, focus on the foam construction. If you want a more padded surface, consider designs that combine foam with a plush top layer.

Consider your sleeping position and comfort needs

Side sleepers may prefer extra cushioning around the shoulders and hips, while back and stomach sleepers may want to avoid a surface that lets them sink more than is comfortable. These toppers are not medical treatments, and product claims about pain relief are not a guarantee of results. If you have ongoing pain or a health concern, speak with a qualified health professional.

Check the materials and airflow details

Memory foam can contour closely, while gel foam, mesh sides, cotton tops, and breathable covers are included in some models to support airflow. Those design features do not guarantee that a topper will keep every sleeper cool. If you tend to sleep warm, compare the cover and construction details, and consider whether the product offers more than a solid foam surface.

Look at how the topper stays in place

Corner straps, elastic skirts, and deep pockets can help reduce shifting, but they need to fit your mattress. If you share a bed or move often during sleep, secure attachment may matter more to you. A very thick topper can also make fitted sheets harder to fit, so check your sheet depth as well as the topper’s attachment design.

Plan for setup and care

Many toppers arrive compressed and need time to regain their full shape. Follow the specific product’s setup instructions and allow the listed expansion time before judging its feel. Check whether the cover is removable and washable; that does not mean the foam itself can be washed. A mattress protector can help keep the sleep surface clean, but confirm that it fits over the added height.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a 5-inch mattress topper too thick?

That depends on your mattress, sleeping position, and comfort preference. Five inches adds a noticeable layer, which may be helpful if you want substantial cushioning but can make the bed taller and change how deeply you sink. Check your fitted-sheet depth and available bed clearance before choosing one.

Can a thick memory foam topper help with back pain?

A topper may change pressure and comfort on a mattress that feels too firm, but it cannot guarantee pain relief or treat a medical condition. The best feel varies by person, and persistent back pain should be discussed with a qualified health professional.

How long does a compressed topper take to expand?

It varies by model. The supplied product details recommend anywhere from about 24 hours to two or three days for these options. Follow the instructions that come with the specific topper and give it the full recommended time before assessing its shape.

Will a 5-inch topper fit under regular fitted sheets?

It may not, especially if your mattress is already deep. Measure the combined height of your mattress, topper, and any protector, then check the pocket depth of your fitted sheets.

Are memory foam toppers washable?

Do not assume the foam can be machine washed. The SurChic description specifies a removable, machine-washable cover, while the other supplied product details do not list a washable cover. Check the care instructions for the exact model before cleaning it.

Which topper is best for a hot sleeper?

Compare the airflow features rather than relying on a “cooling” label alone. The SHOUREN full topper lists mesh sides, NightHug lists a cotton top and mesh sides, and other models describe gel foam or breathable materials. Individual comfort can still vary.

What is the best thick memory foam mattress topper in this guide?

For a simple gel-and-shredded-foam blend with four corner straps, the SHOUREN queen model is a practical choice. If you value a removable, machine-washable cover, consider SurChic. If you prefer a padded mix of foam and down-alternative fill, compare the NightHug’s construction and deep-pocket fit with your mattress dimensions.

Final Recommendation

For a straightforward thick foam option, the SHOUREN 5-inch queen topper offers a gel-and-shredded-foam blend with corner straps. SurChic stands out for its removable, machine-washable cover, while NightHug offers a more padded mixed-fill design. Before ordering, confirm the size, mattress depth, sheet fit, and care details—and allow for expansion after unpacking.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment