A silicone ice cube tray with a cover can help keep ice protected from freezer odors and make it easier to stack trays in a crowded freezer. The right pick depends on the ice you want: large cubes for slower-melting drinks, or smaller cubes when you need more pieces at once. These five options include both styles, with details on capacity, covers, and handling to help you choose.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Pack and capacity | Cube size | Standout feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| VLM 3-Pack Large Ice Cube Molds | 3 trays; 18 cubes total | 2-inch cubes | Sturdy internal frame and removable lids |
| Vethwal 3-Pack Silicone Ice Cube Trays | 3 trays; 45 cubes total | 1.2-inch cubes | Compact cubes and lids with hanging holes |
| KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray | 2 trays; 12 cubes total | 2-inch cubes | Slow-melting cubes and stackable lids |
| GGUW 3-Pack Large Ice Cube Trays | 3 trays; 18 cubes total | 2-inch cubes | Silicone-wrapped steel frame |
| FDDBI 2-Pack Large Ice Cube Trays | 2 trays; 12 cubes total | 2-inch cubes | Framed design for filling and carrying |
Our Picks: Best Silicone Ice Cube Tray With Cover reviews
1. VLM 3-Pack: A Practical Pick for Large, Slow-Melting Cubes
This three-tray set makes up to 18 square ice cubes at once, with six cavities per tray. Each cube measures about two inches, making this a good fit for drinks where you want a substantial piece of ice that melts more slowly than smaller cubes.
The flexible silicone cavities are designed for push-from-the-bottom release, and each tray has an internal frame for added stability. That frame and the handle are useful details when carrying a filled tray from the sink to the freezer. Removable lids help protect ice from freezer odors and let the trays stack neatly.
The large cube format is less suited to situations where you need many small pieces or want ice to chill a drink quickly. But for whiskey, cocktails, and other drinks served with a single large cube, the VLM offers more total capacity than the two-tray options below.
Pros:
- Makes 18 large cubes across three trays
- Internal frame and handle support filling and transport
- Removable lids help shield ice from freezer odors
- Flexible cavities support push-to-release removal
Cons:
- Two-inch cubes take up more room in a glass than smaller cubes
- Large cavities may not suit people who want ice in smaller portions
Verdict: Choose the VLM set if you want a generous supply of large cubes and value a framed tray that is easier to carry when filled.
2. Vethwal 3-Pack: Smaller Cubes for Everyday Drinks
Unlike the other picks here, the Vethwal trays make smaller 1.2-inch cubes. Each tray has 15 cavities, so the three-pack can make up to 45 cubes at a time. That higher piece count can be useful for chilling several drinks or keeping a supply ready for juices, soda, coffee, and cocktails.
The trays use flexible, food-grade silicone and have removable lids. The lids are described as stackable and include small holes for hanging storage. The smaller cubes also take up less room in a glass than the two-inch options, though they are not designed for the same slow-melting effect as large cocktail ice.
The product description lists dishwasher, microwave, and refrigerator use. For shoppers focused mainly on drinks, the key trade-off is straightforward: this set prioritizes a greater number of smaller cubes over the oversized format used by the other four picks.
Pros:
- Makes up to 45 cubes across three trays
- Smaller 1.2-inch cubes suit a range of everyday drinks
- Removable lids help protect ice and allow stacking
- Lids have holes for hanging storage
Cons:
- Smaller cubes may melt faster than two-inch cubes
- Not the best match if you specifically want large whiskey ice
Verdict: Pick Vethwal if you prefer a larger batch of smaller cubes for everyday drinks over a few oversized, slow-melting cubes.
3. KitchFort 2-Pack: Large Cubes in a Simple Set
KitchFort supplies two trays, each with six cavities for a total of 12 two-inch cubes. The large format is intended to melt more slowly, which can help limit dilution in whiskey, bourbon, and cocktails. It can also be used for coffee, juice, or portioning foods such as purees and sauces.
The trays are made from food-grade, BPA-free silicone, with separate cavities designed to make release easier: twist the tray or push the cube up from underneath. The lids help keep the ice covered, reduce exposure to freezer odors, and allow the trays to stack. The product description also specifies dishwasher-safe cleanup.
Compared with the three-tray large-cube sets, this option makes fewer cubes at once. That smaller capacity may be enough for regular home use, but it is worth considering if you often serve a group or want several trays ready for a gathering.
Pros:
- Produces 12 large, two-inch cubes in one batch
- Food-grade, BPA-free silicone
- Lids support stacking and help keep ice covered
- Dishwasher-safe cleanup is specified
Cons:
- Two-tray set makes fewer cubes than the three-tray large-cube picks
- Large cubes may be less convenient for drinks that need several small pieces
Verdict: KitchFort is a sensible choice if you want covered, large-format ice and do not need the higher output of a three-tray set.
4. GGUW 3-Pack: Large-Cube Capacity with a Framed Design
This set includes three trays with six cavities each, producing up to 18 two-inch cubes at once. Its capacity and cube size make it a close alternative to the VLM set, with large pieces intended for whiskey, cocktails, coffee, juice, and other drinks.
Each tray has a silicone-wrapped steel frame, which is designed to add stability during filling and carrying. The independent cavities and flexible silicone are meant to make cubes easier to push out. Removable, tight-fitting lids help cover the ice and allow the trays to stack in the freezer. The trays are also described as dishwasher safe.
The main point to weigh is that the large cubes use more freezer and glass space than smaller ice. If you want a higher cube count in a compact format, the Vethwal set is a better match. For a larger supply of slow-melting cubes, GGUW offers the right capacity and a framed design.
Pros:
- Makes up to 18 two-inch cubes across three trays
- Silicone-wrapped steel frame adds stability for carrying
- Lids help protect ice and make stacking possible
- Dishwasher-safe cleanup is specified
Cons:
- Large cubes require more freezer space than smaller cubes
- Three trays may be more capacity than needed for occasional use
Verdict: Choose GGUW if you want three framed trays for making a larger batch of two-inch cubes and appreciate a design built for easier transport.
5. FDDBI 2-Pack: Framed Trays for a Smaller Supply of Big Ice
FDDBI’s two trays each have six cavities, for a total of 12 square cubes measuring two inches. Like the other large-cube options, these are meant to melt more slowly than smaller pieces and suit drinks such as whiskey, bourbon, cocktails, coffee, and juice.
The trays are made from food-grade silicone and include a silicone-wrapped steel interior rim. That frame is intended to make a filled tray easier to carry to the freezer without bending as much. The flexible cavities support push-to-release removal, while removable lids help keep ice covered and allow stacking. The product description also says the trays are dishwasher safe.
FDDBI is similar in capacity to KitchFort, but its framed design is a useful feature to consider if you are concerned about carrying a soft, water-filled silicone tray. It has fewer trays than VLM and GGUW, so it may be less convenient when you want to prepare a larger batch.
Pros:
- Makes 12 large cubes in two trays
- Silicone-wrapped frame supports filling and transport
- Removable lids help keep ice covered and allow stacking
- Flexible cavities are designed for push-to-release removal
Cons:
- Two-tray capacity is lower than the three-pack large-cube options
- Large cubes may not suit drinks that need smaller pieces
Verdict: FDDBI is worth considering if you want a framed, two-tray set for large drinks ice without needing the output of three trays.
How to Choose a Silicone Ice Cube Tray With a Cover
Choose a cube size that fits your drinks
Large cubes are a good match for whiskey and cocktails when you want ice that melts more slowly. The four large-cube options in this guide make two-inch cubes. Smaller cubes, such as the 1.2-inch pieces in the Vethwal set, give you more individual pieces per tray and can work well for everyday drinks. Think about the size of your glasses and how quickly you want a drink chilled before choosing.
Compare total capacity, not just the number of trays
Look at both the number of trays and the cavities in each one. The VLM and GGUW sets make up to 18 large cubes, while KitchFort and FDDBI make 12. Vethwal produces up to 45 smaller cubes. A higher total can be handy when preparing for guests, but a smaller set may be easier to fit in your freezer if you only need ice for a few drinks at a time.
Consider how you will fill and carry the tray
Flexible silicone helps with removing ice, but a soft tray filled with water can be harder to carry steadily. VLM, GGUW, and FDDBI describe framed designs that add stability. If your freezer is across the kitchen or you tend to fill trays at the sink, that feature may matter. A frame does not change the cube size, but it can make handling a full tray more manageable.
Check the lid design and stacking needs
A cover helps shield ice from freezer odors and can reduce the chance of spills while a tray is moved. Removable lids also make it possible to stack covered trays, which can help save freezer space. If you plan to stack them, consider where the trays will sit and whether you can place them on a flat surface while the water freezes.
Look at release and cleanup details
Many silicone trays use flexible cavities so you can twist the tray or push a cube out from underneath. Separate cavities can make it easier to release one cube at a time. If easy cleanup is a priority, check whether the product description specifically says the tray is dishwasher safe; KitchFort, GGUW, and FDDBI list this feature.
Think about other uses before buying
Several trays in this group are described for more than ice. Large cavities can be used for freezing portions of foods such as baby food, purees, sauces, or soup. If you plan to use a tray for both food and drinks, consider whether its capacity and cube size suit those portions, and keep the lid in place to help protect contents in the freezer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do silicone ice cube trays with covers help keep ice fresh?
A cover helps shield ice from freezer odors and other exposure in the freezer. It also helps keep the cubes covered when the trays are stacked. A lid does not guarantee that ice will never pick up odors, so keep the freezer and tray clean as well.
Are large ice cubes better for whiskey and cocktails?
Large cubes are designed to melt more slowly than smaller cubes, which can help limit dilution. The two-inch trays in this guide are made for that style of use. Smaller cubes can be a better fit when you want more pieces or faster chilling.
How do you remove ice from a silicone tray?
These trays are designed for flexible release. You can usually twist the tray gently or push up from the bottom of an individual cavity. Avoid forcing a cube with a sharp object, which could damage the silicone.
Can covered silicone ice trays be stacked in the freezer?
The products listed here describe their lids as stackable or say that covered trays can be stacked. For best results, place a filled tray on a level surface first so the water is less likely to spill before freezing.
Which tray makes the most cubes?
Vethwal makes up to 45 cubes across three trays, but they are smaller 1.2-inch cubes. Among the large-cube options, VLM and GGUW each make up to 18 two-inch cubes.
Can these trays be used for food as well as ice?
Several product descriptions list other uses, including freezing baby food, purees, sauces, soup, or portions of meals. Check the specific product details for material and care information before using a tray for food.
Final Recommendation
For most shoppers seeking covered trays for large, slow-melting drinks ice, the VLM 3-Pack is a strong all-around choice because it makes 18 two-inch cubes and includes a frame and handle for carrying. Choose GGUW if you want a similar large-cube capacity with a silicone-wrapped steel frame, or Vethwal if smaller cubes and a higher total count better match your everyday needs. If you only need 12 large cubes at a time, KitchFort and FDDBI offer more compact two-tray sets.