Your Modern LivingPractical guides for everyday living

Cookware & Kitchen Tools

Best Griddle Tops For Gas Grills: Top Picks Compared and Reviewed

Updated 10 min read

Reader-supported: when you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Guide at a glance

  • 5products compared
  • 10minute read
  • Side-by-side comparison table
  • Who each pick suits best
  • What to check before you buy

A griddle top lets you cook foods that can fall through grill grates—such as eggs, pancakes, chopped vegetables, and small pieces of seafood—on your gas grill. The options below vary in size, material, coating, and handle design, so the right choice depends on your grill’s cooking area and how much food you want to make at once. Measure your grill before buying, and treat “universal fit” as a starting point rather than a guarantee.

Quick Comparison

Griddle topCooking surfaceMaterial or coatingBest for
BBQ Future Cast Iron Griddle23 x 16 inchesPre-seasoned cast ironA large cooking area and included spatulas
Uniflasy Cast Iron Griddle23 x 16 inchesCast iron with matte porcelain enamelLarge-batch cooking and a coated surface
Utheer 17 x 13-Inch Griddle17 x 13 inchesPre-seasoned, nonstick surfaceCompact grills and removable handles
QuliMetal 25 x 16-Inch Griddle25 x 16 inchesCast iron with nano-ceramic coatingCooking for a crowd on a large grill
Barbqtime 17 x 13-Inch Griddle17 x 13 inchesNonstick-coated steelA smaller, lighter-material option with handles

Our Picks: Best Griddle Tops For Gas Grills reviews

BBQ Future Cast Iron Griddle: A Large Surface with Included Tools

The BBQ Future griddle has a 23-by-16-inch cast-iron cooking surface and comes with three stainless-steel spatulas. It is designed to sit on a grill or other listed cooking surfaces, with side handles for moving it and raised edges to help keep food on the plate.

The large surface can make it easier to cook several breakfast items or burgers at once. Cast iron is a substantial material that retains heat well, but it can also be heavy to lift. The listing describes the griddle as pre-seasoned while also recommending seasoning it before first use; plan to follow the care instructions and season it as needed.

A full-width grease tray is intended to collect drippings and help limit flare-ups. Compared with the smaller Utheer and Barbqtime options, this one offers more room but requires more grill space and storage space. Check the grill’s usable cooking area and the griddle’s fit before ordering.

Pros:

  • Large 23-by-16-inch cooking surface
  • Cast-iron construction with heat-retaining properties
  • Includes three stainless-steel spatulas
  • Raised edges, side handles, and a grease tray

Cons:

  • Its large cast-iron plate may be heavy to handle
  • Requires care to keep the cast iron protected from rust

Verdict: Choose the BBQ Future if you want a roomy cast-iron griddle and value having spatulas included, provided your grill can accommodate its footprint.

Uniflasy Cast Iron Griddle: Enamel Coating for Larger Cookouts

This Uniflasy griddle measures 23 by 16 inches, with a listed height of 2.6 inches. It combines cast iron with a matte porcelain enamel coating, which the product description presents as a nonstick surface intended to make cooking and cleanup easier.

Its size suits cooks who want to prepare several foods at once rather than work in small batches. The listing also describes reinforced ribs on the back to help resist warping. It names a range of compatible grills, including some Weber Genesis II, Nexgrill, and Char-Broil models, but model fit can vary—measure your grill and check its clearance before purchase.

Compared with the BBQ Future, the Uniflasy offers a coated surface but does not list included spatulas. Its cast-iron construction also means you should consider the effort involved in lifting and storing a large plate. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for cleaning and handling the enamel coating.

Pros:

  • Large 23-by-16-inch cooking area
  • Matte porcelain enamel coating
  • Reinforced ribs are designed to help resist warping
  • Listed for use on several grills and cooking surfaces

Cons:

  • Large cast-iron size may be cumbersome to store or move
  • Compatibility should be checked against your exact grill model

Verdict: The Uniflasy is a good option to consider if you want a large cast-iron griddle with an enamel-coated surface and your grill has enough room for it.

Utheer 17 x 13-Inch Griddle: Compact with Removable Handles

The Utheer is a smaller griddle insert measuring 17 by 13 inches, making it worth considering if a full-size plate would crowd your grill. Its nonstick surface is described as pre-seasoned, and the listing gives a maximum temperature rating of 500°F.

A grease groove and raised edges help contain drippings and food while you cook. The handles are removable and reversible; with handles installed, the griddle measures 19.1 inches in total length. That detail matters if your grill has limited clearance or if you want to reduce the space it takes up while cooking.

This is a more compact choice than the two 23-by-16-inch cast-iron options and the larger QuliMetal. The smaller surface means less room for cooking multiple foods at once, but the manageable footprint may suit smaller grills, camping, or tailgating. The listing recommends hand washing, drying thoroughly, and storing it in a dry place.

Pros:

  • Compact 17-by-13-inch cooking surface
  • Removable, reversible handles
  • Raised edges and a grease groove
  • Listed for use on gas and charcoal grills

Cons:

  • Smaller cooking area than the large-format picks
  • Has a listed maximum temperature of 500°F

Verdict: Pick the Utheer if grill space and storage are priorities, and its smaller cooking area is enough for your usual meals.

QuliMetal 25 x 16-Inch Griddle: The Largest Surface in This Lineup

At 25 by 16 inches, the QuliMetal has the largest stated cooking surface among these picks. It is made from cast iron with a nano-ceramic coating, and the listing says the coating is food-grade and free of PFOA and PFAS. It also specifies a maximum safe temperature of 550°F.

The wide surface is designed for cooking several items together, which can be useful for a family meal or a gathering. A built-in grease trough helps collect drippings, and a reinforced crossbar is intended to help resist warping. The product description lists compatibility with several grill brands, but its 25-inch width makes measuring especially important.

The QuliMetal is a larger alternative to the 23-by-16-inch BBQ Future and Uniflasy griddles. Its advertised surface coating may appeal if you want a coated cooking surface, but it still has a cast-iron body. Consider how you will lift and store it, and follow the manufacturer’s instructions for temperature and care.

Pros:

  • Largest listed surface in this selection at 25 by 16 inches
  • Cast-iron construction with nano-ceramic coating
  • Built-in grease trough
  • Listed temperature limit of 550°F

Cons:

  • May not fit smaller grills because of its width
  • Large cast-iron construction can be difficult to move and store

Verdict: The QuliMetal is the one to consider for high-volume cooking if your grill has enough space and you are comfortable handling a large cast-iron plate.

Barbqtime 17 x 13-Inch Griddle: A Coated Steel Option

The Barbqtime is a 17-by-13-inch flat-top plate made from nonstick-coated steel rather than cast iron. Its listing describes polished edges, high sidewalls, a built-in grease trough, and detachable side handles. The smaller footprint can suit a grill where a wide griddle would take up too much room.

The product description lists a broad range of grill brands and several specific models. That list can help narrow down fit, but it is not a substitute for checking your grill’s usable surface and lid clearance. The listing also recommends preheating the plate and adding oil before cooking to help limit sticking.

Compared with the Utheer, the Barbqtime also has a compact 17-by-13-inch surface, but it uses coated steel instead of a pre-seasoned surface. The listing does not give a temperature rating, so check the product instructions for heat and care guidance before use.

Pros:

  • Compact 17-by-13-inch cooking area
  • Coated-steel construction
  • Detachable handles and a built-in grease trough
  • Raised sides help keep food on the plate

Cons:

  • Smaller surface than the large griddle options
  • The listing does not specify a maximum temperature

Verdict: Consider the Barbqtime if you want a compact coated-steel griddle with detachable handles, but confirm its fit and follow its heat-care instructions.

How to Choose a Griddle Top for a Gas Grill

Measure Your Grill Before Choosing a Size

Measure the usable cooking area, not just the outside width of the grill. Check the griddle’s full dimensions, including handles, and consider whether the lid can close with the plate in place. A griddle should sit securely without blocking areas needed for airflow. The listed dimensions are a starting point; grill shapes and layouts vary.

Match the Surface Area to Your Cooking Plans

A larger griddle gives you more room to cook several foods at the same time, but it needs a larger grill and more storage space. The 23-by-16-inch and 25-by-16-inch options are geared toward bigger meals. The 17-by-13-inch models may make more sense for a smaller grill, occasional use, or cooking for fewer people.

Consider the Material and Coating

Cast iron is known for holding heat, but a large cast-iron plate can be heavy to lift. Some of the options have an enamel or ceramic-style coating, while the BBQ Future and Utheer are described as pre-seasoned. Coatings and seasoning have different care needs, so read the included instructions rather than assuming every surface should be cleaned or treated the same way.

Check Heat Limits and Grill Use

Look for a stated temperature limit and follow it. The Utheer listing gives a maximum of 500°F, while QuliMetal specifies 550°F. The other product descriptions here do not provide a clear maximum temperature. Do not assume that every griddle is suited to any burner setting or cooking method, and check the manufacturer’s guidance before heating it.

Think About Grease Control and Raised Edges

Grease grooves, troughs, and trays can collect drippings as you cook. Raised edges can help keep chopped foods on the flat surface while you stir or flip them. These features do not replace careful heat management: grease can still create flare-ups, so keep an eye on the grill and use the griddle as directed.

Plan for Handling, Cleaning, and Storage

Handles can make a griddle easier to move, but they may affect clearance or take up storage space. The Utheer’s handles are removable and reversible, and the Barbqtime has detachable handles. Always let the griddle cool before moving it, use suitable heat protection, and follow the product’s cleaning and drying instructions. Cast iron in particular should be stored dry and cared for to help prevent rust.

Check the Exact Grill Model for Compatibility

“Universal” means a product is intended to fit a range of grills, not that it will fit every model. Compare the griddle’s dimensions with your grill, then check any model-specific compatibility information in the product listing. If a snug fit matters, use your grill’s manual or manufacturer information to confirm the cooking-area measurements.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use a griddle top on any gas grill?

Not necessarily. Some griddle tops are listed as universal, but dimensions, grill shape, lid clearance, and airflow can affect fit. Measure your grill and check the product’s compatibility information before buying.

Which size should I choose?

Choose a size that fits the usable cooking area and matches how much food you make. The 17-by-13-inch options take up less space, while the 23-by-16-inch and 25-by-16-inch plates provide more room for cooking several items at once.

Do cast-iron griddle tops need seasoning?

Care depends on the surface and the manufacturer’s instructions. BBQ Future describes its cast-iron griddle as pre-seasoned but also recommends seasoning it before first use. Follow the specific instructions for your model, and keep cast iron dry when storing it.

Can I cook eggs and pancakes on a grill griddle?

Yes. A flat surface is suited to foods such as eggs and pancakes that would be hard to cook directly on grill grates. Preheat the griddle as directed and use the amount of oil recommended for its surface.

What is the advantage of a grease groove or trough?

A groove or trough gives grease and drippings a place to collect instead of leaving them across the cooking area. It can help with grease control, but it does not eliminate the need to watch for flare-ups or clean the griddle as directed.

Are removable handles useful?

They can help with storage and may provide extra clearance during cooking. The Utheer handles are removable and reversible, and the Barbqtime has detachable handles. Check the dimensions with the handles installed as well as removed.

How do I clean a coated griddle top?

Cleaning instructions vary by product and coating. Let the griddle cool, then follow the manufacturer’s directions. For example, the Utheer listing calls for hand washing, thorough drying, and dry storage. Avoid assuming that care instructions for one surface apply to another.

Final Recommendation

For a roomy cast-iron griddle with spatulas included, the BBQ Future is a strong place to start. If you want the largest stated cooking surface, consider the QuliMetal—but only if your grill can accommodate its 25-inch width. For a more compact option, compare the Utheer’s removable handles with the Barbqtime’s coated-steel construction. Whichever you choose, confirm the dimensions and care instructions before your first cook.

Author

  • Emily

    Emily is the editor of YourModernLiving, where she helps readers make informed decisions about home, kitchen, family, and everyday products. She focuses on researching product features, comparing available options, and creating practical buying guides to help readers find products that suit their needs, preferences, and budgets.

Leave a Comment